| REL
Acoustics Ltd.,
Stentor III Sub Bass
System |
|
|
|
Frank Peraino |
|
9 October
2002 |
Specifications
10" Big Ten
Volt Driver (long throw)
Super ARM™ loaded
cabinet
Enclosure Volume: 70
liters
Frequency Range: 12-100
Hz
DC Coupled, 300 watts
RMS, 600 watts peak
High & Low-Level Two
Channel Balanced and
Unbalanced Input
Connections & Neutrik
Speaker-Level Inputs
Dimensions: 27.5" W
×
23"H
× 17.5"D (65
×
59 ×
41 cm)
Weight: 133 lbs.
Manufacturer:
REL Acoustics Ltd.
North Road, Bridgend
Industrial Estate
Bridgend, CF31 3TP,
Untied Kingdom
Website:
www.rel.net/
US Importer:
Sumiko
Address: 2431 Fifth
Street
Berkeley, CA 94710
Telephone: (510)
843-4500
Fax: (510) 843-7120
Website:
www.sumikoaudio.net
We Don't
Need No Stinkin'
Boomboxes!
Alright, I
am willing to admit
right up front my bias
against and preconceived
notions of subwoofers
prior to my first
exposure to the REL ST
series of Sub-Bass
Systems-namely, for
anything other than home
theater applications, I
was not a
subwoofer kinda guy. My
previous experiences
with subwoofers left me
with the opinion that
subwoofers either
imposed themselves on
fuller range
loudspeakers or did not
blend seamlessly enough
with monitors to
seriously consider them
a valuable asset to any
good system. To me, a
subwoofer's benefit was
outweighed by its
burden. That is, until I
heard what the REL
Stentor III did for a
set of Sonus Faber Grand
Pianos and, eventually,
what it did in my
system.
My friend and fellow
reviewer at the late
Ultimate Audio,
Rufus Smith, one day
related to me his
experiences with a REL
Stadium III that I found
completely antithetical
to my experiences with
subwoofers. So when I
found out that Allan
Haggar of Sumiko was
going to be
demonstrating the REL
Stadium III and Stentor
III at Overture Audio in
Ann Arbor, I decided to
make the 30 minute trek
down the road to see if
Rufus was on to
something or just having
a senior moment (sorry
buddy). REL and Sumiko
both call the REL ST
Series of products
"sub-bass systems" as
opposed to subwoofers -
a moniker I was about to
learn was certainly
appropriate. When I
arrived, it was about an
hour from closing and
Allan graciously offered
to stay past hours to
give me a private
demonstration. Allan
asked if I preferred
hearing the smaller
Stadium or the larger
Stentor, and I chose the
bigger, much beefier
Stentor (it's a
testosterone thing).
What followed caused me
to rethink my old biases
against subwoofers.
Description
The REL
line of sub-bass systems
is equally comfortable
doing duty in either
two-channel or home
theater application.
However, this review is
limited to two-channel
use. The Stentor III is
a 133-pound, beautifully
veneered piece of
furniture with a dark
glass top that exudes
first rate fit and
finish. Yet the Stentor
III is not just another
pretty face and, in this
instance, form follows
function. Inside the
Stentor III you will
find a powerful 300-watt
built-in amplifier (50%
more power than its
predecessor, the Stentor
II) with a self-limiter
to protect against
overload and an improved
die-cast frame 10" Volt
driver. The enclosure is
an ultra rigid enclosure
that incorporates REL's
proprietary "Super
Acoustic Resistive
Matrix" (ARM) loading
which, in essence, is a
series of chambers
leading to the port that
re-matches the driver in
a somewhat similar
way to a transmission
line. The effect is an
enclosure that produces
bass with extension,
depth and impact
completely out of
proportion to what you
would expect from a
single 10" driver. The
Stentor III is stated to
extend down to 12 Hz (-6
dB).
The Stentor III, like
its siblings in the ST
line, incorporates a
system of crossover and
gain controls and varied
inputs which allows the
user a flexibility that
should suit almost any
room and allow the
seamless integration
with almost any
speakers. Adjustments
include a coarse and a
fine gain control, a
combination of crossover
frequencies ranging from
22 to 95 Hz as well the
ability to reverse
phase. The inputs
include low-level
unbalanced RCA inputs
(e.g., for subwoofer out
or preamp outputs), an
unbalanced high-level
input via Neutrik
Speakon connectors for
signals directly from
the speakers terminals
of your amplifier(s) and
high and low balanced
inputs, also via Neutrik
Speakon connectors.
Set-Up
Set-up may
be confusing depending
on whether you have been
advised by the dealer,
who has probably been
trained by Sumiko, or if
you then choose to read
the operating
instructions by REL,
which differ from that
suggested by Sumiko.
Since Allan Haggar of
Sumiko, conducted my
Stentor III audition as
well as my home set up,
I will briefly describe
their philosophy. Allan
started with the Stentor
III in the front corner
with the control panel
facing the sidewall.
Using the soundtrack to
Sneakers with its
repetitive deep bass
line, Allan first set
the proper phase by
switching the phase
setting to determine
which setting produced
the louder bass. That
done, he started moving
the Stentor III out
diagonally from the
corner, listening for
the greatest output and
deepest extension. From
there, he began
adjusting the coarse and
fine gain controls to
determine when the
Stentor III began to
impose itself on the
main speakers. Finally,
after that adjustment
had been made, we began
the rather slow process
of adjusting the
crossover setting and
the fine gain control to
reach the most seamless
integration between the
Stentor III and my main
speakers. In my system,
the Innersound Eros
MK-II has a 10"
transmission line woofer
which extends to 24 Hz,
so we ended up with the
Stentor III crossed over
at a low 23 Hz to allow
it to "come up" under
the Eros woofers-truly
acting as a sub-bass
system. I should also
point out that the
Stentor III was being
driven off the speaker
terminals of the Eros'
bass amp/crossover.
Since the REL does not
insert itself in the
signal path, my Eros are
then still running full
range. The result, as I
will explain was nothing
short of amazing after
we finally dialed in the
Stentor III. Although
this set up process can
be tedious and lengthy,
it will pay dividends
that make the benefit
easily worth the burden.
At first, I felt that I
was not able to hear
some of the subtle
differences in placement
and phase setting that
Allan heard. However, it
was VERY easy to hear
when the Stentor III
locked in at the end
when we switched between
23 and 25 Hz or when we
went one click up on the
fine gain control.
Today, after having had
the Stentor III in my
system for a year, I can
easily hear the
difference one small
increase in the fine
gain control makes and
how that small increase
in the fine gain throws
off the balance and
integration of my
system.
Nothing Up
My Sleeve -- Presto!
Before
describing the sound of
the Stentor III in my
system, I thought it
would be helpful to
describe what I heard in
the dealer demo that
made me explore this
amazing sub-bass system.
About a year ago at
Overture Audio in Ann
Arbor, Michigan, I heard
the Stentor III
demonstrated with Sonus
Faber Grand Pianos in a
fairly large and
untreated room driven by
Linn electronics and the
venerable Linn Sondek
CD-12. Before strutting
the Stentor's "bass"
stuff, Allan asked me to
listen to a solo
classical piano piece by
Evgeny Kissin, first
sans Stentor III.
Reportedly, the
particular cut he played
had virtually no
information below 70 Hz.
Thus, theoretically, the
Stentor III, which was
crossed over at either
23 or 25 Hz and was
being driven off the
speaker terminals of the
Linn amplifiers, should
not have added or
subtracted much of
anything to the
selection. So much for
theory. The sense of
space and venue with the
Stentor III engaged was
so much more realistic
that I would not have
believed it if I hadn't
heard it myself. In
fact, to make sure my
brain wasn't playing
tricks on me (or that
Allan wasn't some sort
of audio David
Copperfield), Allan sat
on the Stentor III while
I manned the CD-12
remote and he would
engage and disengage the
Stentor III (without
telling me which was
which) as I would repeat
the track on the CD. It
didn't take any one with
a golden ear to easily
pick out when the
Stentor III was
engaged-it was that much
better with it in the
system. Obviously, this
was an effective
demonstration approach
and one that left me
very eager to hear what
the Stentor III could do
with information well
below the 30 Hz level.
It did not disappoint!
Bass is the
Place
After this
demonstration, I
requested Sumiko allow
Allan to set one up in
my system, which he
graciously did. After
set-up and break-in, I
was able to appreciate
just what a sub-bass
system was and what it
could do (and what it
shouldn't do). In my
system, the Stentor III,
as it did in the earlier
demonstration in Ann
Arbor, dramatically
increased the sense of
venue, improved the air
and space around an
instrument or performer
and simply gave me a
greater sense of what
transpired in the studio
or at the event. I must
admit that even if this
were all the Stentor III
did for my system, it
would be worth its
asking price. However,
what the Stentor III did
for my full range Eros'
and my system's bass
performance made this a
no brainer. I should
note that the
transmission line woofer
in the Eros is no slouch
in digging deep and
doesn't leave one
feeling like he isn't
hearing deep bass like a
monitor does. However,
the Stentor III crossed
over at 23 Hz and
supplementing the Eros
woofer did something I
did not expect. Yes, I
expected deeper bass
extension, more impact
and weight (which the
Stentor III delivered in
spades), but what I did
not expect was that even
with all those
improvements, the bass
was now tighter and more
articulate.
To give you an idea of
some of the music I used
to gage this effect, I
played a fabulous CD by
bassist Brian Bromberg
entitled Wood
[A440 Music CD 4001].
For any fan of jazz
acoustic bass, this CD
is required listening
and has spectacular solo
cuts of "Come Together"
by Lennon/McCartney and
"All Blues" by Miles
Davis. On the first cut,
"The Saga of Harrison
Crabfeathers,"
Bromberg's 300-year-old
Matteo Guersam bass was
so rich, so full and so
woody sounding, that I
could feel it in my soul
as well as my gut when
he rattled his strings.
Some electric bass
lovers may think an
acoustic bass sounds
anemic or recessed when
hearing one played
backed on a home system.
However, if you have
ever heard a good
acoustic bass in a small
live venue, they extend
much deeper and have
more impact than may be
evident in many
recordings or on many
home systems. With the
REL Stentor III, Brian
Bromberg's bass was
anything but anemic. It
had all the impact, body
and depth without any
smearing or bloat. The
Stentor III equally
improved electric bass
performance. Every
bassist, from Béla Fleck
and the Flecktones'
energetic Victor Wooten
to Abe Laboriel to the
inimitable Francis Rocco
Prestia of Tower of
Power, was closer to the
real thing. Their bass
lines were more clearly
delineated, more
impactful and deeper
with the Stentor III.
Not only bass, but also
kick drums, church
organs, tubas, trombones
and baritone saxes had
greater visceral impact
with the Stentor III.
However, the icing on
the cake was that every
instrument, every voice,
every nuance of the
recording had a greater
degree of focus and
airiness-a much improved
spaciousness, openness
and, at the risk of
redundancy, sense of
venue and magic that
they did not have sans
Stentor III. With the
Stentor III in my
system, I heard a
greater sense of ease,
the Eros sounding even
more unforced and
effortless. Soundstage
depth and, to a lesser
degree, width was also
improved. With such
seamless integration, I
heard none of the
typical unwanted
by-products normally
associated with
subwoofers that I had
come to expect - e.g.,
decreased purity and
clarity (usually from
the sub's internal
amp/crossover that is
placed n the signal
path), poor integration
with the main speaker
and bass boominess and
bloat.
At $5,000 the Stentor
III is not cheap, but
considering what it did
for my system and what
it can probably do to
yours, for many music
lovers, the improvements
will justify the price
of admission. But be
warned, the Stentor III
is not going to be able
to show its stuff (nor
will you be happy) in
typical subwoofer type
two-channel applications
where it is used to
compensate for
bass-challenged speakers
or where it is crossed
over too high so as to
intrude on the main
speakers. Used as
supplement to your main
speakers and set up
properly, the REL
Stentor III will blend
seamlessly with almost
any speaker and will
improve not only your
systems' bass response,
but it will improve your
system in areas you may
not have previously
associated with
subwoofers! I liked what
the Stentor III did for
my system so much, I
bought not one, but two
Stentor IIIs. My highest
recommendation!

|