| The
Klipschorn
Speaker
System |
|
|
|
Constantine
Soo |
|
3
August 2001 |
Specifications
Manufactured
in 1989
Sensitivity:
104dB/w/m
Bandwidth: 35Hz
– 17.5kHz +/-
3dB
Crossover
Frequencies: 400Hz
and 6kHz
Nominal Impedance:
8 ohms
Output: 124dB
maximum continuous
Power Handling:
100 watts maximum
continuous (400
watts peak)
Configuration:
Fully horn-loaded,
three-way system
Driver Components:
K77-M 1"
Phenolec tweeter,
K55-M 2"
Phenolec midrange,
K33-E
15"
folded-horn woofer
Weight: 167 lbs.
(75.7kg)
Dimensions:
52" ×
31.25" ×
28.5" (HxWxD)
Finish: Walnut
Oil, Mahogany, Oak
Oil, Oak Clear or
Black (review
pair)
Grilles: Black,
brown, woven cane
MSRP: $5,798/pair
Manufacturer:
Klipsch
Web: www.klipsch.com/
I
mentioned in my
Granite Audio
interconnect
review that I
would be posting a
review of my
Klipschorn
speakers, which I
put aside because
of commitments.
Recently, a reader
reignited the
flame by inquiring
into the status of
that review. Thank
you, reader.
Some
of you may have
contemplated
adding horns to
your systems.
While there are
magazines
trumpeting the
unique experiences
of horn
proponents, some
high-end
establishments
remain resistant.
One dealer
demonstrated his
idea of a horn’s
sound by cupping
his mouth with
both hands. As
advancements have
been realized in
almost all aspects
of modern playback
systems, horn
speakers are often
seen as a
throwback.
However, in spite
of the horn’s
century-old
operating
principle, it
continues to offer
advantages: the
simplicity of its
technology and an
efficiency that
permits the use of
low-power
amplifiers.
When
Stereophile
held its High end
Show in San
Francisco, I
returned to two
horn exhibitors’
rooms three days
in a row: Kochel
and Tannoy. Kochel
was a new Korean
company making
multi-driver horn
systems, utilizing
the classic
diaphragm-plus-throat
approach, while
Tannoy sported
their prestigious
dual-concentric
technology in the
Churchill
enclosure, the
core technology
having been
patented before
World War II. The
East and the West
met at a junction
in the form of the
horn. Both
exhibitors drove
their speakers
with low-output,
single-ended
triode amplifiers.
Since I couldn’t
afford either
speaker, I kept
coming back with
CDs in order to
etch in my mind
the two systems’
incomparable sonic
attributes. While
different
sounding, their
two crowning
attributes were
dynamic realism
and harmonic
coherency.
In
the spring of
1999, when a pair
of used 1989
Klipschorn became
available, I
seized upon the
moment and bought
them. According to
Klipsch, the 1989
and 2001 differ
only in an updated
crossover, which,
so far as I can
determine,
produces no
variance in sound.
Like the Kochel
and the Tannoy
systems, the
Klipschorns,
powered by
remarkably few
watts, can
transport you to
the realm of sonic
realism. The
Klipschorn
exhibits an
intensity of
dynamic transients
via tube or
solid-state
amplification. In
fact, I’d been
driving my
Klipschorns with
one Monarchy Audio
SM-70 with
extraordinary
results until
January 2001, when
I bought a second
SM-70 for
monoblock
operation.
Soundstaging
The
K-horn is a
three-way system
consisting of a
one-inch
compression
tweeter horn,
two-inch
compression
midrange horn and
a fifteen-inch
folded bass horn.
The
tweeter’s horn
sits on top of the
midrange horn and
covers the range
from 6kHz to
17.5kHz. Centrally
situated above the
bulk of the
cabinet and below
the tweeter’s
horn, the midrange’s
horn runs only
about half of the
width of the
cabinet and is the
main driver of the
system with a
specified
frequency range of
400Hz to 6kHz. The
main cabinet
houses the
rear-firing,
15-inch driver’s
folded bass horn,
which covers the
range from 400Hz
to its specified
limit of 35Hz.
Most
speakers sacrifice
soundstaging
definition when
placed wide apart.
The K-horns are
designed for large
rooms and will
generally function
satisfactorily in
opposite-corner
placement. In a
medium-sized room
like mine, I had
to make a few
minor adjustments
to optimize
performance.
Specifically,
the K-horns are
designed to fit
into the corners
of the long wall,
using the
adjoining
sidewalls as an
extension of the
bass horn. This
unusual placement
actually creates
the Klipschorn’s
life-size
soundstage.
Although the
dimensions of my
listening room, at
12’ × 17’ ×
8’ (W × L ×
H), can
accommodate the
recommended
long-wall
placement, it is
an open-ended
rectangle with
only one short
wall. Since this
asymmetry
precludes the
recommended
placement, I had
to use the short
walls’ corners.
At their initial
setup, the K-horns
inevitably became
overly
"toed-in,"
both channels
converging into a
sweet spot five
feet in front of
my listening
position, making
the soundstage
unfocused and
remote-sounding. I
toed them out
until each K-horn’s
midrange was
firing at the
listening
position. Then I
tilted the
speakers slightly
downward to have
the midrange fire
straight at me.
Thus set up, with
my listening
position
approximately
three meters away,
the K-horns throw
a precise center
stage with
excellent overall
soundstage
delineation.
The
height of the
midrange and
tweeter horns
further reinforce
the life-size
soundstage. For
our readers in San
Francisco, it
resembles the
Premier Orchestra
first floor
seating at the San
Francisco Symphony’s
Davis Hall.
And
yet, with their
impressive
soundstage depth,
horns are less
than peerless in
soundstage
crystallization.
For readers who
are adamant about
supreme image
depth, quite a few
planar and cone
speakers will do a
better job, e.g.,
my Apogee Duetta
Signatures.
Furthermore, the
K-horns’
midrange and
tweeter horns are
so highly
directional that
my ASC acoustic
treatments are
largely
unnecessary. The
Klipschorns sound
their best when
pointing directly
at you.
The
Sound
The
K-horns do not
possess the
timbral finesse of
the Audio Note
AN-E/D speakers I
recently reviewed,
but I do not hear
this shortcoming
as a serious
liability. Many
describe the horn
system’s sound
as artificial,
congested, flat
and unmusical. In
my listening room,
the K-horns
produce the
opposite effect,
and their
unrivaled dynamic
realism remains
evident and clean
even at high
volume levels.
The
K-horn’s bass
achieves its
maximum with
modest amplifier
power. The Audio
Review website
contains comments
from K-horn users,
mostly describing
the bass as
natural. Although
the low end can be
thunderous, it
maintains the
music’s critical
overtones, a
capability that
relates to the
naturalness many
K-horn users
proclaim. However,
larger rooms are a
prerequisite for
optimum bass.
Therefore, if good
bass is at the top
of your sonic
priorities, the
K-horn may not be
for you if your
room dimensions do
not allow for
corner placement.
Regarding
the Klipschorn’s
17.5kHz roll-off,
although I’ve
never seen such
limited top- end
specifications
from any speaker,
I have always been
happy with the
K-horns’ highs.
Other speakers in
the same room do
not provide more
perceptible
top-end
information. In
addition, the 3dB
roll-off slope may
be slow enough to
allow for
higher-frequency
information at
high listening
volumes.
Furthermore, with
CD’s 20kHz upper
limit, the
differences may be
too subtle to be
appreciable.
Some
studies show that
our brains can
process ultra-high
frequencies
although our
auditory senses
cannot seeming
hear beyond 20kHz,
even in our youth,
when our hearing
is at its best.
Certain theories
further claim that
our well being
depends on this
ultra-high-frequency
information, in
that it stimulates
the secretion of a
relaxation-inducing
chemical. This may
be significant
when playing SACD’s
or LPs. Perhaps
some day Klipsch
will better
address this
design aspect.
Amplification
Although
the Klipschorn’s
high sensitivity
invites the use of
low-power,
single-ended
triode amplifiers,
care must be taken
in choosing a
quiet preamp and a
power amp with low
idling noise. The
Wadia 27’s
versatile,
user-adjustable
output level and
digital volume
control are
supremely quiet,
making it an ideal
candidate in
driving most tube
amplifiers. The
Audio Note Western
Electric 300B
Quest monoblocks
(review in
progress), as
driven directly by
the Wadia 27
Decoding Computer,
produced a minute
level of
non-intrusive
idling hiss. The
Decware SE84C
(review in
progress) also
mated well with
the Wadia.
The
125-wpc,
EL-34-based Music
Reference RM9 II
was inappropriate,
in that it must be
set to the highest
feedback/lowest
output position in
conjunction with
the Wadia to keep
the idling noise
down. At this
setting, the RM9
II lost its
transparency.
Solid-state
amplifiers are
quiet during
idling. Both my
relatively
high-powered
Aragon 2004 and
Monarchy Audio
SM70 produced very
satisfying
results. The 2004
rendered a less
energetic
presentation, with
a softer top end,
smoother midrange
and thicker bass,
versus the SM70’s
crystalline top
end, detailed yet
slightly forward
midrange, and
dynamic lower
midrange and bass.
The
Decware SE84C, AN
Quest and MR RM9
II amplifiers
exhibited
increased idling
noise when a Krell
KRC-2 preamp
replaced the Wadia
27. Therefore, the
otherwise
excellent Krell,
with its high
output
capabilities, is
inappropriate for
driving the
Klipschorn with
some tube amps.
Coexistence
with Significant
Others
my
wife welcomed the
Klipschorns
positioned in
their corners. She
deplores the
imposing presence
of all other
speakers,
complaining
regularly about my
room-dividing
Apogees and
Genesis, and even
the mini-monitor
Celestion SL700s,
as they must all
be positioned well
into the listening
room.
The
Klipschorns will
coexist with your
other speaker
system in other
ways. You can
position new
speakers in front
of them with no
negative
consequences. For
example, to
minimize early
reflections from
the rear wall and
the sidewalls, I
usually place
other speaker
systems about
one-third into the
room. The rear
radiation of other
speakers will
engage the front
of the Klipschorn.
Since each
Klipschorn is now
angled at 30 to 45
degrees from the
long walls, corner
standing waves are
mostly diffused,
with the remaining
reflections from
the front of the
K-horns returning
to the rear of the
freestanding
speakers.
Therefore, you
need only treat
the sidewalls. I
have obtained
excellent results
using other
speaker systems in
the presence of
the Klipschorns.
As I never felt
the need to move
the Klipschorns
while using other
speakers, you
should beware that
the K-horns’
majestic yet
unobtrusive
presence may grow
on you.
Conclusion
The
Klipschorns tower
over my other
speakers in their
dynamic realism
and sheer
listenability. CDs
played through
them possess
lifelike,
compression-free
qualities.
Furthermore, the
horn midrange and
tweeter are
impressively
devoid of chaos in
the midst of
instrumental
outbursts.
Although
Klipschorn
possesses
impressive
detailing, realism
and musicality,
perfection doesn’t
exist in any
loudspeaker
system. While its
extreme
sensitivity
permits the use of
low-power purist
amplifiers, mating
it to a suitable
amp is crucial.
Even
after careful
consideration, it
may require a leap
of faith to
acquire a horn
system, since to
do so may alienate
you from orthodox
audiophiles. To
return to the High
End Show I mention
above, I was able
to loiter for long
periods of time in
the Kochel and
Tannoy sound rooms
because neither
room ever got
crowded. The true
believers stayed
away. Even
stepping in for a
peek would mean
excommunication.
That was about
three years ago.
With recent rave
reviews for the
European Avante
Garde horn
systems, a
heightened
awareness of a
well-designed horn’s
strengths may have
changed High-end
sentiments.
When
driven by my
25-wpc,
solid-state
single-ended class
A Monarchy Audio
SM-70, the K-horns
delivered
full-blown
dynamics and
convincing
dimensionality.
Tube amplifiers,
like the Audio
Note Quest
monoblocks (see my
recent review) and
the Decware SE84C
(review in
progress), provide
a mellower, more
musical sonic
signature without
dynamic sacrifice.
The technically
capable purist can
replace the
original crossover
with an external
three-way unit,
the doing of which
might elevate
timbre accuracy
and
dimensionality,
among other
performance
aspects.
My
sincerest thanks
go to Trey Cannon
of Klipsch for his
responsive replies
to my many
background
inquiries.

|