|
Talon Audio's Peregrine X |
|
|
|
Ian Weber & Dave Thomas |
|
8 March 2003 |
Specifications
Specifications
Height - monitor only: 61 cm (24")/Overall: 109 cm
(43")
Width 30.5 cm (12")
Depth: 48 cm (19")
Weight with stand: 74 kg (163 lbs.)
Bandwidth: 19 Hz - 25 kHz
Power Handling: 1-1000 Watts
Nominal impedance: 8 Ohms
Price: $9,500 / with stands: $11,500
Address:
Talon Audio Technologies, Inc.
5175 South Green Pine Drive
Murray, UT 84123
Telephone: 801-619-9000
Fax: 801-619-9001
Website:
www.talonaudio.com
About a year and a half ago, I came to the conclusion
that I was tired of upgrading my speakers. Although
buying a new pair of speakers every two months was
entertaining and exciting, it also became time
consuming and rather arduous. Hereafter, I reached
the seemingly obvious verdict that if I bought the
best speaker made I would not have a reason, or even
the ability, to upgrade. So, I set out on my quest,
like Indiana Jones searching for the Holy Grail, to
find the illusive "best" bookshelf speaker. For me,
bookshelf speakers are a necessity, as I don't have
room for a floor standing speaker. I thoroughly
researched everything produced knowing that for the
first time in my lie, money was no object. My initial
search ended with the Dynaudio Confidence 3 and the
Sonus Faber Guaneri Homage. The Dynaudios were chosen
for their great top end, rich midrange and brawny
bass. Their rich mix of qualities made them
competitive with some of the best floor standers in
production. On the other hand, the Guaneris were
nominated for their magical midrange and their
beautiful looks. Just as I had reached a decision I
came across a new speaker from an innovative company.
After a little bit of research I knew the Talon
Peregrine X had the potential to be the best
bookshelf speaker in the world. Did I find the Holy
Grail?
All three of the aforementioned speakers are
particularly attractive. The Sonus Faber's petite
size, beautiful craftsmanship and design make them
some of the most beautiful speakers, in my eyes, ever
created. The Talons embody the beauty of simplicity.
Talon took the traditional speaker shape, modernized
with chrome and coupled it to their Nest stands that
belong in the MOMA. Who knew a box could look so
good? The Talon's design resembles a refined muscle
car while the Guaneri's have the sophisticated
appearance of a small Italian sports car. The
Dynaudios are simple and unobtrusive but are a
tribute to building a sturdy non-resonant cabinet. In
the end, the importance of having extended bass
response led me to choose the Talons over the
Guaneris. Integrated bass was of particular
importance, as a sub is not an option in my small
listening room. Furthermore, I have yet to hear a
powered external sub rival passive integrated bass.
The Dynaudios, although being nearly perfect, lacked
the midrange magic of the other two that I value so
highly, and were hence out of the running. I ordered
the Talons and waited for my grail to arrive!
The Talons arrived in huge cardboard boxes and were
packed well enough to survive just about any
thrashing. Once out and set up, the Peregrines have a
commanding presence in any room, which certainly has
both positive and negative aspects. Their large size
and flashy appearance make it aesthetically difficult
for them to be integrated into their surroundings. I
began the arduous task of breaking them in and played
them continuously for weeks on end. After significant
play-time, their sound homogenized and I deemed them
ready for review.
The Peregrine X is the second ranked speaker in the
Talon line and is their finest stand mounted
transducer. Each monitor consists of two ten-inch
drivers and a one-and-a-half inch tweeter. The large,
back-to-back woofers act as both a midrange and a
woofer. All of this is enclosed in a huge rectangular
two-foot tall package. The binding posts are of the
new Cardas variety and only allow for spades and
single wiring. Although this radical design slightly
limits your choice of speaker cables, it does allow
for a very snug fit.
These speakers are particularly easy to set up. All
Talons are designed to be very room friendly and they
work well in most location, however these qualities
especially apply to the Peregrines as they include a
forward facing port that allows them to be placed
very close to walls. Generally rear ported speakers
require space behind them for the port to "breath,"
but these Talons exhale into the room from the front,
hence placement close to the front wall is possible.
Most of the Talons have a similar "family" sound, and
the Peregrines are no different. In fact, the
Peregrines are said to sound almost exactly like the
famed Khorus X. I once had a dealer tell me that he
could only tell the difference between the two
speakers on 3 out of every 8 songs. Their main
difference lies in a slight reduction in upper treble
sparkle and sheen, but most of that has been ironed
out with the most recent of crossover upgrades. Talon
is constantly redesigning and upgrading their
crossover designs and I had one of the most recent
versions installed in my set. Crossovers change the
specifications of the speaker, and this version is
said to have raised the efficiency to about 93 db and
raised bass-depth by about 1 hertz. The specs look
good, but how do they sound?
Sound Off…
The Peregrines' boast a very atypical sound. It took
me about 10 -15 hours to become accustomed to it. My
initial reaction was that they sounded constipated,
blurred, muffled and just plain unpleasant. Still,
after some time, I became accustomed with their style
of reproducing sound, so accustomed in fact, that I
now find most other speakers are lacking something.
For a reason I cannot quite understand, the
Peregrines' sound is not immediately easily enjoyed.
It appears that one must become sincerely accustomed
to their character before judging them seriously, and
admittedly, this transition requires time. Once
familiarized, the sound is very laidback, warm and
inviting. Music is rarely harsh or fatiguing yet
miraculously, the speakers manage to display nearly
all of the detail in the recording. The detail,
however, is not presented in the regular audiophile
fashion. The sounds and minutiae are, in a way,
gently swept into the soundstage, relying on the
listener's awareness to pick them out. The music is
not hyped or artificial sounding, instead it is
reproduced in the most natural manner I have heard
from a transducer. Most first time listeners find
this element of the speaker to be a detraction, but I
unquestionably disagree. Many prefer the sound of
other speakers because their details are overly
discrete and the sound is glorified. The Talon is
anything but, and the details are there but they are
married with the music. Although the Peregrines force
the listener to be more aware and listen in a
different form, they reward him or her with a wealth
of detail presented in the most refined manner I have
come across. I would have to estimate that much of
this exquisite non-fatiguing detail retrieval is
partially due to their dead quiet backdrop and their
carefully designed crossovers. Overall, their manner
of reproducing music is very distinct and limited to
only a handful of speakers, a quality only
appreciated by those who are acquainted with its
subtle beauty.
Admittedly, these speakers have few weaknesses. In
general, the Peregrines' have a very balanced sound:
there is a seamless integration of the tweeter and
the mid/bass drivers. The upper highs are pristine,
clear and grainless. They have the ability to sparkle
and extend like Esotar equipped speakers, without the
Hi-Fi unnaturalness. The bass on these speakers is
essentially the same as that on the Khorus X, and
hence it rivals the best on the market. These tandem
drivers put out more bass than almost any sub I have
ever heard and it's the fastest, tightest, cleanest
and most tuneful bass I have heard from any speaker
system to date. If this speaker's sound has a fault
then maybe it's in the midrange. The midrange is
probably the best I've heard, which says plenty, but
not quite as good as this transducers lowest octave
and treble output capabilities. The recent
improvements to the crossover design have eliminated
this drawback in almost every facet, but a tad more
warmth would be welcome. This statement, however,
must be taken with a grain of salt, as it's only
apparent in a handful of recordings and possibly due
to my time spent with amplifiers, which are known to
be a bit reticent and rather cold in the midrange.
Transparency and Imaging
In my opinion these are the most important aspects of
any loudspeaker. How can one mistake a stereo
reproduction for a live performance if the sound is
coming from two distinct sources? The Talons are
Audio Physic-like in their disappearing act.
Everything but the most extreme of high frequencies
appears to emanate, beautifully structured, from the
area in front of you. The soundstage is
oh-so-three-dimensional, allowing the listener to see
deep into the recording and place the singer,
drummer, etc., in their respective positions, both
side-to-side and front to back. The speakers present
an uncannily believable image with spatial definition
that is as good as it gets.
The Talon's are also astonishingly transparent. The
soundstage's fluidity and unity is jaw dropping and
incomparable to anything I have personally
experienced. The see-through clarity gives one the
notion that the collection of sounds is completely
unified and utterly realistic. It is the Peregrines'
excellence in these two aspects of musical
reproduction that make them truly state of the art.
Conclusion
Overall, if I had one real nit to pick with the
Peregrine X, it's would be their size. They are not
small speakers. Even though they never fail to draw "oohs"
and "ahs" from on lookers, they are very intrusive on
the space in which they are installed. Although they
are beautiful to behold, the way they dominate a
room's décor is generally something that I could do
without.
Those looking for a speaker with which to blow away
their friends, do not look here. But those who are
looking for a transducer that creates believable
music have come to the right place. This may seem
like a stupid statement but it's the truth. Many
speakers at this price produce a sound that is larger
than life - almost better and grander than an actual
production - but it's hard to mistake their sound for
the real thing. The Talons may sound almost lifeless
and uninspiring in comparison but they do an amazing
job at creating realistic believable music, which is
what counts most too many of us. Overall, in their
respective price range, I can't think of another
speaker that comes close. Until you consider speakers
costing almost $10,000, they are truly in a class by
themselves. It appears Talon has another winner on
their hands!
Dave Thomas offers a Peregrine X-tra!
I am in agreement with most of the
findings from my colleague's pointed review of these
highly under appreciated loudspeakers. My main
disagreement would come from his feeling that he
would welcome "a tad more warmth" from the updated
crossover. Personally, I'd want for the crossover to
be as neutral as possible and allow added warmth in
the sound to come from somewhere else in the system
chain. Unfortunately, a recent discussion with Talon
boss Mike Farnsworth, seemed to indicate that the
Peregrine X soon would no longer be a part of Talon's
future product line as two new models (including the
much anticipated Firebird) will be introduced in the
coming months. So the purpose of this follow up is to
shed more light on the crossover upgrade that was
alluded to in my colleague's review, since it will
continue to be offered to current Peregrine X owners.
According to Talon, the upgrade, called a Common Mode
Reject Circuit (CMRC) is a new "balanced" crossover,
which crosses over at 1800Hz giving it steeper
slopes, a lower noise floor and less phase shift than
6db designs. This means that the woofers and tweeter
work a lot more effortlessly resulting in a
soundstage that is far more detailed and spacious
than before. They have also eliminated notch filters
and added the Talon Audio "T" logo to the dust cap of
the woofer which helps stop standing wave resonance.
This upgrade is available for the Khorus X, Peregrine
X, and Raven speakers at a price of $2000. The Khite,
the smallest speaker in the Talon line can be
upgraded for $1500.
Now I will tell you up front that I am not a fan of
expensive upgrades to already fine quality equipment.
"If it ain't broke, don't fix it" is how I believe
the saying goes. But there's also another saying from
Emerson that goes "Nothing great was ever achieved
without enthusiasm." I'm not sure what the connection
is but suffice it to say that Lord Farnsworth was
very enthusiastic about just how big an improvement
the CMRC upgrade is. "This upgrade takes the
Peregrine X to about 90% of the Khorus X," Mike
enthused during one discussion. So after a little
more prodding I finally shipped my pair off and in
just a few short days they were back. In fact, they
were back so fast that I briefly even wondered if
they had done anything or if they just mistakenly
sent them back before updating them.
I immediately re-installed them into my system, which
consists of the Electrocompaniet EMC-1 CD player, a
Talon modified EC 4.7 pre-amp and the fabulous Nemo
monoblocks. This system would of course make any
speaker sound good so I figured that this upgrade
would have to be something truly special to justify
the two grand fee. And bear in mind that there are no
changes in the driver compliment. All of the
modifications go into the crossover. Now remembering
back to when Mike said that the upgrade would take
the Peregrines to 90% of the Khorus X, my thought
after a week of critical listening was that he was a
little off. They're a lot closer than that.
I've been able to listen to the Khorus X at a
dealership on a couple of occasions and I can
confidently say that the upgraded Peregrines sounded
every bit as good as the Khoruses on most material.
Bear in mind though that I am talking about Khorus X
speakers without the CMRC upgrade. I have yet to hear
what the upgraded Khoruses sound like. One of my
favorite recordings to use for speaker evaluation is
"Exotic Dances from the Opera" performed by
Eiji Oue and the Minnesota Orchestra
[Reference Recordings
RR-71CD]. On large-scale
orchestral recordings such as this the Peregrines can
sound a bit overwhelmed in the upper midrange
compared to the Khoruses. But on minimalist
performances like "Don't Know Why" by Norah Jones
from her excellent debut cd Come Away With Me
[Blue Note 7243 5 32088 2 0]
the Peregrines deliver her voice with a holographic
quality I haven't heard since Astrud Gilberto and
Stan Getz hooked up on "That Girl From Ipanema"
[Verve].
But where the Peregrine X really shine is when their
speed is put to the test as it is on the great Ahmad
Jamal's "Yellow Fellow", from Live at the Montreal
Jazz Festival [Atlantic
81699-2]. This track is
great fun to listen to from the start as a
French-speaking woman's voice introduces Jamal with
startling clarity. I get a kick out of watching my
friends look around to see where that voice is coming
from when ever I want to show off my system's
prowess. Those of you who are familiar with Jamal
know that he wastes little time getting into and
keeping a brisk pace in his performances. The Talons
don't miss a bit of it. Their speed allows for
immense amounts of detail to come through vividly,
especially on the bottom end where James McCormack's
bass sounds more like an instrument than it does on
some other speakers I've heard in this price range.
It is unfortunate that this splendid looking and
sounding speaker is going away from Talon's talented
line up. But according to Farnsworth the extremely
high quality of fit and finish, crossover parts,
chrome trim and stands that are not only breathtaking
to look at but actually help disperse energy away
from the enclosure, make this a speaker that is worth
far more than its already hefty price tag. He'll get
no argument out of me. The quality of this speaker,
as with all of the Talon line, is top shelf.
Sonically, the upgraded crossover puts it firmly in
the same class as the far more expensive Wilson
Watt/Puppy and Kharma Ceramique 3.2. In the case of
the Wilson, it dominates it on low-end performance.
Should you come across a pair of Talon Peregrine X
snatch them up as fast as you can. You can call Talon
to find out if your pair has been upgraded or not. If
they have, you've got one hell of a speaker. If they
have not then listen to them, enjoy them and then
prepare to be devastated by how much better the CMRC
upgrade makes them sound. You will own one of audio's
truly unique creations.

|