| The
Talon
Khorus X |
|
|
|
Clement
Perry |
|
4
March 2002 |
Specifications
Height:
112cm
(44.24")
Crown: Width 22cm
(8.5") Depth
29 cm
(11.37")
Base: Width 45 cm
(17.75")
Depth 52 cm
(20.5")
Shape: Obelisk
Weight: 86 kg (190
lbs.)
Bandwidth: 17 Hz -
35 kHz
Power Handling:
1-1000 Watts
Nominal impedance:
8 Ohms
Price: $16,000
Address:
Talon Audio
Technologies, Inc.
5175 South Green
Pine Drive
Murray, UT 84123
Tel: 801-619-9000
Fax: 801-619-9001
Web Site: www.talonaudio.com
"In
a world of
abundance the
only scarcity is
human
attention."
....Author
unknown
I
love the smell of
napalm in the
morning. Flip your
calendar back to
the summer of
2000. Talon
Audio's topmost
engineer, Tierry
Budge, sent ST
column instigator
Stu McCreary and
myself his Talon
Audio Khorus
loudspeakers for
the world's first
appraisal. After
an arduous 25-year
pursuit, Budge,
with the help of
Mike Farnsworth,
Talon's corporate
maharishi, hoped
to hit pay dirt
with this unusual
departure from
predictable
dynamic
loudspeaker
design. Our
subsequent and
unadulterated
approval of this
immediate and
powerful sounding,
yet wonderfully
intimate
transducer,
combined with
Talon Audio's
audacious claims ("20-30
times faster/100
times lower in
distortion"),
set off a
firestorm of
debate that's
still smoldering
on several audio
chat rooms.
Irrefutable
ear-witnesses,
Grant Samulson and
Greg Petan, from
two other
magazines,
announcing the
Talon Khorus as
their new
reference
loudspeaker seemed
only to fan the
flames of debate
even faster.
Somebody call in
an air strike
because there is
another
loudspeaker from
Talon Audio that's
better than their
original called
the Talon Khorus
X!
Budge's
lifelong ambition
- to design the
lightning fast and
naturally
translucent
quality ribbons,
planars and
electrostatics
coupled with the
legendary bass
prowess of dynamic
drivers - was
finally realized.
What's most
amazing of all
however wasn't
that Budge
delivered on the
sonic goods as
promised, but
that he did it
using a full-range
all-purpose pair
of 10"
drivers as its
foundation!
This
dual 10"
foundation has set
the stage once
again for yet
another adaptation
Talon has dubbed
the Khorus X. The
"X" nom
de plume isn't for
the unknown
integer, it isn't
for the Roman
numeral, nor is it
for the '60's
Black militant,
but rather for the
UN-known qualities
that come with an
eXtra eXemplary
approach in
eXperimental
loudspeaker
design, built, you
guessed it,
eXquisitely. Here,
is a loudspeaker
that, in
actuality, is
nothing more than
a gargantuan 200
lb. mini monitor
comprised of two
virtual full range
10 inch drivers,
get this, loaded
back to back (made
to spec with
specially designed
voice-coil, motor
assemblage, as
well as super
stiff
suspensions).
Talon woofers have
the difficult, but
nevertheless,
prodigious task of
reproducing
signals beginning
at 17 Hz up to a
staggering 2200
Hz! This dynamic
duo only then
begins its
near-perfect blend
with its 1 ˝ inch
soft-dome sibling
(a modified
Scanspeak tweeter)
sitting right
above it. Though
Talon does not use
a midrange driver,
this rather large
tweeter is many
times mistaken for
a one because of
its size and
placement, and it
extends frequency
reproduction up to
13 kHz. Finally, a
1" titanium
super-tweeter
(made by Audax)
takes over at just
above 13 kHz and
extends out to
over 20 kHz,
earning the
speaker a unique
2.5-way
designation. Talon
professes the
crossover
"slopes"
as being closer to
first-order in
their electrical
function.
Purportedly,
because the
crossover combines
with the
mass/size/speed-related
characteristics of
the drivers, the
typical roll-off
is somewhere
between 3rd
and 4th
order. Sound
confusing? Take a
glimpse at my last
conversation with
Budge on this
subject. Excedrin
Headache material
indeed.
"The
traditional
approach to
crossover slope
design,"
says Budge,
"states
that the
crossover is
supposed to
define
(electrically) a
very specific
bandwidth for a
chosen driver.
This has been
expanded to
include
driver-matching
elements as well
as the use of
LCR
(inductor/capacitor/resistor)
circuits to
'equalize' the
phase
interaction and
cancel basic
driver-generated
non-linearities.
Speaker
companies also
seem to have a
very specific
selection of
crossover
"slopes,"
or electrical
roll-offs, that
they choose to
use.
Manufacturers of
fast roll-offs
tend to argue
that such an
approach favors
power handling
and dynamics.
Whereas,
Manufacturers
who use more
'gentle' slopes
argue that these
types of slopes
are kinder to
musical flow and
imaging. At
Talon, we feel
that both of
these approaches
ignore the
deleterious
characteristics
naturally
generated by the
drivers and
crossover parts
themselves.
Instead of
allowing these
inherent
phase-shifts to
become an
unpredictable
part of the
sonic picture,
each phase-shift
is not allowed
to operate in
the range that
begins its own
roll-offs.
Additionally,
each of the
passive parts
works with the
speaker to help
create the
final, desired
output."
Other
technical
attributes include
its power-friendly
impedance of 8
ohms and 90.5dB
rated sensitivity.
Oh, one more small
thing, power
handling is rated
at 1000 watts,
while transient
power handling is
rated at an absurd
3000 watts RMS.
If
it ain't broke,
why fix it?
Why
make a Khorus X if
the first
iteration was a
reference tool and
highly lauded by
the audiophile
press? Yeah,
that's exactly
what I said to
Budge. Was the
first an
unfinished
product? Was there
something wrong
with the first
design? I had
questions swirling
about my cranium.
However, the
question I needed
to ask myself that
most hushed the
voices inside my
head
lickety-split.
"Was the
Talon Khorus
simply the best
speaker I
owned?" The
answer was an
undeniable Yes!
Could it be
improved? I guess
so.
By
the end of 2000,
Talon placed
itself in an
envious position
from a
manufacturing
standpoint. All
cabinets, formally
assembled off
premises, were now
built in-house
which ultimately
increased QC
(quality control).
In addition, to
improve the look,
Talon hired
talented designer
Dave Evett, of
Evett & Shaw
designs. Choosing
to manufacture
in-house gave both
Budge and
Farnsworth the
opportunity to
take a much better
look at cabinet
design from start
to finish. It also
provided the
obsessive Budge an
opportunity to see
things that he
could improve
upon. Through a
fairly serious
study of porosity
(bad for
acoustics),
rigidity (good for
a woofer), and
density (good for
a tweeter), Budge
discovered cabinet
porosity affected
performance far
more than he
believed possible.
Further, Camp
Talon discovered
the reality of
what Budge refers
to as "the
problems of
cabinet
breathability."
"It was one
thing," says
Budge, "to
'discover' the
breathability of
even exotic
materials (along
with the resultant
dynamic, tonal,
and transparency
problems.) But,
it's another thing
entirely to find
an answer that
solves this very
problem without
disturbing the
mechanically
dissipative
effects of a
well-designed
cabinet." In
the end, Talon
settled on a
material that they
would like to
remain anonymous
that could be
laminated (with
special adhesives
and
vacuum-forming) to
the inside of the
cabinet without
disrupting the
cabinet's natural
mechanical
properties.
Farnsworth
quipped,
"It's an
arduous and pricey
solution, but it
is only about 1/5th
as expensive as
the
alternatives."
The
X model went into
production and I
was ready and
willing to test
drive this latest
adaptation
embodying all the
abovementioned
improvements.
My
Khorus X came in
the glossy piano
black finish
accented with
chrome riding
along its cornered
edges, and further
accented with
chrome end caps
(company name
TALON proudly
inscribed in upper
case compliments
of Dave Evett).
Physically, the
Khorus X is simply
stunning. Its
sophisticated
appearance (with 7
optional finishes)
makes this a very
handsome piece of
furniture. Against
the glow of soft
track lighting,
especially in the
evenings, they literally
shine in my
dedicated
listening space.
It's
sophisticated,
solid look, feel,
fit and finish
tells a story of
success all its
own. Hookup,
formally a tedious
affair, especially
for us reviewers,
has now been made
much easier on the
Khorus X. No
longer are the
speaker terminals
located underneath
these heavy
behemoths. The
screw-on special
Cardas binding
posts are centered
8 inches above its
base and directly
below its
attractive
"X"
insignia plate.
I'm relieved that
the infamous
burn-in period of
four to five
hundred hours for
the original is no
longer necessary.
I was ready for
serious listening
after noticeable
improvements
occurred within
one hundred hours.
Placement was
identical to the
original, which
was about 4 1/2
feet from the
loudspeaker's
outermost corner
to my front
listening wall and
approximately 9
1/2 feet apart,
with my listening
chair about 10
feet away. Java in
one hand, stogie
in the other, I
was ready for some
serious listening.
Equipment used was
essentially the
same. Amplifiers
were two Bel Canto
EVo's used in mono
application.
Sorry, but CD
playback was
changed to the
Electrocompaniet
player due to it
thoroughly
embarrassing my
Sony SCD-1 in
terms of sonic
truthfulness,
tonality, harmonic
integrity and
musicality. I've
gained a new
respect for 16/44
Redbook via the
upsampled 24/192
digital freeway.
The
oneness of sound
There
has always existed
the singleness of
space and time
from the Talon
single driver
technology.
Whether listening
to the Peregrines,
which I use as
center and as
surrounds in my
home theater
setup, or the
original Khorus.
The sense - rather
than the reality
that all the sound
emits from a
single source in a
distinct
holographic space
- never escapes
this listener. The
resulting
qualities of this
attribute cannot
be understated. To
this audiophile,
the first thing
one gets with the
Khorus X version
is an increase in
perceived speed,
weight, imaging,
finesse and
dynamics. This is
a lot in a new
loudspeaker of the
same design
employing the
exact same
drivers. Would I
characterize these
sonic attributes
as a total
departure? No.
This sonic
blueprint is still
that of Talon;
smooth, rich and
incredibly
textured without a
hint of serrated
edges so many
designs are guilty
of when played to
extremes. However,
there is no doubt
there's a lot to
like in this X
version that some
may have been sort
of put off by in
its previous
incarnation. For
example, the Talon
X possesses a
certain quality of
upper treble sheen
that was not
previously
evident. Same
fabric, different
embroidery.
The
Khorus X offers
nary a hint of
being in the room
once proper toe in
is achieved and
the music starts
up (accomplished
in my room with
the speaker's side
walls barely
visible from the
listening seat).
From what I can
hear from
listening to
various CD's, but
mostly those used
in my original
review, is that
the Khorus X
doesn't localize
nearly as much as
the original
model. It also
achieves the
delicate feat of
having no sound of
its own. And if it
does editorialize,
it's doing in a
way that I cannot
detect. I'm not
saying that the
sound, for
example, from
heavily panned
(and previously
used in the
original review)
Miles Davis' Someday
My Prince Will
Come CD
[Columbia CK40947]
sounds any better.
I am noting that
instruments sound
more like they're
coming from a
place rather than
a source. Again,
the introspective
"Old
Folks"
squeaky chair and
all, was selected
as well as "Teo."
Again Miles blew
into that muted
Harmon
communicating a
loneliness and
isolation all his
own. Miles'
incredible musical
sense on such a
slow and
methodical, yet
melancholy, number
is conveyed like
only he could. So
much so, in fact,
I renamed it the
sweet and sour
song.
No
matter how many
times I played
this classic disc,
engineering wise,
Miles always stood
out from the
performance; yet
this time it was
even more
engaging. This
disc, mind you,
with the speakers
out more than 9
feet apart, offers
a real sense of
the wide panning
techniques used at
Columbia studios,
yet manages to
keep Miles tightly
focused dead
center. Hank
Mobley's solo,
following Miles,
springs from the
right speaker with
a powerfully
enveloping ambient
field of delicacy
and decay and that
definitely sounded
more resolute than
the original
Khorus. Another
illustration was
Wynton Kelly
coming from the
extreme left with
a lyrical
interpretation on
piano that sounded
so "in the
room" that it
came through like
a present-day
recording. Played
at low to moderate
levels, Kelly's
piano seemed to
free itself from
cabinet resonance
and coloration,
allowing that
"plinkety"
sound every piano
should make when
the right keys are
struck. Even with
this new
recognition in a
classic-but-dated
jazz studio
recording there is
this true sense of
what was intended
from the engineer.
The heavy panning
effect used widely
in the '60's may
negate total sound
quality by
exaggerating it on
the extremes of
the soundstage.
But it sounds to
me exactly what
Teo Macero had
intended for these
recordings -- and
more importantly,
there's nothing
more breathtaking
than hearing 'Trane,
Miles, Diz, Sarah
and the Messengers
as they were meant
to be heard. When
history speaks
musically, through
Miles' slurred
Harmon mute or 'Trane's
wild cord
progressions, I
want the real
deal. The Talon
Khorus X creates
the picture
perfect venue that
allows me to do
just that.
Saving
the Best for Last
The
most prominent
character of Talon
X, and the one
thing that I
believe it will be
most famous for,
lies in its bass
performance. Most
loudspeakers in
this price range
do wonders in the
areas of
soundstaging,
three
dimensionality,
tonality and
perceived depth
along with
midrange lucidity.
The Khorus X
performs
flawlessly in
these important
areas but that
isn't what it does
best of all.
What
it can do like no
other loudspeaker
I've heard to date
is dig into the
smallest crevice
and unleash bass
notes in a
three-dimensional
space of their
own. Imagine bass
that's harmonic,
gut wrenching and
rich. Bass as
tight as a
turtle's ass, yet
delicate as silk
and all at once,
breathtakingly
lifelike. I now
can identify with
my daughter
Rebecca's favorite
cartoon character
Osmosis Jones when
he yells out
"Oh why ya'
hit so hard?"
My
guess is that
these attributes
are a direct
consequence of its
amazingly low
noise quotient,
speed and driver
build, performance
that previously
was available only
in the finest
electrostatics.
Unfortunately, due
to life's
unpleasant
tradeoffs,
electrostatics
would start
rolling off as
soon as the word
low bass was
mentioned (which
automatically
warranted you go
out purchase a
subwoofer). I
believe
electrostatics
still will win in
the ultimate
transparency
sweepstakes but
they suffer a
tradeoff that I
could neither
tolerate nor live
with.
Two
discs the Talon X
will make stand
out as references
for bass head
demons is Hugh
Masekela's Stimela,
off the Burmester
sampler [Burmester
CD III] and the
entire Deen Peer's
Think…It's
All Good CD
[Turtle Records].
Both these
recordings contain
material that
simply shakes you
out of your
listening seat.
You just have to
hear them for
yourself. Through
a pair of the
Talon X, of
course.
It's
a Wrap.
Not
a hint of these
aforementioned
qualities could
ever present
themselves in the
ultra consolidated
manner in which
they do if it were
not for the
impeccably
designed
woofer/midrange
drivers existing
in the Khorus X.
Period. End of
sentence. Kudos
should be extended
to Camp Talon
because the audio
gods have never
been kind to dream
weavers of
full-range
drivers.
Experienced
designers hardly,
if ever, ventured
beyond a 6-˝ inch
woofer/midrange.
Of the many
attempts I've
heard in simply
trying to get
deeper bass from a
large 2-way, its
most notorious
tradeoff was a
muddy and
disproportionate
bass hump, smack
dab in the middle
of the midrange,
the heart and most
sacred part of any
transducer. The
cleverness behind
Camp Talon to
build a no-copycat
design devoid of a
dedicated
midrange, not to
forget the
ingenuity employed
loading all this
into a single box,
masterfully
avoiding all the
pitfalls, speaks
more of the real
talents behind
Camp Talon than
any reviewer could
ever extol on its
products.
Lastly,
this industry
needs a new
loudspeaker like a
Moose needs a hat
rack. So to hit a
near bulls-eye in
these dark,
shark-infested
waters of high-end
audio with a
totally new
loudspeaker that
causes this big a
ripple, speaks
volumes of Budges'
design,
irrespective of
what any of us
thinks. Talon has
landed dead in the
center of the
high-end audio
playing field with
a state-of-the-art
loudspeaker for
the musical
connoisseur to
cherish. Camp
Talon has done
their job, and a
damn good job at
that.
Dedicated
to Bob Lynch who
gave his life
saving others on
September 11, 2001
in the World Trade
Center. Bob, your
tireless work
ethic and support
will always be
remembered.

|