| THE PENAUDIO REBEL2 LOUDSPEAKER |
|
Rebel With A Cause |
| Nelson Brill |
|
January 2005 |

“If a sick person is not cured by
tar, spirits or sauna, then they will die.”
- Finnish proverb
Recently, I had the good fortune to attend a
live performance by the jazz pianist, Patricia
Barber and her trio in a wonderful, small,
nightclub space here in the Boston area. On
this night, Ms. Barber and her bandmates
plunged into a musical exploration spanning
jazz, blues, bossas and ballads, with such
passion and invention that I was left
breathless by the end of the set, literally
hanging on the band’s every note ‘til the
last. I left the concert in a state of
complete invigoration, as if I had been
rejuvenated by the heat of a Finnish sauna and
then plunged into the icy waters of the
Baltic. I am sure that each of us has
experienced this kind of exhilaration after
listening to live performances of our favorite
music and I would bet this is why most of us
are passionate about our home audio systems.
We seek to replicate such experiences from
live performances in our own living spaces to
feel renewed, refreshed and truly alive.
This sense of renewal through artistic
inspiration, of seeking well-being through
listening to one’s favorite music, is captured
in the motto of the Finnish company that makes
the Rebel2 loudspeaker Penaudio. Penaudio’s
motto is “auditional well-being,” a phrase
that captures the essence of seeking renewal
in one’s life through music. The science of
critical listening forms the basis for all of
Penaudio’s speaker creations. Penaudio’s
founder, chief designer and musician, Sami
Penttila, states that every Penaudio speaker
is designed and voiced on live music and based
on listening impressions in different rooms.
In other words, he wants to make sure that a
violin sounds like the real thing. A panel of
professional and amateur musicians composes
the final litmus test for all Penaudio speaker
designs. Sami states that his goal in
designing these speakers is to bring the
listener not only closer to the recorded
music, but into the venue in which the music
was originally created.
The
Rebel2 is a two-way, stand-mounted,
reflex-loaded design, utilizing a 20mm soft
ferro-fluid textile dome tweeter and a
specially treated 120mm midrange/bass unit.
Penaudio only uses soft, non-resonant tweeter
units in their speakers. The Rebel2 frequency
range is noted in both anechoic response
(80-2200Hz) and in room (50-20000Hz) with a
quite high crossover at 4000Hz. Sensitivity is
rated at 85 dB and nominal impedance is 8
ohms, with recommended amplification at an
optimistic minimum 30+ watts. As one would
expect with a speaker of this modest size
(9.4” W x 11.2” D x 5.5”W), the Rebel2
preferred a good deal of current flow to
achieve best sonic results. Solid-state
amplification of around 100 watts into 8-ohms
suited it quite nicely.
I auditioned the Rebel2 primarily in my small
office space which measures 8’ x 12’. Although
I spent most of my listening sessions with the
Rebel2 mounted on 24” Sound Anchor stands. I
also listened to them simply placed on a desk
facing me at ear height about 8’ from my
listening position to test their versatility.
I know that a lot of us are looking for small
speakers to place in small to medium office
spaces with the goal of integrating that
Finnish sense of renewal right into our daily
lives. In my office, I found the optimal
placement of the Rebel2 to be 1’ from both
side and rear walls with the speakers slightly
toed outward facing my shoulders, not at my
ears directly. The Rebel2 owner’s manual is
quite good with regards to the level of detail
that speaker placement is discussed. Of
course, the small footprint of this speaker
makes experimentation with positioning all the
more easier and flexible.
The Rebel2s arrived in exemplary packing, in a
wonderful light oak grain. The Finns have
another great saying that “in the sauna,
everyone is equal.” In the land of loudspeaker
aesthetics, however, I would opinion that all
are not equal, and I would offer that the
Rebel2 is a speaker of understated beauty for
its size. It will be equally pleasing to the
eye in either a small office or a family den.
A minor quibble: I was not enamored with the
metal grills that came with this pair, with
their sharp edges and propensity to bend even
with care upon their removal. I thus left
these grills off entirely and enjoyed the pair
much more in their absence. Apart from this
small detail, the overall sense of design and
fit of these handmade speakers is superb.
Capturing Interstitial
Beauty
In order to convey the critical sonic
signatures that I heard while listening to the
Rebel2 on a daily basis in my office for
several months, I would return to Patricia
Barber as well something we may all have been
taught in high school biology. I am talking
here of “interstitial,” defined as “relating
to or situated in the small narrow spaces
between tissues or parts of an organ.” What we
have here, in the Rebel2 speaker, is the
epitome of a vehicle for interstitial
exploration on a small, intimate scale. We are
talking here of interstitial exploration, not
of a frog’s anatomy (remember those dissection
days in biology class?) but of what we love
the most: the search for musical truth, intent
and expression in an audio recording. In
Patricia Barber’s recent live performance, her
creative mining of the interstitial spaces
existing BETWEEN the rhythms and syncopations,
the life-beating forces of the bossas and
blues numbers she explored, was simply divine.
Between the spaces of the melodic lines laid
down by her bass, drums and guitar
accompaniment, Barber took off running on her
piano into creative lines interwoven magically
between the rhythms and melody without
confusion or harm to the main theme. Barber
would also use her vocals to scat, harmonize
and fragment further this reality existing
between the notes, to a degree that was
inspiring. Each piece would somehow come to a
perfectly harmonizing conclusion, all wrapped
up in a beautiful coda, leaving the listener
fascinated from whence he or she came.
The Rebel2 speakers allowed me this same
window into glorious interstitial exploration
on most recordings I played; particularly
revelatory on small-scale jazz, chamber music
and acoustic string selections. The Rebels
clearly excel in correct and accurate timbre
and ravishing detail, notably in the mid and
high treble regions. They provide this
precision without any treble grain or
harshness. Some might prefer more added warmth
in the treble regions, as the Rebel2 is
anything but soft or dull in the treble. Some
may also hear a slight forwardness in its
presentation. This was not an issue for me and
indeed, I was completely captured by the
unique, inner detail
presented
in the treble regions that this speaker
afforded. For example, one of my current
favorite audiophile discs to test tonal
accuracy, is the brilliant analog recording,
Sampler #4 Classical [Naim 061]. On
The Devil’s Trill by Tartini and performed
by Yuval Yaron, Yuval’s violin is conveyed
pitch-perfect by the Rebel2, with no nasal
quality or excess dryness. Yuval’s breathing
is heard distinctly as his bow punctuates the
beautiful passages of this music. There is
terrific imaging here, with Yuval present in
my office, lifelike and breathing in a
realistic performance space. Again, the sense
of inner detail, that interstitial magic, is
conveyed by the crystalline treble provided by
the Rebel2.
Another
good test of mid-treble accuracy is the voice
of Cassandra Wilson whose unique, sonorous
tone can be difficult to accurately capture.
One of my favorite recordings of hers is “Belly
of the Sun,” [Blue Note 72435], for its
pristine recording and the breath of its
creative vision. On Wilson’s version of
Wichita Lineman, the Rebel2 conveys her
deep voice in an open and natural way,
existing independent of the speakers. This
disc also uniquely illustrates the strengths
of the Rebel2 in capturing Sami’s goal in his
speaker design: conveying a particular
recording venue. Several of these cuts were
recorded in a train station on hot August days
in Mississippi, while a few were recorded in
the confines of a box car because the train
station was not available to the recording
crew at one point. Checking out the sonic
differences between these cuts was a
revelation with the Rebel2’s, as they painted
a completely different sonic picture of the
two recording spaces: one open and spacious
and the other, confined with lots of
reverberation off the box car’s limiting
walls. The Rebel2 conveyed this interstitial
detail with skill, accuracy and a lifelike
portrayal of the recording venue.
Moving down to the lower mids and bass region,
I can best describe what I heard by comparing
the Rebel2 to another outstanding speaker in
its class and price range, the Totem Model 1
($1600). My listening sessions with these two
speakers was courtesy of my generous
colleagues at Goodwins High End Audio, in a
room slightly larger than my office space. The
Totem Model 1 is a larger bookshelf speaker
with a slightly larger aluminum dome tweeter
and woofer unit. Its sensitivity is rated at
87 dB and frequency response specs are very
similar to the Rebel2. For these sessions, the
classically warmer electronics composed of the
Musical Fidelity A3.2 integrated and A3.2 CD
player were substituted for my Portal Panache
and Creek player.
The
bottom line was that the Totem threw a deeper
and wider soundstage, with a more rounded,
smooth mid-band and bass presentation. The
Rebel2 held its own, with its smaller
dimensions, and cast that magical treble that
the Totem just couldn’t muster. For example,
on orchestral works, like Bantock’s “Celtic
Symphony,” [Hyperion 66450] (a wondrous
recording of great emotional delivery), the
Totem was delicious in providing a dynamic,
deep soundstage for such a small speaker,
while the Rebel2 did the same, with slightly
less fullness and dynamic range in the lower
registers. At the beginning of the Celtic
Symphony, the strings enter playing a slow,
beautiful soft passage, highlighted by a harp.
The Rebel2 captured this soft passage with a
delicacy and
lightness
that the Totem did not, as the Totem offered a
rounder, smoother presentation in which this
inner detail in the mid band was not presented
as clearly. The bass of both speakers was
tight, clean and quick. However, the Totem
offered a noticeably deeper, more robust bass,
especially on hard driving rock and roll
numbers. On Stevie Ray Vaughan’s “Come On (Pt.
III),” from his rollicking disc, “Couldn’t
Stand The Weather” [Epic 65871], the Totem
provided a noticeable deeper bass foundation
and a rounder sound overall to Vaughan’s
vocals and guitar. The Rebel2 provided a
leaner bass underneath but its portrayal of
Vaughan’s vocals was extraordinary in its
chiseled glory, without harshness and with
complete realism. I think in a smaller room, I
would prefer the
Rebel2
for its lithe treble accuracy and probably
would not miss too much its lack of the weight
as compared to the Totems. The Rebel2 was in
all of its interstitial glory on instrumentals
like those found on Brooks Williams sweetly
recorded, “Little Lion” [Signature Sounds
1255], and captured Williams precise bass
lines with power and inner beauty. The Totems
were enticing as well, adding more body,
weight and roundness to the presentation. If
you adore your acoustic guitar down to the
last fret squeak and harmonic tone, audition
the Rebel2 and enjoy its nimble accuracy.
Revel In A Rebel!
I thoroughly enjoyed my wondrous hours
listening to the Rebel2 and highly recommend
it, particularly for those looking for a
speaker that provides glorious tonal accuracy
and treble liquidity in small to medium living
or working spaces. It will bring you pleasure
in its dexterity, mining of inner detail and
interstitial delight. Some might find a
rounder, more full-bodied presentation more
enticing, but the Rebel2 gets to the heart of
the musical matter quickly, with few sonic
diversions. The Rebel2 also enjoys
companionship with cable that suits its solid
state brethren, so investigate this synergy
carefully. I found the Audience AU24 speaker
cable to be a match made in heaven with this
speaker, as this cable sprung even more inner
detail and dynamics to life, dancing with the
Rebel2. Kippis! (“Finnish Cheers”) to All!
Specifications:
Frequency Response: anechoic 80-22K; in room
50-20K
Sensitivity: 85 dB/1m/2.83V
Power Handling: 30 watts minimum
Impedance: 8 Ohms nominal
Connections: single
Size: 5.5 “ W x 11.2” D x 9.4”H
Weight: 2.25 lbs. each
Price: $1,500/pair
Penaudio
Telephone: +358-9-288-100
E-mail:
info@penaudio.fi
Website:
www.penaudio.fi
US Importer:
Portal Audio
Voice: (888) 737-4434
E-mail:
equusaudio@aol.com
Website:
www.portalaudio.com

|