| EgglestonWorks
Fontaine
Speaker |
|
| Henry
Wilkenson |
| 15
November
2001 |
Specifications
Frequency
Response: –3db
@55 Hz to well
beyond 24,000
Hz
Efficiency: 87
db.
Impedance: 8
Ohms, nominal,
Minimum
impedance: 6.3
Ohms.
Tweeter: One
1" cloth
dome with
large diameter
vented pole
piece.
Mid-bass,
bass: Two
6"
polypropylene
double magnet
drivers with
3" voice
coils.
Single Rhodium
binding posts
Dimensions: 9
½" W. X
151/2" D.
X 17" H.
Weight: 70lbs
each
Website: www.egglestonworks.com
EgglestonWorks
is a company
that I had
heard of long
before I ever
had the chance
to sample
their wares.
Located in
Memphis,
Tennessee,
EgglestonWorks
was founded in
1992 with the
goal of
producing the
finest
loudspeakers
possible and
is applied to
all of the
products in
their line.
Their first
offering was a
speaker that
looked like an
end table but
ultimately was
not as
successful as
they had
hoped. In late
1996, the
Andra was
released.
While it
received wide
acclaim and
generated
strong sales,
EgglestonWorks
continued to
modify and
refine the
speaker.
The
opportunity
for me to hear
an
EgglestonWorks
speaker came
by way of my
friend and
colleague,
Marshall Nack.
Some of you
long term
readers may
recall
Marshall’s
in-depth
review of the
EgglestonWorks
Rosas. I have
had many an
opportunity to
listen to
those speakers
since they
have taken up
residence as
Marshall’s
reference
speakers.
Marshall,
and his lovely
wife Lynn, are
an unusual
couple in that
they are both
audiophiles.
Actually, they
are the only
audiophile
couple that I
am personally
acquainted
with. I’m
sure the fact
that they are
both serious
musicians is
largely
responsible
for their
being able to
hear very fine
tonal
gradations and
detail with
such ease.
Among his many
talents,
Marshall has
an exceptional
ability to
voice a
system. He
always seems
to be able to
find the right
mixture of
components and
accessories
that result in
an
exceptionally
well-balanced
system. This
is far more
difficult to
accomplish
than you might
think.
However, the
revealing
nature of the
EgglestonWorks
speakers was
instrumental
in achieving
his sonic
goals. With
each
substitution
of components
or
accessories,
the Rosas
clearly
revealed the
sonic
contributions,
for better or
worse, of
whatever
hardware
changes had
been made.
When
the
Stereophile
Show came to
town this
spring, the
EgglestonWorks
room was high
on my must
visit list. It
was there that
I met
EgglestonWorks
prez Jim
Thomson, and
took my first
listen to the
Fontaines. I
know you have
all heard that
the sound
quality at
shows is
generally
pretty bad.
While I find
this to be
largely true,
at the same
time, you can
get some idea
of a product’s
sonic
potential, or
how it might
ultimately
perform under
home
conditions.
The Fontaines
were set up in
Eggleston’s
home theater
room. Included
with the
display was a
pair of
dedicated
sub-woofers.
Though I’ve
never ventured
into the realm
of home
theater for a
number of
reasons,
primarily a
lack of space,
I have to
admit that
this set-up
sounded quite
good.
According
to company
literature,
"the
design of each
loudspeaker
model in the
EgglestonWorks
line begins
with the
midrange."
For the
Fontaines, a
pair of
6"
polypropylene,
double magnet
drivers handle
the midrange
and bass. Each
of these
drivers has a
3"
diameter voice
coil. It has
been said many
times before
but it bears
repeating, as
it is so true;
if the
midrange is
not correct,
than all else
is fruitless.
The tweeter
has a large
aperiodic
damping
chamber that
imitates
infinite
baffle
loading. The
tweeter is
hard wired to
the crossover
with one cap
and two
resistors used
as an L-pad.
A
single set of
binding posts
is mounted in
a recessed
panel on the
rear of the
driver
section. I
asked Jim
Thompson about
using a single
set of binding
posts as
opposed to the
current trend
of using dual
posts. He told
me that after
extensive
listening
tests, and as
the midrange
has no
crossover, it
was decided
that there
were no sonic
gains to be
made by the
addition of a
second set.
The drivers
are directly
connected to
the binding
posts. Of
course, if a
customer is
set on
biwiring,
these speakers
can be
outfitted with
dual binding
posts by
special order.
If you wish to
use what Perry
has so aptly
named
"rigor
mortis"
cable, you
will have to
use banana
plugs in order
to reach the
recessed
binding posts
without unduly
stressing the
cable.
The
bass and
mid-bass
drivers are
housed in what
EgglestonWorks
describes as a
quasi
transmission-line
loaded
enclosure.
This is
accomplished
by employing a
specialized
acoustic
stuffing
material known
as "acousta
stuff."
This is a
polyester
strand that is
crimped every
millimeter.
This makes
every strand a
complex shape,
capable of
providing
greater
diffraction to
the sound
waves
traveling
through it.
The cabinet is
constructed of
5/8"
thick MDF wood
panels, twice
laminated with
an imported
damping
material. To
further damp
the
enclosures,
the outside
panels have
one-centimeter
thick, Italian
granite slabs
bonded to
them. The end
result of
these efforts
is a very
inert
enclosure that
provides much
better bass
response than
the small size
of the drivers
would
indicate.
After
several
conversations
with Jim
Thompson, four
medium-sized
but fairly
heavy cartons
arrived from
EgglestonWorks.
The cartons
contained the
driver and the
matching base
sections. You
should be very
careful while
setting up
these speakers
so as not to
damage the
exquisite
piano black
finish. The
picture does
not in any way
do justice to
these
speakers. You
really have to
see them in
person to
understand
what I mean.
The Fontaines
can be viewed
as one of
those products
that fall into
the
"audio as
art"
category. They
are simply
beautiful.
The
fit and finish
is right up
there with the
best that I
have ever
seen. It is
obvious to me
that
EgglestonWorks
has taken a
great deal of
care and gone
to
considerable
expense in the
design and
construction
of these
enclosures.
Once
assembled, the
speakers give
the appearance
of a
monolithic
floor stander.
The bases are
sand-fallible
and will form
a very
substantial
enclosure. I
would strongly
advise you to
settle on
final
placement
before filling
the bases with
sand. These
babies are
quite heavy to
begin with;
once filled
with sand,
they would be
almost
impossible for
the average
person to move
alone. I
placed the
speakers on a
quilt, then on
their sides,
to insert the
four bolts
that hold the
bases in
place. This is
done through
an access
panel in the
bottom of the
base. While
the spikes
that are
supplied are
very sturdy
ones, they
have a fine
thread and can
be easily
damaged if you
are careless
while
installing
them. The
driver
enclosure is
very inert so
I would advise
great care if
you decide to
perform the
knuckle test.
I
particularly
like the way
they have
chosen to deal
with the
grills. They
are
constructed
with a very
sheer material
mounted on a
slender steel
frame. They
attach to the
front baffle
by means of
magnets that
are buried
under the
surface
laminate. This
arrangement
makes
attaching the
grills as
simple as
possible and
worked just
fine for me. I
found the
grills to be
audibly
transparent,
so I choose to
leave them in
place.
While
the efficiency
is listed as
what might
seem like a
rather low
87db, I had no
problem-achieving
lease breaking
levels with
the Bel Canto
EVo power amp.
However, I
would not
recommend
trying to
drive the
Fontaines with
single ended
triodes.
When
I receive new
equipment to
review, I will
often invite
several
non-audiophile
friends over,
fire up the
system and
observe their
reactions. In
each case, the
reactions to
the Fontaines
began before
the first CD
was in the
drawer and
they were
always quite
positive.
Everyone was
taken with
their striking
appearance and
the way that
they so easily
blended into
the room. They
are as
beautiful as
they are
unobtrusive.
While it is
quite obvious
from the specs
and the
quality of the
hardware used
that
EgglestonWorks
constructs its
speakers with
a great deal
of care, the
most important
question is
yet to be
answered.
How
Do They Sound?
After
a suitable
break-in
period, I sat
down to give
the Fontaines
a serious
listen. The
company states
in its
literature
that the
primary design
tool used to
voice the
entire line of
speakers is
the sound of
music as
opposed to a
primary
reliance upon
measurements.
Since I do not
have the
ability to
perform any
measurements
on the
equipment that
I have for
review, I can
only tell you
how they
perform in my
system. While
I believe that
measurements
do have their
place, they
hardly give
the total
picture. There
have been many
components
that have
measured
terribly but
were stellar
performers
sonically, and
vice versa.
Even
before the
speakers were
fully broken
in they
sounded quite
good. I found
two of the
most prominent
sonic
attributes of
these speakers
to be their
midrange
clarity and
their ability
to paint a
rich harmonic
portrait. They
have that
see-through
quality that
allows each
instrument to
occupy its own
space, but
always with a
natural sense
of proportion
within the
soundstage. No
hardness or
edginess ever
accompanied
this clarity.
I also noticed
a consistent
easy quality
to the sound
that just let
the music flow
in a most
seductive way.
Cymbals and
bell tones
have the
proper amount
of sheen and
delicacy and
again, they
seem to have
the right
size. The
decay rates
for these
instruments
also
contribute to
the sense of
realism.
The
Fontaines
floated a very
good image
across the
stage with
excellent
localization
of the
instruments.
They
consistently
revealed the
low level
details that
among other
things gave a
real sense of
the size of
the recording
venue. With
Miles Davis, Kind
of Blue,
[Columbia
CK52861 - Gold
Version and
Columbia
CK64935 - 20
bit Re-master]
by Miles
Davis, Bill
Evans’ piano
comes across
much more
realistically
than I usually
hear it. I
have always
taken issue
with the
recorded sound
of the piano,
especially
with many of
the older Blue
Note
recordings.
Just the
opposite is
the case with
the XRCD
recording, Waltz
for Debby
by the Bill
Evans Trio [JVC
XRCD
VICJ-60141].
Here the tonal
qualities and
complex
harmonic
structure of
the piano are
presented very
well.
I
was surprised
by the sense
of depth that
these speakers
presented me
with. My room
will not
cooperate very
much in this
area, so this
was a welcomed
surprise. In
fact, it is
the best that
I have heard
here. The
center fill
was spot on
with soloists
being a little
more forward
than I am used
to but it was
to good
effect.
Overall, I
found the
imaging
abilities of
these speakers
to be
exceptionally
good. For my
taste, they
struck the
right balance
between image
specificity
and
naturalness.
The great deal
of effort that
EgglestonWorks
has put into
the design of
the driver
enclosures
really pays
off in the
superior
imaging
qualities of
these
speakers.
Since
the –3db
point is
listed at
55hz, I didn’t
expect too
much from the
lower regions
but I was
pleasantly
surprised with
what I did
hear. Now don’t
misunderstand,
these are not
the speakers
for pipe organ
or reggae
fans. For that
kind of bass
output you
should look
much higher up
in the
EgglestonWorks
line. What is
notable about
the low end in
this case is
the accuracy
of the bass.
It is never
boomy; rather,
it tends to be
tight and
tuneful. When
poorly
executed, the
bass can
obscure
musical
elements in
the lower
midrange. The
bass of the
Fontaines does
not interfere
with or
obscure the
midrange at
all. In other
words, the
bloom of the
low end does
not come at
the expense of
midrange
clarity. For
classical and
a good deal of
jazz, you
could be quite
satisfied with
the low end of
the Fontaines.
Overall, the
bass output
was much
better than I
expected.
Tim
Shea wrote a
terrific
review of the
Musse Audio
Reference Two
NF speakers
last June. I
have them on
hand and will
do a follow up
review.
However, since
they are in
the same price
range as the
Fontaines, I
thought they
would make an
interesting
comparison.
The
Reference
Twos, like the
Fontaines, are
two-way
monitors. In
this case, you
supply the
stands. The
sonic
differences
are striking
because of the
strengths of
each lie at
opposite ends
of the sonic
spectrum. With
a -3db point
of 35Hz and
the port
tuning
frequency of
29Hz, it is
not surprising
that the
Reference Twos
go deeper. The
low end here
is tight and
tuneful as
well. While
the Fontaines
do not go as
deep, I have
to say that
the bass is a
bit tighter
and a bit more
tuneful than
the Reference
Twos. However,
the Fontaines
definitely get
the nod for
their midrange
and upper
register
extension,
sweetness and
excellent
rendition of
detail. These
are sonic
traits that
are a
permanent
fixture in
Perry’s
listening room
and I have
subsequently
come to listen
for them all
of the time.
In addition to
this, there is
plenty of air
around the
instruments
with very good
decay rates.
Some might
describe these
speakers as
being tonally
neutral,
however you
wish to
describe that
characteristic.
I, on the
other hand,
find their
tonality to be
slightly on
the warm side.
That suits me
just fine.
Overall they
simply get out
of the way of
the music.
This is what
many speaker
manufactures
claim that
their products
do but the
reality is
often quite
different.
Etta
James, Life,
Love and The
Blues
[Private Label
01005-82162-2]:
This is a CD
that is a very
good example
of the
"Mussel
Shoals"
sound. It has
a very heavy
sustained bass
line
throughout
many of the
cuts. Check
out "Here
I am
Baby" to
see what I
mean. In this
instance, a
good bit of
this bass is
attenuated.
After all, you
can only move
so much air
with a
six-inch
driver. The
roll off is
very graceful,
with no sign
of driver
overload or
other
distress. From
the upper bass
on up all is
well. Etta
James’ voice
comes through
with the right
amount of bite
and warmth.
Patricia
Barber, Companion
[Blue
Note/Premonition
7243 5 22963 2
3]: This is a
live recording
that really
shines on the
Fontaines. The
sense of
immediacy and
presence is
such that you
can get an
implication of
the size of
the room
without any
hyper-detail
to get in the
way. On the
cut "Use
Me,"
there is an
upright bass
solo that the
Fontaines
reproduce with
all of the
textures and
harmonic
richness in
tact. Ms.
Barber’s
voice has a
breathy
texture that
is quite
pleasant
without the
vocal detail
ever being
overdone. I
never had the
impression
that I could
see her
tonsils.
With
large-scale
symphonic
works, these
babies
continue in
the same vein.
While their
limited
low-end
capabilities
will diminish
some of the
slam and
weight that
their larger
brethren are
able to
handle, they
still give a
satisfying
performance.
To
sum up, the
EgglestonWorks
Fontaines can
best be
described as
being very
musical. While
they will give
you all of the
attributes
that
audiophiles
crave, they
are never
overly
analytical. I
really
appreciate the
midrange
qualities that
keep my
listening
sessions on
the long side.
They make me
want to get
the audiophile
stuff out of
the way and
just sit back
and enjoy the
music. I find
myself pulling
out CD after
CD that I have
not heard in a
while to give
a listen. If
you feel that
you simply
must have that
last bit of
bass output,
remember that
matching subs
are available.
The
characteristics
of these
speakers that
impress me the
most are the
grainless
midrange,
top-end
extension, the
ability to
float a
realistic,
totally
coherent
soundstage and
the
top-to-bottom
ease of the
musical
presentation.
I never heard
any
discontinuity
between the
bass, mids or
the highs.
They were
always
coherent in
this regard.
These
are very high
quality
speakers and
you need to
connect them
to equally
high quality
gear upstream.
Of course they
will work with
inexpensive
amplifiers,
but they will
quickly reveal
all of the
sonic
deficiencies
and warts. The
EgglestonWorks
Fontaines are
what the high
end is all
about. While
they cannot be
considered
cheap and are
in a crowded
field at this
price point,
they do offer
very good
value
considering
their
excellent
performance.
Music
used in this
evaluation:
Cannonball
Adderley, Something
Else,
[Blue Note
1595]
Miles Davis, Kind
of Blue,
[Columbia
CK52861, Gold
Version and
Columbia
CK64935 20bit
Re-master]
Clifford
Jordan
Quartet, Live
at Ethell’s,
[Mapleshade
56292]
Bill Evans
Trio, Waltz
for Debby,
[JVC XRCD
VICJ-60141]
Carmen Lundy, Self
Portrait,
[JVC XRCD
0005-2]
BBC Music, Best
CD’s of 1994,
[BBC-BO94]
The Boston
Pops
Orchestra, American
Visions,
[BMG
092206-68786]
Marc Antoine
Charpentier, Concerto
Vocale,
[harmonia
mundi HMC
901006]
|