| Tyler
Acoustics,
Taylo
Reference
One
Loudspeakers |
|
Stuart
McCreary
Associate
Editor,
Hardware,
Positive
Feedback
magazine |
| 19
July
2000 |
Specifications
Frequency
response:
22-20k
Sensitivity:
89db
Power
handling: 20
watts minimum,
300 watts
maximum
Impedance:
8-Ohm nominal
Crossover
points: 80hz
and 2300hz
connections:
single, bi, or
tri wire/amp
Size:
20"w x
24"d x
45"h
Weight:
monitors 50
lbs. each,
bass modules
90 lbs. each
Price: $5,800/
pair
(270) 691-9500
Contact: www.tyleracoustics.com
"Ty
Lashbrook has
broken through
to the big
leagues. When
you factor in
the sweet
price, the
Taylo’s have
to be
considered, at
the very
least, a
division
winner. With
the right
supporting
equipment,
they might
even win the
Pennant."
It’s
been a while
since I’ve
had something
new in the
speaker
department.
The last
several years
have been
dominated by a
number of Von
Schweikert
designs—VR-4.5’s,
VR-6’s and
VR-8’s, to
be exact. I
really have
been spoiled.
They are all
excellent
loudspeakers
and tough
competition
for any
contender. The
latest
contender, and
the first non-
VR speaker in
three years,
comes from a
virtual
unknown in the
speaker world.
Have you heard
of Ty
Lashbrook and
Tyler
Acoustics? You
might have
caught him at
the last CES
show, but
probably like
me, you don’t
have a clue.
Let
me take a
minute to tell
you a little
about this
unassuming
gentleman from
Kentucky. This
is no
self-absorbed
audio guru. My
conversations
with "Ty"
have always
been pleasant,
light-hearted
and
refreshingly
BS free. In
fact, with his
southern drawl
and
self-effacing
manor, its
easy to like
this southern
good ‘ole
boy –so
easy, that
this normally
hard-boiled
Yankee lawyer
actually found
himself
rooting for
the guy and
hoping that
his
loudspeaker
would make the
grade.
Ty
is an
audiophile
with a
fifteen-year
history of
tweaking his
system and
experiencing
frustration
with the
results,
particularly
in the speaker
department.
Like many of
us, Ty thought
he might be
able to do it
better
himself.
Unlike many of
us, he
actually did
something
about it. He
experimented
with speaker
design and
concentrated
much of his
efforts on
cabinet
construction
and driver
selection. He
makes no bones
about it –
Madisound does
the basic
crossover
design using
MLSSA and his
selected
drivers and
cabinet
volume, then
Ty builds the
crossovers and
cabinets and
does the
critical
listening and
tweaking of
the circuit in
the fully
assembled
speaker. Let’s
be frank,
anyone with
decent
computer
skills with
today’s
software and
testing
hardware can
put together a
loudspeaker
that has good
frequency and
phase
measurements.
The
"art"
of
conventional
high-end
loudspeaker
design is in
messaging the
basic circuit
and minimizing
the cabinet
effects.
I
have listened
to quite a few
loudspeakers
that have had
excellent
measurements,
but fell far
short of
expectations
when subjected
to critical
listening. You
can make
slight changes
to the values
of caps, coils
and resisters
without seeing
any
appreciable
difference in
the frequency
curves. But
sit down for a
good listen
and voila! —it
sounds like a
very different
animal. It’s
axiomatic that
the audiophile
ear is far
more sensitive
than today’s
test
equipment.
Consequently,
the excellence
of a
loudspeaker is
more directly
related to the
quality of the
designer’s
ear and his
ability to
tweak the
circuit then
it is to the
test regimens
employed.
There
are some
loudspeaker
designers,
John Dunlavy
being the
archetype,
that think
that the
quality of the
individual
crossover
components and
the drivers
themselves are
not nearly as
significant as
a small group
of test
perameters. Ty
Lashbrook is
the polar
opposite. His
designs are
built around
the very best
crossover
parts and
drivers he can
afford and
time listening
rather than
obsessing over
test data.
Technical
Tidbits
Drivers
2-12"
Peerless
woofers,1-6.5"
Seas Magnesium
cone mid, and
1-1"
Scanspeak
Revelator
tweeter
Crossovers
Hovland
capacitors are
used in the
tweeter signal
path and
Geortz
Alpha-Core
inductors in
the midrange
signal path.
Steel laminate
inductors are
used in the
woofer signal
path. The
crossovers are
2nd and 3rd
order designs.
External
tri-wired
crossover
boxes are
available as
an option (the
review pair
came so
equipped)
Woofer
System
Dual 12"
compound
system with
one woofer on
the front and
the other
firing into a
sealed
compartment in
phase with the
front woofer
and wired in
series. The
woofers are
crossed over
at 80 Hz with
a 12db slope
The
Taylo
References are
obviously not
budget build
speakers. The
cabinets are
well-braced
1.5" MDF
in an eye
pleasing
stacked,
truncated
pyramid
configuration.
The ports on
both the base
module and
monitors are
front firing.
The veneering,
fit and finish
is impeccable.
There are
three sets of
binding posts
on the back
(two on the
monitor and
one on the
bass module)
so you can
fuss all you
want with tri-amping
or tri-wiring.
Tri-wiring is
a tweakers
dream enabling
you to
optimize your
cables for
bass,
midrange, and
treble….and
in case you
were
wondering, I’m
just anal
enough to do
it.
My
review pair
came with the
outboard
crossover
option. The
crossovers are
nested in an
elegant black
wood boxes
that are
spiked and
have removable
tops. The tops
are attached
with velcro
tabs, so it’s
a breeze to
pop the lids
and ogle the
insides. What
you find there
is a veritable
"Who’s
Who" of
high quality
parts
point-to-point
soldered with
Silver Sonic
wire. My pair
also came with
Silver Sonic
T-14 tri-wire
jumpers from
the crossover
boxes to the
speakers. I
highly
recommend the
external
crossover
option as I
suspect that
it does make a
sonic
difference in
terms of
minimizing
problems with
magnetic
inductance
between the
driver magnets
and the
crossover
coils and in
lessening
hysteresis
distortion. If
tri-wiring is
a tweakers
dream, then a
"pop
top"
external
crossover is
an audio wet
dream. OK,
show of hands
–how many of
you just can’t
leave your
audio gear
well enough
alone? You
obsessively
"modify"
every piece
you own,
tailoring the
sound to your
personal
taste:
"Hmmm…Let’s
see, I think I’ll
by-pass that
big Solen with
a Hovland cap…yeah,
that tweeters
just a tad hot
so I think I’ll
pad it with a
smidge more
resistance…
and while I’m
at it, let’s
make it a
Caddock."
Remember what
I said about
the
"art"
of high-end
speaker design
being the
process of
messaging the
crossover
circuit? Well,
damn right it
is!… and you
are hereby
invited to be
the artisan.
It’s just
soooo easy
with these pop
top crossover
boxes. You can’t
possibly cause
any permanent
damage. If
your changes
suck, just try
something
else, or wire
it back with
the original
value parts.
Hey man, if
you want to be
part of the
"Tribe,"
you’ve got
to "tune
your bow"
(high fives,
Dr. Gizmo)!
This creative,
roll up your
sleeve process
gives you a
real
connection to
the sound. It’s
very
satisfying to
roll your own
and make a
true custom
loudspeaker.
All
right then,
now that we’ve
looked at the
design,
components,
and specs,
does something
stand out at
you?.. I mean,
is something
flashing in
your head like
a Kmart Blue
Light Special?
Oh, Yeee-ah…..
show me duh
money! Is this
a lot of
speaker for
$5800, or
what! There
are many
speakers with
less in terms
of drivers,
crossover
parts and
cabinet
quality that
are selling
for well over
$10,000. I
know, I’ve
had a few of
them. In the
world of
high-end audio
loudspeakers,
this really is
factory
direct,
wholesale
pricing. If
these speakers
were merely
good,
competent
performers,
they would be
an excellent
value. The
good news,
Kmart
shoppers, is
that they’re
much better
than that.
The
Blue Light
Sound Tour
"Believe
me, you have
never heard
12"
woofers
sound like
this. The
sound is
reminiscent
of 6 or 8
inch drivers
– fast,
with no
overhang,
and yet with
the air
moving
authority of
a larger
driver."
I
love a big
soundstage,
not
exaggerated in
size, just big
as the
recording
venue. With
the Taylo
references, I
enjoyed a
soundstage
that was
intimate with
Clark Terry at
the Village
Gate and the
full size of
Carnegie Hall
when I played
Harry
Belafonte’s
and the Weaver’s
live albums.
The sweet spot
was a little
smaller than I’m
accustomed to
(the VR
speakers are
noted for a
two or three
person sweet
spot), but
once you get
locked in, it’s
huuuuuge in
there. This is
not what
people
sometimes call
a "head
in the vise
grip"
sweet spot,
but rather a
narrow window
that will
collapse to
one speaker or
the other if
you move your
head more then
a foot to
either side—fairly
typical of
dynamic driver
speakers that
do not have
any rear
firing
elements. The
optimum
placement of
the Taylo’s
ended up being
within a
fraction of an
inch of my
standard setup—not
surprising
since my wall
treatments for
primary and
secondary
reflection
points are
properly
aligned at
this location.
The speakers
are nine feet
out from the
front wall
with their
centers three
feet out from
the sidewalls.
The speaker
centerlines
are 8.5’
apart and my
head is eleven
feet from each
speaker on the
diagonal. A
22-degree
toe-in
provided
excellent
center fill
while
maintaining
the best stage
width and
image
separation. I
knew I had it
right when the
stage at
Carnegie Hall
took up the
entire front
of my room,
extending five
or more feet
beyond the
sidewalls. The
front of the
stage started
about a foot
back from the
front plane of
the speakers
and went back
ten or more
feet beyond
the front
wall. I haven’t
been to
Carnegie in
years, but I
would say that
this is pretty
close to life
sized.
The
placement of
instruments
and vocalists
on the stage
was precise
and three
dimensional
–on a par
with the very
best I have
heard in my
room. The
ability of
these speakers
to image
laterally well
outside the
speakers was
exemplary.
Many good
speakers, with
a proper set
up can do
this, but the
real trick is
to do it while
maintaining
proper depth
delineation.
Quite often,
images outside
the speaker
are limited to
a small plane
– from
slightly
forward of the
speaker to
slightly
behind it. The
Taylo’s
placed images
all the way
back past the
front corners
of the
listening room
. I like to
use Sting’s
"The Soul
Cages"
with
"Q-sound"
to test this.
For the first
time that I
can remember,
the Q-sound
phase tricks
worked
extraordinarily
well. I heard
distinct
sounds and
images coming
from behind me
at the four,
eight o’clock
positions
(with me in
the center of
the clock) as
well as from
the two, and
ten o’clock
positions and
most points
in-between.
When this is
done right it’s
quite an
amazing
carnival trick
that will
amaze your
unsuspecting
guests.
Using
the
Stereophile
test disc with
the left,
right, up and
over
"clicker"
imaging test,
I was again
impressed with
how well these
speakers
performed. The
test where the
image is to
form a
continuos
rainbow arc
above and
between the
two speakers,
was
particularly
noteworthy.
The Taylo’s
produced a
nearly
seamless arc
with very
little
flattening at
the apex. This
matches the
best
performance I
have heard to
date on this
test.
What
about the
tonal balance
of this
loudspeaker?…I’d
say close to
neutral, with
a slight lower
treble
emphasis. This
is not a
midrange
enhanced,
syrupy sweet
speaker. On
the great
loudspeaker
continuum, I
would place it
just to the
right of
neutral center
– a touch
lean, very
detailed,
almost
analytical
with its
treble detail.
The Revelator
tweeter is a
revelation of
treble detail—microscope
precise with
very little
grain or edge—but
, woe to the
‘phile with
a second rate
front end. You
will hear the
mediocrity
unmasked and
it may get
ugly. On the
other hand, if
you have a
friendly,
always polite
tweeter, you
might achieve
good sound,
but never
excellent
sound. The
resolution and
extension of
SACD disks on
the Sony 777ES
demands what
the Revelator
delivers –
treble
excellence.
The
Seas is "mmm"
good – a
"magnesium
midrange
marvel."
It’s agile,
uncolored and
speaks the
harmonic
truth. It
easily handles
the broad
range from 80
to 2300hz,
which is
precisely the
broad band I
like to see in
a three-way
design. Get
the midrange
right and just
supplement the
top and bottom
– that’s
the ticket.
The higher
crossover
point avoids
the 1000 to
2000 Hz range
that is often
a ragged
trouble spot
for soft dome
tweeters and
the 80 Hz bass
crossover
keeps the
singing in the
midrange, not
the woofer. I
really can’t
find anything
truly negative
about this
speaker’s
midrange
performance. I
suppose that
if I had to be
critical (duh…it’s
my job), I
would wish for
a smidge more
lower midrange
warmth and
body. The good
news is that
it was easy
for me to dial
this in with
some tweaks to
the midrange
crossover.
Bass
is
surprisingly
fast and tight
for two
12"
woofers. As
advertised,
the compound
loading of
these drivers
really
minimizes cone
excursion and
distortion.
The bass
extension is
good, but not
earth shaking.
I think the
response
starts to
deviate from
flat below
30hz. The
specs are
correct in
that there is
usable bass at
22 Hz, but the
3db down point
in my room (14’
× 29’) is
probably about
28hz. Ty says
he detests
bloated bass,
so the bass
alignment of
these speakers
is
purposefully
lean. The
internal
volume of the
bass modules
are made
slightly
smaller than
what the
Peerless 12’s
and the design
software calls
for. This
tends to raise
the Q of the
system and
makes it more
critically
damped. This
is my first
experience
with this type
of bass
loading and I
must say that
I’m very
impressed.
Believe me,
you have never
heard 12"
woofers sound
like this. The
sound is
reminiscent of
6 or 8 inch
drivers –
fast, with no
overhang, and
yet with the
air moving
authority of a
larger driver.
With
an SACD front
end and the
amazing Bel
Canto Evo
amplifier on
board, the two
words that
best describe
my system’s
sound are
transparency
and agility.
By
transparent, I
mean nearly
devoid of any
coloration,
background
noise or
distortion.
The sense of
immediacy is
almost
excruciating.
I use the word
"agility"
rather than
"speed"
because I
think it more
aptly
describes the
effortless
dodging and
weaving of the
musical
prizefight --
the system’s
ability to
stop and start
on a dime and
then hit you
with the
hay-maker that
comes out of
nowhere.
Agility
connotes a
certain grace
and balance.
Indeed, this
system has it
in spades. It
can render the
most subtle
nuances and
the finest
gradations of
micro-dynamics
with what can
only be
described as
graceful
organic
rightness.
How
do I know my
system sounds
like this?
Quite
obviously, it’s
because the
Taylo
Reference
Speakers are
letting it all
come through
with
outstanding
fidelity. A
bloated,
stodgy
loudspeaker
would kill
this magic.
Heck, even a
slightly
forgiving
speaker could
make the
Goosebumps
disappear.
This is high
praise indeed.
I think I have
one of the
best front
ends available
today (Sony
777ES SACD),
the right
interconnects
and cables
(Harmonic
Technology and
Analysis Plus)
coupled with
THE best
amplifier (The
Bel Canto Evo).
In this heady
setting, the
Taylos aren’t
outclassed--they’re
right at home.
Checking
out at the
Express Line
Tyler
Acoustics has
produced a
first rate
loudspeaker in
the Taylo
References.
They are a
testament to
what a clever
audiophile can
do with a
sound
crossover
design, robust
cabinets and
near state of
the art
drivers and
crossover
components.
No, you don’t
have to learn
the mystical
art of speaker
design at a
temple in
Tibet. You don’t
have to be
"grasshopper"
to one of the
great masters
for many years
to
"earn"
the right to
produce a
great product.
No, armed with
only a good
set of ears
and a penchant
for quality,
Ty Lashbrook
has broken
through to the
big leagues.
When you
factor in the
sweet price,
the Taylo’s
have to be
considered, at
the very
least, a
division
winner. With
the right
supporting
equipment,
they might
even win the
Pennant.

|