| A
Visit to Meadowlark
Audio |
|
Road Trip |
|
Clement Perry |
|
19 December 2002 |
Watertown, NY, three
hundred forty miles
north of New York City
and only a stones throw
from the Canadian
border, is a town so
peaceful in its people
and so serene in its
surroundings, compared
to New York City;
it's the real Mayberry
RFD. In fact, each mile
north via Interstate 81,
felt like a step back in
time…and seasons,
literally. November may
only be fall in New York
but it's a snowy
blustery winter in
Watertown. The snow
greeted me about halfway
up making driving
conditions a serious
concern on some roads
even for all-wheel drive
vehicles like my huge
Ford Expedition. Make no
mistake about it;
Watertown is ski
country, and good ski
country I hear. I can
now see why. The one guy
I'm certain who loves
early winters and isn't
fazed by ten-foot
snowdrifts is
Watertown's own Stu
McCreary.

Hadn't seen Stu in a
month of Sundays and I
personally didn't
recognize him with all
the weight he lost and
replaced with muscle
bulk. Talk about fit &
trim. Damnnnnn! I
workout too, well, I
mean, I used to, or
thought I did. But after
one good look at Stu,
I'm hitting the floor
each morning getting my
fifty pushups (thanks
for the inspiration).
Macho-ness aside, Stu
and I really enjoyed the
time just sitting in his
listening room shootin'
the breeze and of
course, listening to
music. Stu's system is
sounding very good these
days (Stu turned me on
the Bel Canto eVo's)
with the new Kestrel2's
burning in. I brought
some of my own discs and
can tell you that Stu
had a damn good system
the last time I visited
three years ago. Well,
he's not missed a beat
and the system is
sounding just as good if
not better, considering
the last time I was
there the $12,500 Von
Schweikert VR6
loudspeakers were
in-house. Well, if the
Kestrel2's are a third
that price and sound as
good as I heard with my
own CD's, then I'll bet
you the Kestrel2's
become Stu's reference.
Unless he takes a deep
breath and opts for the
Blue Heron's.
My purpose in visiting
Watertown was not just
to hang out with Stu
listening to music, as
pleasant as that was. My
goal was to see the new
facility of Watertown's
newest denizen Pat
McGinty, Meadowlark
Audio's chief engineer
and designer.
Originally from New
York, McGinty, believe
it or not, started his
cross-country drive to
Watertown from southern
California on September
11, 2001. This obviously
made the drive very
intense for McGinty and
his wife Lucinda. For
one, on that fateful
day, all aircraft were
grounded within
forty-five minutes-an
aviation first-after the
attacks. Excepting
fighter jets screaming
across the horizon our
skies were painfully
silent.
Despite the long and
sometimes scary drive
east, the McGinty's
arrived safely in
Watertown, thankfully,
in one piece. Despite
the fears the swept
across our nation, the
McGinty's, amazingly I
should add, got busy
getting their plant
readied to build
loudspeakers. So busy,
in fact, McGinty
redesigned virtually ALL
of his loudspeakers
within one year. By the
looks of the accented
wood finish on his new
Kestrel2's and Ospreys I
would say McGinty was
very busy indeed. How
busy (you had to ask)?
Busier than a one-legged
man in an ass-kickin'
contest!
Background Check
Pat
McGinty began Meadowlark
Audio back in 1995 with
the debut of his now
classic Kestrel
loudspeaker, though he
had developed quite a
reputation for himself
designing loudspeakers
dating back to 1987.
Seventy percent of
Meadowlark owners
purchased via
word-of-mouth McGinty
boasts. I was taken by
the Meadowlark sound
when I first heard the
Ibises at fellow
compatriot Leon Rivken's
place. Driven by a pair
of VAC Renaissance
mono's, these
first-order,
phase-coherent,
transmission-line
behemoths left an
indelible imprint on my
audio psyche. Of course,
it didn't help with Stu
calling me up raving
over the little Swifts
stating, "They sound too
good." My intrigue,
fueled by both Leon and
Stu's enthusiasm, and of
course, my own
curiosity, led me to
Watertown.
My visit left me with
this revelation: Pat
McGinty is a serious
loudspeaker designer. I
suspect other
loudspeaker designer's
envy him. Also, he and
his lovely wife Lucinda
are a team. A damn good
one too. Hell, they've
lasted this long and
look to be growing as a
company despite our
lagging economy. If
you've already met the
McGinty's, or spoken to
them on the phone, then
you already know what
I'm talking about. In
this business, which is
an unusually tough one,
the McGinty's are widely
considered one of
high-end audio's
pleasantries. Needless
to say, my trip proved
to be an eye, and ear,
opening one. Hopefully,
there will be more on
these pages.
Here's a brief technical
description of the
Meadowlark approach to
loudspeaker design by
explained by McGinty.
On Transmission Line
bass loading, McGinty
says,
"Though excruciatingly
difficult to design
and quite challenging
to construct, the
Transmission Line bass
loading concept
delivers deeper and
tighter bass than the
simple vented
alignments that
prevail in the market.
A recent realization -
an epiphany of sorts -
on my part has lead to
BASSIC - which stands
for IMPEDANCE COUPLED
BASS. The Swift was
the first model to
feature this new
concept - and you
heard it Clement - it
is no joke."
On
Time Coherence, he
continues,
"All
Meadowlark speakers
are time coherent
using simple
first-order crossovers
made with the finest
parts and physically
phase aligned drivers
by virtue of the
slanted baffles to
achieve coherent
output. Clement, as
you may know, most
speaker companies
disregard what we
consider to be a
minimum performance
characteristic - time
coherent output.
Simply put, this means
that the acoustic
output of the speaker
"looks" like the input
signal; the speaker
reproduces the
waveform that it is
'fed' at the input
terminals. It often
comes as a surprise to
audio customers that
98% of speaker
companies do not even
attempt to reproduce
the waveform. But that
is the current state
of affairs. Meadowlark
and a bare handful of
others have raised the
bar, if you will, by
designing and building
coherent speakers. FYI
- all amplifiers are
coherent, so are
preamps, CD players,
phono cartridges,
microphones. Cheap
cassette players are
coherent. Even the
cheapo 79-cent op-amp
that you buy at Radio
Shack is coherent. The
ONLY link in the chain
that is "allowed" to
be incoherent is the
speaker...and the
reasons are it's
cheaper, it's easier
and everybody else
does it."
A
full
workup on the
subject - with
animations - can be
located is available on
Meadowlarks website.

Got
to admit McGinty's
right. The sound coming
from those little Swifts
was quite impressive
when driven by Mike
Elliott's Aria 350 mono
amplifiers and a BAT
preamp. Considering this
huge (all-brick) room's
dimensions, which I
estimated to be 25 by 60
feet, pulling off a
stunt like filling the
room with sound would be
hard for any
loudspeaker, much less
the Swift. I mean,
c'mon, it retails for
only $995.

Life
for Meadowlark Audio
begins here in their new
plant. McGinty boasts
his production model as
"…quite aggressive,
even daring. We are
doing a number of
things here that just
have not been done
before. Bottom line is
that we are set up for
a continuously mixed
production environment
that can quickly
produce both small and
large runs of product.
The prototype to
production process
integrated by our CNC
methods is remarkably
fast. I actually
conceived the Swallow,
designed it,
prototyped it and put
it into actual
production in less
than a week!"

Here's a shot of
McGinty's powerful CNC
Router machining a set
of four Osprey
baffleboards.
A
pair of Swifts on the
hand-assembly line.
While most speakers are
V-grooved and folded
together to save cost,
Meadowlark's products
are fitted exact with an
unusually large joint
for maximum gluing area.
They are then glued in
the traditional fashion,
by hand, and clamped for
several hours to allow
the glue to polymerize.
The result, says
McGinty,
"is an
extra strong joint
that is the key to a
stabile cabinet."
You'll notice through
the woofer hole on the
Swift that is facing
you, that the speakers
are intensively lined
with a heavy acoustic
felt that does an
superb job of
absorbing the
backwave."
(Built on the right is
their largest Blue Heron
Center Channel).

Swallow cabinets and
Swift baffleboards with
Dark Ash stain applied
are ready for lacquering
and glue up.

Blue
Heron2, Osprey and Owl
raw cabinets awaiting
application of veneer.

This
is a photo of the
interior of their spray
booth with a bunch of
Swift bases partially
coated with their black
texture finish.

The
Osprey's baffle board
being sanded and readied
into a Pennsylvania
Cherry with a Rock Maple
Stringer.

The
Meadowlark Audio Swift
crossover, built
entirely in house using
AuriCap capacitors,
heatsinked Caddock power
resistors and a 16 gauge
core inductor with all
parts hand
point-to-point soldered
using silver solder. All
Internal wire is DH Labs
T-14 silver-plated
oxygen free copper in a
Teflon dielectric.
Frankly, the parts
quality is what you'd
expect to find in a $10K
speaker - if that. As
you can see, the
crossover is absolutely
minimalist - a simple
first order electrical
design. When in place in
the speaker, it resides
in its own isolation
chamber.

The
rear shot of the new
Osprey

Pat
McGinty smiles while
sandwiched between his
latest arrivals. On the
left is a world's first
exclusive photo of the
Kestrel2 prototypes done
in Curly Maple with twin
offset walnut stringers
(wood accent). Look for
Meadowlark to make a
formal announcement in
the very near future of
there arrival. On the
right are the Ospreys
done in Pennsylvania
Cherry with a Rock Maple
Stringer, and Light
Native Ash with a
Heritage Walnut
Stringer. In the rear
you can see part of
Meadowlark Audio's lab -
which McGinty describes
as one of the more
extensive analog labs in
audio.

Here's Meadowlarks
Swallow bookshelf
speakers flanking the
Swan center channel
(both in a Light Ash
finish). The Swallows
are perched on
Meadowlark's new (sand
fillable) stands which
list for $249. The
stand's appearance looks
very basic to the naked
eye but McGinty declares
"don't let the looks
fool you. They're
sonically excellent
owing to the heavy sand
damping." The Kestrel2
prototypes and Ospreys
are also visible.

An
exclusive world's first
glimpse at the new Blue
Heron2! And I'll be the
first to say that I am
as impressed by the
Heron's look as I am its
sonic performance. Talk
about WAF appeal! Priced
at $10,000, it looks and
sounds much more
expensive once you see
it up close. The one
thing you become
instantly aware of at
Meadowlark Audio is
there's virtually no
difference in how
McGinty builds his
loudspeakers based on
price. As you can see in
the photos, they're
built from the very same
fabric, perhaps a finer
silk thread exists in
the Blue Heron, but it's
the same needle pattern.
|