| The Escalante Design Fremont |
| What More Could A Man Want |
| |
|
April 2006 |
Should’ve
kept them boxes
Without knowing it I have been a huge fan of
the work of loudspeaker designer
extraordinaire Tierry Budge for more than a
decade. His handiwork turned up in some of the
early Wilson Audio designs (circa 1989-1992),
Voce Divina, and in the recent past, Talon
Audio. The Talon Audio Peregrine X
loudspeakers had been my reference for a
longtime (if you’re an audio critic, owning
anything for more than five years is
considered a long time). I was absolutely in
love with everything about these speakers;
from their drop-dead gorgeous high-gloss black
with chrome trim cabinets, to their unique
“eagle talon” shaped “Nest” stands. They
boasted bass down below 20Hz and were as
musical as all get out, especially after I had
them upgraded with Talon’s Common Mode
Rejection Circuit (CMRC). The only thing I
didn’t like about the Peregrines was that they
came in four huge boxes and at the time, my
girlfriend Mittie and I were in a space
challenged condo a stone’s throw away from the
John Hancock Building in downtown Chicago.
I eventually rented a storage space so that I
could have a place to store these and other
boxes that the various components of my system
came in; not to mention the fact that Mittie
had a shoe collection that could make Imelda
Marcos say “Damn girl! You got a lot of
shoes!” So for the first few years that I
owned the Peregrines, I kept their boxes in
storage. But, as hard to believe as it might
be, Imelda … er, uh, I mean Mittie’s shoe
collection actually grew and space was already
at a premium. Besides, I couldn’t imagine a
scenario under which I’d part with my
speakers, so I decided to free up some storage
space by throwing away those big boxes. But I
only got rid of the speaker boxes. I kept the
stand boxes because they had a panel of MDF in
the bottom of them and were great for packing
away heavy items. A few years later, they
really came in handy as I moved into the
spacious house I have now.
Escaping
to Escalante
It was at about this time that Tierry Budge
left Talon (for reasons best not discussed
here) and hooked up with Matt Waldron, an
earnest and business-savvy young musician who
lived near Budge in Provo, Utah. Matt admired
Tierry’s speaker building prowess, which he
knew to be matched only by his decency and
work ethic. Before long Matt convinced Tierry
to co-found Escalante Design.
Matt,
essentially speaking, wanted to provide Tierry
with an environment in which he could focus
all of his energy on speaker design and see
many of his design theories through to
fruition. Escalante’s first offering was the
highly praised Pinyon mini-monitor followed
closely by its natural partner, the Uinta
subwoofer. I was blown away by this
combination’s musicality and flexibility for
two-channel audio and multi-channel home
theater applications and awarded them a Stereo
Times
Most Wanted Component
award in 2005 ( photo
above: Matt and our fearless leader CP).
But almost immediately, Budge had ideas for a
larger monitor that would build upon all of
the musical attributes of the Pinyon/Uinta
system. It’s called the Fremont and it is the
subject of this review.
As I mentioned earlier, Budge, prior to
joining Talon, worked for Wilson Audio (as
Manager of Research and Development.) He was
directly responsible for the WATT III, Puppy
2, WHOW 2, WAMM VI, and did much of the ground
work for what would become the Wilson Grand
Slam. At Talon, he designed the controversial
and wildly popular Khorus loudspeaker, Roc
subwoofer, and others including my Peregrine
X’s. His efforts thus far with Escalante have
been exceptional as he has worked tirelessly
to constantly dig out every last octave and
decibel of music that he can. That brings us
to the Fremont.
Describing the Fremont is fairly simple.
First, take a look at the Escalante Pinyon,
now imagine if it had been spending a lot of
time around Barry Bonds the last few years.
Get my meaning? For a monitor, it’s HUGE! In
fact, Budge doesn’t just call it a monitor.
Instead, he calls it a “megamonitor.” It’s 14”
wide, by 28.5” tall, and 18” deep and weighs
in at 110lbs! The standard cabinet is made
from bamboo, believe it or not, and is highly
dense not to mention extremely attractive.
They also have stylish brushed aluminum inlays
which add to the speaker’s aesthetic elegance.
Escalante offers several other cabinet
finishes including the show-stopping BMW®
Indianapolis Red Metallic that they showed in
their demo room at T.H.E Show.
The Fremont uses two direct coupled 12”
bass-mid drivers and the famous Scanspeak
Revelator R2904 tweeter. There are two slot
ports bookending the tweeter and a slick
looking laser cut aluminum Escalante logo at
the bottom. At the rear you’ll find only a
single set of Cardas speaker connections.
Waldron designed a slick looking and nicely
finished stand that puts the tweeters right at
ear height. Despite its massive proportions
this is a very attractive package and should
not cause your significant other any
decorating stress.
Technically speaking …
I interviewed Tierry Budge in order to ensure
that the design intent of the Fremont was
accurately conveyed to you, dear readers. The
Fremont is 93-dB
sensitive. However, this is somewhat deceptive
in that it is very friendly to amplifiers (a
good thing.) Also, the bandwidth is
18Hz-50kHz, +/- 3dB. According to Budge, the
crossover points were a bit trickier. “At
80Hz, there is a crossover point between the
internal and external woofer. The cone of the
external woofer takes the response on up to
nearly 500Hz. It's at this point that a very
delicate balancing act had to be struck,” said
Budge. “If we didn't have the ‘group-phase’
loading, the woofer would have a rise-time
somewhere above 3000uS (probably closer to
5000uS.) However, in this loading the woofer
has a 70uS rise-time…faster than the typical
high-end, 2" dome midrange,” said Budge.
This meant that Budge would design the
dust-cap of the woofer from-the-ground-up.
“The dust-cap had to be a very specific size
and geometry to roll-in naturally where the
cone no longer radiated semi-omnidirectionally.
Because of its shape and size, it radiates
nearly omnidirectionally all the way up to
3.2kHz (approximately). Since the tweeter
itself is crossed in at 2.5kHz (and continues
to 50k), the whole speaker radiates nearly
omni-directionally - or, at least until about
22kHz, where the tweeter gradually becomes
less and less omnidirectional. Because the
dust-cap began radiating like a dome midrange,
it necessitated my specifying the use of
several, very low-q materials; three, to be
exact; four, if you include the bonding
agent.”
The "speed" that Budge needed to accomplish a
believable midrange, brought along with it
some added benefits. “The 12" woofer (in this
loading only) can complete 11 complete
excursion cycles while the best quality
audiophile 5.25” drivers can only complete
one,” said Budge. This type of response makes
for a speaker that is not only easier on small
amplifiers, but also has a tendency to move a
fairly extreme amount of air without having to
accomplish massive excursions themselves.
Additionally, intermodulation is kept at
extremely low levels. All of this not only
makes the speaker more drivable, but far more
comfortable at high volumes as well.
The
payoff
So what is the sonic payoff for all of this
techno-speak? I got a loudspeaker with
stunning top-to-bottom resolution, power, and
lifelike presentation. In other words, one of
the most satisfying music listening
experiences I have ever had. It also means
that I will be looking for boxes to pack my
beloved Peregrine X’s in.
I won’t go into a detailed discussion about
what the Fremonts did better than the Talons
to prompt the change. The change itself says
enough. I’ll let it suffice to say that no
other speaker that has entered my home (and
there have been a lot of them) has made me
feel the way about listening to music that the
Fremonts have.
Fresh out of the box (or crates in this case)
the Fremonts sounded like you might expect, a
little too tight on the low end and a bit
etched up top. The midrange, on the other
hand, showed the promise of what was to come.
Imaging was very nice and stage depth was
surprisingly well delineated. But after about
200 hours of break in, everything was as I
liked it.
To
me, no other type of recording can allow you
to fully evaluate the performance of a
loudspeaker than a good live recording. And
when it comes to live recordings, it doesn’t
get much better than the late Eva Cassidy’s
Live at Blues Alley [Blix Street
GS-10046]. If there was ever an award for most
used recording during a hi-fi show, it would
be the second track on this disc, “Stormy
Monday.” Cassidy’s voice and vocal styling was
made for a venue like this. She personalizes
every song with pure soul and passion. And
when you can gain a sense of that while this
recording is being played on your system, you
truly have something special. The Fremonts
rendered her voice holographically, letting it
seem to hover in three-dimensional space. The
position of her bandmates within the
soundstage is easily discernable as is the
characteristics of
their instruments. That Budge can get the
dust-cap on the bass driver to move so fast
that it can reproduce midrange detail of this
level is astonishing. And the ability of the
Fremonts to convey the size of the venue is
eerie, especially while listening in the dark,
as I often do.
Dynamics
are superb. I put on the soundtrack to the
wonderful Latin-jazz documentary, Calle 54
[Blue Note] and listened to the brilliant
pianist Chano Dóminguez perform “Oye Cómo
Viene.” Dominguez’s fingers seem to dance
across the keys and produce music that is
light, yet very rhythmic. The Fremonts
reminded me that the piano is essentially a
percussive instrument because I could hear the
hammer strikes on the strings and the decaying
vibration that follows. This is nerdy stuff
but man is it cool. I found myself digging up
live recordings just so I could see what else
I could hear that I hadn’t before.
Now I know some of you bass-lovin’ hamsters
out there are reading this and saying: “This
is all cute Dave, but get to the good part.
Can these things crush my skull with some
subterranean bass or not?” The answer, oh
inquisitive ones is: WHAT DO YOU THINK A PAIR
OF 12” WOOFERS THAT DIP DOWN TO 18HZ ARE GONNA
DO FOR YOU! Don’t forget that the path that
has brought Tierry Budge to where he is was
paved by lessons learned from designing
subwoofers and bass enclosures for Wilson,
Voce Divina, and Talon. Lord knows if the
Talons had nothing else they had thunderous
bass. Yes, the Fremonts can get into some
serious throw-down when it comes to bass. Try
listening to any Danny Elfman soundtrack and
prepare to be blown away. My personal favorite
is the Planet of the Apes soundtrack
[Sony]. From start to finish this disc is
loaded with dazzling dynamics and bass deep
enough to be felt on Dante’s fifth level.
Particularly track four, “The Hunt.”
Percussions slam! Cymbals crash! And low level
energy is reproduced with weight and presence.
Listening to this track made me feel as though
I was having a Jumanji experience complete
with animals smashing through my 56” Hitachi.
Conclusion
High-end audio is a funny business and you
never know where the next great thing is going
to come from. I spent a lot of time admiring
this loudspeaker at this past T.H.E. Show and
now I’m enjoying it on a daily basis in my
home. At the Show it was partnered up with the
incredible Butler Audio Monad tube monoblocks
and showed that even on low-powered tube amps
you can still get an incredible amount of
dynamics and deep bass. At home, I’ve also
heard the Fremonts on $50K worth of
solid-state amplification from Tidal Audio,
the $3K Luminance KST-150, and the ICE-Module
powered Red Dragon Audio Leviathan mono amps,
and let me tell you, they sounded stellar with
all of them.
But beware, they’ll be honest with you about
the quality of your amplification and you will
hear the differences between components. I
used one amp that has a known tendency to be a
little bright sounding and the Fremonts did
not sugarcoat that. Now of course if you like
bright sounding amps then the Fremonts won’t
cover up what you enjoy. The same applies to
tube amp lovers or folks who like their music
slightly to the warm side of neutral. The
Fremonts simply reveal what you love about
rest of the components in your system. I don’t
know about you, but when I put together a
system based on a certain sonic
characteristic, I don’t want to finish off the
system with a speaker that undoes everything I
tried to do. Just give me the truth from my
discs. Give me the magic of the live
performance. Give me the Escalante Design
Fremonts.
Dave Thomas
______________
Specifications
Design Type: Direct Coupled
Woofer: 2 x 12"
Tweeter: ring radiator, soft-dome
Freq. Response: 18Hz - 50kHz
Amp: 1 - 1000 watts
Sensitivity: 93 dB
Impedance: 8 Ohms nominal
Height: 28.5 inches (73cm)
Width: 14 inches (36cm)
Depth: 18 inches (46cm)
Weight: 100 lbs. each (kg)
Shipping Weight: 160 lbs. each (73kg)
Stand Dimensions
Height: 16 inches (41cm)
Width: 14 inches (36cm)
Depth: 18 inches (46cm)
Weight: 54 lbs. each (25kg)
Shipping Weight: 112 lbs. each (51kg)
Price:
$14,990.00/pair
Address
Escalante Design
3585 N. University Ave. #200
Provo UT 84604 USA
Phone: 801-373-4712
E-mail:
people@escalantedesigns.com
Website:
http://www.escalantedesigns.com

|