|
Electrocompaniet’s
24/192 EMC CD Player |
|
|
|
Clement Perry |
|
3 July 2002 |
Specifications
Single ended gain: 1.6X
(4dB)
Balanced gain: 3.2X
(10dB)
THD: (1V out, 1KHz) <
0,002%
Maximum output:
(Balanced) > 14V RMS
Channel separation: (1V
out, 1KHz) > 90 dB
Equivalent input noise:
4µV
Digital section:
Latest version of
Phillips CD PRO Top
loading drive unit 24
bits 192KHz D/A
converter
Digital out: RCA/XLR
Other: True
balanced system
Mechanical filter which
cancels
acoustic/mechanical
vibrations preventing
the laser pick-up from
receiving unwanted
signals FTT Power supply
Fully remote (no volume
control)
Power consumption:
(no load or signal) 23 W
Dimensions: Width
483 mm / 19 inches Depth
440 mm / 17.3 inches
Height 115mm / 4.5
inches Weight 20Kg / 44
lbs.
Price: $5000
US Distributor: Jason
Scott Distributing.
Phone number: 800.359.9154
Website:
www.Electrocompaniet.no
And
to Think
I Hesitated
Electrocompaniet’s
designer Per Abrahamsen
has been making
amplifiers for more than
a quarter century. A
history this broad in an
industry filled with
wannabes and copycats
whose life span is
usually shorter than the
common housefly,
Electrocompaniet should
be all the rage here in
the US. They are not.
Norwegian roots coupled
with a terrific
reputation for sound
quality,
Electrocompaniet has
mysteriously remained on
the margins of the
American hi-fi
conscience. With their
newest product boasting
the latest analogue
boards and digital
24/192 kHz upsampling
capabilities, the
all-new Electrocompaniet
EMC1 CD player hopes to
change all that.
I
chose the Sony SCD-1
SACD player as my new
front-end reference,
replacing my
long-standing reference,
the legendary Meitner
BIDAT DAC and transport.
Obviously I really
believed DSD was the way
to go. I mean, let us
consider its musical
implications for a
second: Direct Stream
Digital is a simplified
mechanism for recording
and playback resulting
in a frequency response
of over 100 kHz and a
dynamic range over 120
dB across the audible
frequency range. DSD
increases the resolution
of music by closely
following the original
waveform of the music,
resulting in music
reproduction that is
remarkably pure and
faithful to the
original. The SCD1,
Sony’s pinnacle
top-loader is state of
the art in terms of
build quality. Built on
a curvaceous 60-lb.
aluminum chassis, it
still remains my champ
for state of art musical
reproduction. There I
was, front and center in
the fall of ’99 awaiting
its New York premier
with intense
anticipation reminiscent
of when I was a child
tossing and turning the
night before Christmas.
The SCD1 lived beyond my
expectations in its
ability to unravel the
most intricate musical
details with a sense of
ease never before heard
from a CD based system.
SACD became a rousing
success and the SCD1 won
product of the year in
many audiophile
publications.
Then
what am I doing writing
a review of just another
CD player? Read on…
His-story
A
little technical
background on
Electrocompaniet reveals
Per Abrahamsen,
Electrocompaniet’s chief
designer, and three
friends whose musical
playback aspirations far
exceeded what was then
available from
transistors, started
Electrocompaniet back in
1972. Designing
amplifiers using Dr.
Matti Otala’s brilliant
Transient
Intermodulation
Distortion (TIM)
approach led to the
first TIM-free, 25-watt
amplifier that went on
to become a huge success
(lasting more than seven
years before a more
powerful model replaced
it). Further R&D
introduced a "Floating
Transformer Technology"
(FTT) into their
designs. In 1999, after
many years of steady
success in the amplifier
and preamplifier market,
Abrahamsen introduced
the company’s first CD
player, aptly named the
Electro Magnetic
Cancellation 1 (or
EMC1), based on the sole
premise that there is
no difference between a
record player and a CD
player. That is, if
you pay strict attention
to vibration induced
noises to the transport
mechanism.
Apparent throughout all
my research was the
specific emphasis
Electrocompaniet placed
on noise cancellation
and mechanical
vibration. This
eventually brought their
most auspicious design:
the EMC1 and its
patented
electro-mechanical
damping system. It is
made purely from a blend
of soft rubber and metal
alloy that purportedly
isolates the transport’s
laser mechanism from
bothersome vibrations
completely. Similar to
their amplifiers, the
EMC1’s circuits are
fully balanced and
symmetrical (the latest
employing updated 24/192
kHz DAC’s) for both the
left and right channel
respectively.
Additionally, four
separate power supplies
using their exclusive
Floating Transformer
Technology (FTT) feed
the digital, analog,
drive mechanism and
fluorescent display.
Hey,
There’s
a UPS
Man
Knocking
on My
Front
Door….
I
clearly remember
screaming upon first
lifting the carton
“Damn, this can’t be a
CD player. It’s too
heavy. Heavier than my
Bel Canto amp and as
heavy as the SCD-1!”
Yep, there it is,
Electrocompaniet in bold
type is stamped right
here on the box. More
than any info I managed
to grasp, the most
physically beguiling was
the EMC1’s 50-lb. mass.
Surprisingly, after
dismantled the shipping
carton from the EMC-1,
it maintained its heft,
revealing this wasn’t
just heavy packaging.
The
next thing that hit me
upon the arrival of the
latest 24/192 version of
the EMC1 uncrated was
this top-loader’s beauty
and minimalist design
approach. Four flush
mounted brass
pushbuttons decorate its
right flank while a blue
fluorescent-lit display
window adorns its left.
Centered in brass
splendor is the company
logo, inscribed on the
transport mechanism’s
sliding front drawer.
All this, by the way, is
smartly dressed within a
1” thick Plexiglas front
fascia that spells style
and class in any
language. A single
power-on button switch
completes the front of
this otherwise well
thought-out device. The
rear of the EMC1
supports both RCA and
XLR interconnects. It is
strongly recommended
that the XLR connections
be used, rather than the
single ended
connections, due to the
EMC1’s design being a
truly balanced one.
Balanced (XLR) and coax
(RCA) digital outputs
come standard in the
event one chooses to use
an outboard D/A.
Unfortunately, the EMC1
will not output 24/192
kHz. The transport
mechanism (a Philips
based CDM-Pro) comes
equipped with a
three-piece locking
mechanism to further
insure safe delivery
against your everyday
UPS gorilla. This takes
the mystery out of the
Allen wrench packaged
with the rather cheap
looking, and I might
add, plastic remote
control. A simple task
of unbolting the locking
device that’s cleverly
hidden underneath the
EMC1’s brass badge
situated right behind
the transport drawer is
required before the EMC1
is ready for playback. A
handy bubble level for
fine-tuning the EMC1’s
trio of adjustable brass
feet is thrown in for
extra good measure. The
EMC1 will not read SACD,
DVD, or DVD-A encoded
discs, but will read
your favorite selections
placed on a CDR (of
which my collection is
gaining steady ground on
my original store
purchases). All in all,
the EMC1 looks as if it
were designed to take
over where the original
CD failed: force vinyl
lovers to wonder aloud
weather the fuss
associated with an
analogue is really worth
it. Equipped with looks
that are to die for and
a serious attention to
detail and
build-quality,
specifically its
transport mechanism,
there’s no question the
folks at
Electrocompaniet hit a
home run in their first
digital undertaking.
I was
relieved to find our own
Greg Petan reviewed the
EMC1 24/96 kHz version
for the now extinct
Ultimate Audio magazine,
where he compared it
quite favorably to his
reference Linn CD12.
Knowing Greg’s tastes
were in alignment with
my own, I would have
some serious competition
for the Sony’s SACD. I
should also state that I
find it strange that the
Linn CD12, devoid of
fancy high-rez labels
and/or capabilities,
always sonically floated
my boat over the Sony
SCD1, or any other CD
based device for that
matter.
So
What
Does
it Sound
Like?
Simply put, I was left
dumbfounded by the
performance of the EMC1.
There’s no way, I
believed, anyone could
get standard 16/44 discs
of no particular origin,
upsample them to 24/192
and outperform DSD
encoded material from a
Sony SCD1. Examples? I
got plenty. Miles Davis’
melancholic Sketches
of Spain [Columbia
CS65142] reissue in DSD,
is absolutely superb
sounding, considering it
wasn’t originally
recorded in DSD.
However, they all
sounded night and day
better than the original
16/44 pressings. The
sonic outcome is
certainly more
analog-like, loaded with
tons of room ambience
exuding from what
appears to be every pore
of the recording’s
venue. It casts as large
a three-dimensional
field, laterally as well
as front to back, as
I’ve heard, across my
listening room’s wall --
everything Sony
advertised is still
apparent via the DSD
signal chain.
Nevertheless, the EMC1
manages to take any
standard 16/44 disc,
upsample them to 24/192,
and sonically outperform
SACD’s in side-by-side
comparisons.
The
EMC1’s exquisite
resolving power backed
by the incredibly low
noise floor it possesses
makes clear evidence of
Davis’ stellar
individual talents even
when surrounded by such
a large accompaniment.
With the EMC1 spinning
this standard disc, the
soundstage actually
expanded beyond the
already extended
boundaries of the Talon
Khorus X’s physical
plane. Treble extension
took a noticeable step
skyward, especially with
respect to percussion
instruments, while
contrarily remaining
smoother in overall
response. This gave an
improved sense of height
to each recording,
something I couldn’t
help but appreciate.
There
exists a sonic
footprint, rather a
romanticism, in the EMC1
that’s unmistakable,
without the slightest
roll-off occurring
anywhere in audio
spectrum this listener
could discern. Softer?
Compared to what? Life?
Compared to the SACD,
yeah the sound is
sweeter, albeit smoother
and polished, but only
when appropriate. The
sound of Davis’ trumpet
had more blat than I
could recollect through
the EMC1, a quality I
most often associate
with the real thing. One
thing’s for sure, the
EMC1 possesses the most
quiet, see-through and
natural presentation
I’ve heard from anything
this side of the Linn
CD12.
These
amazing sonic feats
weren’t just apparent on
Miles’ Sketches of Spain
DSD disc, but on the
Quiet Nights [Columbia
65293], ‘Round About
Midnight [Columbia
CS85201], Jazz At The
Plaza [Columbia
CS85245] and Live
Evil [Columbia
CS65135], all of which I
own in both formats. To
insure I wasn’t fooling
myself, I pulled out
SACD hybrids like the
Mark Levinson Red
Rose [Red Rose Vol.
1], Vanguard Classics
Guitarra Flamenco by
Manitas de Plata
[VSD503] and DMP Records
Far More Drums
from Robert Hohner
Percussion Ensemble [DMP
SACD10]. Played through
both the Sony and EMC1,
but this time with a
group of discerning
audiophiles whose ears
I’ve grown to trust, all
preferred the EMC1’s
more analog-sounding
performance over the
SACD. The EMC1 sounded
ever so slightly less
mechanical. Hence, less
digital (a phenomenon
vinyl aficionados always
claim to hear, thus
their lack of
enjoyment). I won’t
admit I hear it in SACD
playback as much, but
compared to the EMC1,
well, let’s just say I’d
much rather listen to
the EMC1. It just sounds
that superb.
The
bass and midrange of the
EMC1 also requires
special mention. When
listening to Ahmad Jamal
Trio’s The Awakening
[Impulse 226], you get
the idea that the white
paper detailing
Electrocompaniet’s
transport functionality
for the cancellation of
noise ain’t just techno
babble. On this poignant
melody of Oliver
Nelson’s Stolen
Moments, Ahmad Jamal
not only captures the
feeling of Nelson’s
original make, but in
doing so, using minimal
chord structure with
maximum spacing, takes
this giant jazz
composition to another
level. The crackling
resonances of Jamil
Nassar’s upright
revealed itself with
greater comprehension
than previously
realized. The string
tension proved more than
apparent. This sonic
tonic was tied with
Jamal's near
undetectable piano
fingerings, exposing
more of the acoustic
spacing hidden in each
note as well with this
remarkable recording.
The EMC1 moves the Ahmad
Jamal Trio to the
forefront of the natural
rendering and further
away from the artificial
signature often heard
with lesser designs. The
EMC1 allows the
extraordinary quality of
getting out of the way
while allowing the music
to communicate
unregulated. Rare
indeed.
In
summary, the EMC1 simply
is the best sounding CD
player to have graced my
system. It humiliated
the highly touted SACD’s
in the all-important
sonic parameters -
richness, tonality,
soundstaging,
resolution, image
specificity and
quietness - right out of
the dog-gone box. The
EMC1 outperformed SACD
discs through the
almighty Sony SCD1. Its
16/44 to 24/192 kHz
upsampling capabilities
of standard everyday
CD’s together with its
formable build quality
and to-die-for good
looks make it both a
spectacular performer as
well as a bargain. For
anyone who already owns
or is familiar with the
EMC1’s performance, you
know the words are
merely superfluous: You
must listen for
yourself. I have. The
EMC1 is easily the best
CD player to have graced
my system.

|