| Origin
Live
Silver
250
Tonearm |
|
|
|
Paul
Szabady |
|
28
November
2001 |
Specifications
Price:
$735 (price
will vary
based on UK
currency
exchange
rates,
Shipping
excluded)
Available
from and
manufactured
by:
Origin Live
87 Chessel
Crescent
Bitterne,
Southampton
UK SO19 4BT
Phone: +44 (0)
2380 442183 or
578877
Fax +44 (0)
2380 398905
Website: http://www.originlive.com/
I
consider
Origin Live’s
modification
of the Rega RB
250 tonearm to
be the
premiere
bargain in
analog audio
today. It
supplants the
long-reigning
Rega RB 300
arm for that
honor and has
been intensely
enjoyable in
my various
systems over
the last year
and a half.
The kind of
intense
musical peak
experience
that makes it
is impossible
to get up
after the
record to cue
the arm up has
become
routine. The
OL RB250 has
been so
musically
satisfying
that I’ve
felt no need
to upgrade it
or to consider
more expensive
arms.
Rhythmically
beguiling,
musically
articulate,
tonally
balanced, and
sweetly
detailed
without
resorting to
x-ray
penetration,
its
inexpensive
price allows
ownership by
serious music
lovers not
blessed with
obscenely high
incomes. My
hat is off to
Mark Baker for
combining
savvy
engineering
with a pricing
policy that
brings into
question the
value of
high-priced
tonearms.
The
Silver 250 is
the newest
addition to
the Origin
Live stable of
tonearms.
Priced at $735
US (price will
vary as the US
dollar varies
in value with
the British
pound, and
roughly $300
more than the
OL RB250), it
slots in under
the
entry-level,
"high-end"
tonearms. The
"silver"
refers to the
new, non-Rega
arm tube and
headshell,
which are made
of aircraft
alloy. The
"250"
harkens to its
roots in the
Rega RB 250,
roots that are
now only
vestigial.
Gone are the
OEM Rega black
arm tube,
bearings and
counterweight:
only the
tonearm
pillar, base,
antiskate, and
cueing
mechanism/platform
remain to link
it with the
stock Rega
arm.
Significantly,
an
"Origin
Live"
insignia now
graces the
tonearm. The
horizontal
bearings are
of a higher
ABEC rating
and the
bearing yoke
has been
widened. The
arm stub and
counterweight
are identical
to Origin Live’s
modification
of the Rega
arm, as are
the tonearm
wiring and
phono plugs.
The
non-removable
headshell is
much thicker
and more rigid
than on the
standard Rega
arm and is
de-coupled
from the arm
tube. An Allen
bolt,
precisely
torqued,
maintains
integrity of
the headshell
in the arm
tube. The
headshell and
the
counterweight
are both
de-coupled.
Mark Baker
believes that
there are
definite
advantages to
decoupling at
crucial
points: too
long a
resonance
path, despite
it
attractiveness
as theory, can
create
problems in
practice. This
runs against
the Rega’s
design
philosophy,
but the Silver
250 is no
longer a
modified Rega;
it should be
considered an
Origin Live
tonearm.
The
Silver 250
builds on the
excellent
sonic and
musical
strengths of
the Origin
Live RB250; a
fair
understanding
would be to
see it as a
higher-resolution
OL 250. Detail
is improved
across the
bandwidth,
while
maintaining
the OL 250’s
excellent
conveyance of
rhythmic
drive,
balanced
tonality,
punctuation
and
articulation
of phrasing,
and bass
weight and
punch. The
increased
detail is of
musical
interest; this
isn’t the
kind of detail
that is
extraneous to
musical
communication.
It offers a
finer insight
into the
subtleties of
instrumental
timbre,
musical
performance,
and recording
quality.
Dynamic
contrasts are
larger and
thus the sound
is more vivid
than the OL
250.
Instrumental
and soundstage
focus is
sharper and
clearer.
Control of
transients is
also improved:
the overall
impression of
the Silver 250
is of finer
precision and
control, with
greater
finesse,
subtlety and
nuance. As
such, it
allows a more
cerebral
understanding
of both sonic
and
performance
detail than
the OL RB 250,
but by no
means enforces
such a view. I
could not call
it analytical,
in that word’s
pejorative
sense, because
the arm is not
cold or etched
sounding, and
while details
are
differentiated,
they are also
synthesized
into a musical
whole. I
consider this
to be the
ideal goal of
increased
resolution:
more detail in
the service of
the music.
The
Silver 250
demands
conscientious
set-up: slight
errors in
Vertical
Tracking Angle
and in
cartridge
alignment are
obvious. Get
the VTA wrong
and you’ll
know it; get
it really
right and the
music takes
wing. The
Silver 250’s
increased
detail reveals
the
limitations of
indifferent
recordings,
cartridges,
and pressings,
but does not
highlight
them. As such
it benefits
from being
matched to the
finest
ancillary
components and
recordings. It
is somewhat of
a thoroughbred
in its need
for
fastidiousness.
The OL 250,
though less
focused
overall, is
less
persnickety
and more
forgiving: it
tells you what’s
good about the
music without
focusing on
the recording’s
flaws.
From
a musical
standpoint the
2 tonearms are
somewhat akin
to hearing the
same
performance in
two excellent
but different
halls: the
detail and
clarity of a
slightly dry
contemporary
hall versus a
warmer, more
romantic-sounding
older hall.
The musical
quality of the
performance
isn’t
necessary
changed, but
each hall
(arm) offers a
different
perspective.
I
auditioned the
Silver 250 in
4 turntables:
the Origin
Live Standard
Kit, a Linn
Sondek LP12
Nirvana, an AR
with Merrill’s
acrylic
subchassis and
bearing, and
an Origin Live
DC-motored
Linn LP12
(formerly a
Valhalla). The
simpatico
mating of the
OL arms with
the Linn LP 12
continues with
the Silver 250
I’m happy to
report. Not
surprisingly,
the audibility
of the
improvement of
the Silver 250
over the OL RB
250 was
greatest in
the DC-motored
Linn, followed
closely by the
OL Standard
Kit. As Linn
has long
espoused, the
hierarchy of
contribution
to overall
sound proceeds
first from the
turntable,
then the arm,
and finally,
the cartridge.
I
installed a
gamut of
cartridges in
the arm that
fairly
encompass the
range of
cartridge
sound and
generation/output
types: Grado
TLZ-V
Signature and
Shure V-15 V
xMR (high
output moving
iron and
moving magnet,
respectively),
Audio Technica
AT- OC9ML,
Goldring
Eroica LX, and
Koetsu
Rosewood
Signature
(low-output
moving coil)
and Denon DL
160
(high-output
moving coil.)
The sonic
signatures and
capabilities
of each
cartridge
emerged
clearly and at
no time did I
feel that the
Silver 250 was
being taxed or
losing
control. Quite
the contrary,
it sailed
through my
usual acid
test LPs with
ease, finesse
and great
satisfaction.
Do
owners of the
Origin Live RB
250 need to
immediately
upgrade? Not
necessarily:
the cheaper
arm is still a
stunning and
completely
viable musical
product. It
still produces
intense
musical
pleasure and
its slightly
forgiving
nature can be
sonically
flattering. I
could live
happily with
the OL RB250
arm for the
rest of my
life. Is the
Silver 250
worth the $300
additional
cost over the
OL RB 250?
Yes. The gains
in resolution,
subtlety,
finesse and
detail enhance
musical
understanding
and pleasure
without
negative
trade-offs.
The quality of
one’s
turntable
should be
considered
however in
opting for the
Silver 250, as
lesser table
might not
allow its full
potential to
flower. The
Silver 250 is
another superb
product from
Origin Live
that
challenges the
$2000+
mega-buck arms
to justify
their
existence.
Origin Live
continues its
run of
excellent new
products and
its tradition
of reasonable
prices. A
terrific arm,
a terrific
bargain, and,
obviously, the
highest of
recommendations.
|