| The
Musse
Audio
Reference
Two NF
Loudspeakers |
|
Follow
Up
Report |
|
Henry
Wilkenson |
|
15
March 2002 |
Specifications
Enclosure
Type: Two way
ported design
Tweeter: One
1" soft dome
Woofer: One
6.5" carbon
Fiber woofer
Frequency
Response: 35 Hz to
20 Hz +/- 3db
Sensitivity: 87db
@ 1m/2.8 v
Impedance: 8 ohms
Rated Power
requirement: 50 to
200 watts RMS
Port tuning
frequency: 29 Hz
Equipped with 5
way binding posts
Price: $5,000.00
per pair
Address
Musse Audio Pte
Ltd.
151 Chin Swee Road
#06-05/07
Manhattan House
Singapore 169876
Tel: 60-19-3139816
Fax: 60-3-31912340
Web: www.musseaudio.com
It
has always been a
rule of thumb that
small, stand
mounted speakers
had special sonic
virtues. These
qualities centered
around, but were
not limited to,
their ability
float a large and
convincing image.
Speed and
transparency
throughout the
midrange was
another area where
the smaller
speakers were said
to out perform
their floor
standing brethren.
However, if you
opted for the
small speakers
sonic abilities,
you had to give up
anything
resembling a
convincing low
end. Many people
felt that the
"bottom"
could be ignored
since the majority
of the music
resided in the
mid-range anyway.
While
Perry and I live
in adjoining
states,
fortunately public
transportation is
such that it is a
relatively quick
and easy trip for
me to get over to
his place.
Recently, I was
there after some
major changes were
made to his
system.
Unbeknownst to me,
the new Talon Roc
subwoofer was
added to the
system. The
results left
others in the
room, as well as
me, speechless
(very tricky
Perry). I thought
that a major
improvement had
been made to his
system with the
addition of the
new Talon Khorus X
speakers. As good
as the old Talons
were, the X's
performance places
them head and
shoulders above
them. However, the
new sub takes the
system to a much
higher level of
musicality. This
is not a small
incremental
improvement;
rather, it is a
quantum
improvement.
Seldom have I been
witness to this
level of
improvement being
achieved in one
step. It really
has to be heard in
order to be
believed. You will
be hearing much
more about this
sub as time goes
on. The point here
is simply this:
the bass is very
important to the
overall musical
spectrum.
Former
ST contributor Tim
Shea, in his
thorough and
insightful review
of the Musse
Two's, commented
upon the
capabilities of
the Musse Two's in
this area. The
folks at Musse
Audio have joined
the ranks of a
growing number of
manufactures that
have recognized
the need and
desirability of
having a decent
low end, even in
small speakers.
As
Tim stated in his
review, the Musses
are a beautifully
finished, two-way
monitor. However,
given their large
size, these
speakers deserve
to have dedicated
stands that would
offer better
support and
stability. The
stands that are
shown in the
picture are the
ones that I used
and I found them
to be inadequate
for this speaker.
The top plate is
very small; as a
result the
speakers are
capable of being
easily knocked
over.
My
second complaint
concerns the five
way binding posts
on the rear. The
two pair of
binding post is
set a little too
close together and
the center post is
too large for many
spade lugs to fit
over. This
necessitates the
need to use banana
plugs; this is my
least favorite way
of connecting
speaker wire. A
set of dedicated
jumpers should
also be included
for those people
who wish to use a
single run of
speaker wire.
While Cardas
binding posts are
available as an
option, I feel
that at this price
level, they should
be standard issue.
Those
nits aside, these
are fine speakers.
I found their
overall sonic
perspective to be
a little on the
laid back side.
That works just
fine for me.
Tonally I have to
say that they are
somewhat warm
sounding. While
the lateral
imaging is good,
the images across
the stage were not
quite as well
defined as I heard
from the
Eggleston's. They
also didn't quite
match the
Eggleston's unique
ability to resolve
tonal information.
While the
Egglestons were
not quite as warm
overall as the
Musses, they
served up a richer
tonal palate. For
instance, the
differences
between Coltrane
and Adderley on
Miles Davis, Kind
of Blue
[Columbia Legacy
CK 64935] was more
clearly delineated
with the
Egglestons. The
Reference Two's
didn't quite match
the Fontaines in
treble extension
or openness. I
wouldn't say that
they were veiled,
however, in direct
comparison to the
Fontaines you can
readily hear the
Egglestons have
the edge in this
area.
Where
the Reference Twos
really shine is
when it comes time
to rock. Their
low-end extension
provided more body
and more
foundation to the
music. Curtis
Lundy's
"Players
Anthem," from
the Against All
Odds CD [Just
in Time Just
129-2], begins
with a prominent
bass intro that
the Reference Twos
handle
exceptionally
well. In this
regard, you forget
that you are
listening to a
stand-mounted
monitor. If the
lights were out,
you could be
fooled into
thinking that you
were listening to
a floor stander.
Etta James'
"Here I
Am," from
her, Life, Love
& The Blues
[Private Music
01005-82162-2] was
recorded with a
very prominent
bass guitar
accompaniment that
undulates
throughout the
song. While larger
satellite and
sub-woofer
combinations
perform far better
with this piece,
the Reference Twos
still served the
music very well.
This is foot
tapping dance
music that a
polite, base shy
speaker just
wouldn't be able
handle very well.
I
feel that this
speaker is better
suited to jazz,
pop and rock
music. For Baroque
or other classical
works, the slight
lack of
transparency that
I mentioned
earlier would be
problematic. The
"Menuet pour
la petit gnomide,"
from Marc
Antoine
Charpentier,
Divertissements
Airs et Concerts,
William Christie
Les Arts
Florissants, [Erato
25485] is a piece
that once heard on
a really
transparent system
will make a
lasting
impression. The
limitation in
treble extension
and transparency
of the Reference
Twos become quite
evident here.
These problems
were minimized
while using the
Audience speaker
cables and
interconnects.
This combination
produced a good
even tonal balance
while reaching the
speaker's limits
of speed and
transparency. I
have to wonder if
this might be the
sonic price that
is paid for the
lack of a pair of
dedicated stands.
I
find the high
number of speakers
competing in the
five
thousand-dollar
price range to be
astonishing. While
I will never
consider anything
in this price
range to be a
"bargain",
I do acknowledge
that the speakers
I have heard in
this range do
consistently offer
superior
performance levels
over less
expensive ones.
While
sonic compromises
have to be made
with any speaker,
regardless of
price, the
performance level
of monitor
speakers has risen
considerably in
the past few
years. During my
time with them, I
found the
Reference Twos
very musical and
easy to listen to
for extended
periods. At no
time were they in
any way hard or
harsh sounding,
nor were they
trying to excel at
only one or two
sonic attributes.
Rather they seemed
to strive for a
good musically
balanced sound. In
that, they were
successful.
If
the issues that I
raised previously
are addressed, I
believe that the
Musse Reference
Twos will be
competitive with
anything in its
price class.
Publisher's
comments:
I must concur with
Henry's finding of
the Musse
Reference NF
monitors. They
don't provide the
last nth of detail
in the upper
frequencies as
other designs may.
But I am adamant
that it isn't
rolling off the
treble either.
Here's my reason.
My experience has
shown that no
matter the
transducer, when
the bass balance
isn't adequate,
more times than
not, the treble
excels at a pace
that gives the
treble the
appearance of
possessing a halo.
This is typical in
high end audio.
Worse, treble this
disproportionate
to the audio
spectrum causes
this listener to
duck at every
dynamic peak on a
song. The Talon X
is the first
loudspeaker that
taught me a new
appreciation of
what I've
discerned as the
proper tonal nourishment
all the way up the
audio spectrum by
virtue of its unequaled
bass. The
Reference 2's do
this nifty feat
surprisingly well.
It
is to this end,
that I find it so
fascinating that
even the most
skillful of
audiophiles find
Musse Audio
Reference 2's
slightly rolled
sounding. With a
loudspeaker that
can unfurl bass in
all of its many
shades and colors,
(albeit in a
slightly smaller
picture than the
bigger and
costlier Rosinante'
Dulcineas and the
Talon Khorus X),
it would be easy
to assume the top
end isn't as
extended as
certain
competitors.
Again, it is not
rolled off. It's
no coincidence
this very argument
was made against
the Dulcinea and
Khorus X,
especially since
both do bass
respectively among
the best in their
class. I will say
that the Musse's
laid back
personality and
wonderful harmonic
integrity will do
more for the music
lover than Joe
audiophile looking
for the
loudspeaker of the
month. Especially
to the lover of
the '60's, most
dominate voices in
jazz like Ella
Fitzgerald, Billie
Holiday, Sarah
Vaughn and Betty
Carter. For
listening through
the Musse's with
their exquisite
upper bass speed
and articulation,
adds exactly what
all the reissues
have attempted to
do: add warmth and
resolution.
Lastly,
because they play
louder than many
would think
possible due to
their diminutive
stature,
headbangers who
love to crank but
are cramped for
space should all
rejoice. This
speaker doesn't
just go but it
also goes low. The
Musse Reference is
a loudspeaker that
simply sounds
right to these
ears and needn't
apologize for its
non-aggressive,
sultry
performance. If
musical enjoyment
is your goal then
you then this is
one speaker you
ought to audition.

|