|
Premium Car
Radios-High End or
Hokum |
|
Commentary |
| Ross
Wagner |
|
23 October 2002 |
The
star of the June Home
Entertainment Show in
New York City was not a
speaker system. Nor was
it an amplifier, a
pre-amp, CD player or
anything to do with a
home theater.
Here's a clue. It was
large, and almost as
heavy as the
Wisdom/Rowland 'Million
Dollar System' heard at
the CES show last
January. Like the
speakers in that system,
it boasted an impeccable
silver finish. Unlike
that system, it had four
performance tires, and a
twelve cylinder, 450
horsepower engine under
the hood. I am, of
course, speaking of the
bran'-spankin' new Aston
Martin Vanquish which
gleamed under the
halogen spotlights in
the huge Linn display
suite.
What in the world is
this vehicle, or any
vehicle for that matter,
doing at a home
entertainment show?
Well, I'll tell you
what, and it may not be
good news.
High-end, or what is
supposed to be high-end
audio, has infiltrated
itself into automobiles.
Try to buy any car with
a sticker over, say,
$23,000 from a dealer's
lot without a 'premium'
radio stuffed into the
dash. It's hard to do.
The Ford Escape I bought
a few years ago sported
a 'premium' radio.
Likewise the Infiniti
G-35 I purchased a few
months ago. Spent $500
extra on the former;
$900 on the latter.
My reward for shelling
out the extra
bucks…speaker drivers
everywhere, several
hundred watts of power
(rated God-only-knows
how), and a peaky upper
mid-range that could
turn Lot's wife into
salt without the need
for her to turn her
head. One more
outrage…Ford deleted the
cassette player from its
'premium' radio. So
good-bye to your
existing tape collection
and books on tape. Oh
well. Want to brush up
your Farci on those long
commutes to work?
Fuhgeddaboutit. And if
you want to experience
Tolstoy, better get the
book out of the library.
The bass on these units
(it isn't low bass:
rather it is a pervasive
mid-bass thump) is, to
put it bluntly, awful.
How best to describe it?
A sensation somewhere
between an orgasm and
the kind of pelvic
cramps one experiences
after drinking tap water
in the Mexican
countryside.
I have found no way to
make these units
listenable, except to
turn down both the
treble and bass tone
controls to minimum, and
put a lid on the gain.
So far I have been
talking about the
nameless 'premium' sound
system found in the Ford
and the Bose system
infecting the Infiniti.
And speaking of
Infiniti, the name
adorns many of the
extra-cost systems in
dealers' showrooms as
well as Clarion
and…well, you know the
names. Right?
But the trend introduced
by Lexus, the folks who
let you pay $1000 extra
for a Nakamichi upgrade
when they introduced the
LS400 in 1990, is
expanding. Lexus is
still at it, but today's
high-end name is Mark
Levinson. Here is an
otherwise respectable
purveyor of true
high-end audio
electronics lending
their name to a
high-priced automobile
audio system. To be
fair, the Madrigal
effort is somewhat more
listenable than the Ford
or Infinity effort due,
in part, to a mid-range
level control.
Unfortunately, the
emphasis is still on a
hot top and an
ill-defined mid-bass.
Again, no real low-end
response.
Besides offering
doubtful value, I
believe these systems
will have a long lasting
and harmful effect on
true high-end audio. I
fear the standards of
taste in music
reproduction are being
corrupted by the
association of these
sounds with the premium
names of the high-end
industry. How are the
purveyors of quality
sound in audio salons
going to explain to
owners of 'premium'
automobile audio systems
that they should pay big
bucks for home systems
that sound nothing like
what these folks have
been listening to in
their cars. Hmmm, they
will ponder, why does
this Mark Levinson home
system sound so
different from the Mark
Levinson system in my
car? Gosh, Mr. High-end
Salesman, why aren't you
selling me something
that sounds like the
pricey sound system in
my Lexus?
Its time to get back to
the Aston Martin and
Linn. Remember? That's
where we came in?
Anyhow, we need to keep
in mind that the Linn
system is an
after-market effort. The
Linn folks were
presented a completed
car with the challenge
of providing a one-off
upgraded sound system
without mucking up the
hand finished leather
and rare wood interior
of this world-class
automobile. Linn decided
to install four small
three-driver pods, one
in each of the four
doors. Each pod includes
a tweeter, a mid-range
and another driver to
round things out. So
twelve drivers in all.
Guess how many amps.
You're right…twelve. A
sub-woofer and its
dedicated amp complete
the system.
Pretty good sound, I
would say, for an
automobile, but still
with the emphasis on a
punchy presentation. The
massiveness and rigidity
of the vehicle itself
helps to keep the sound
under control. Linn need
feel little
embarrassment for its
effort.
This article has been
pretty much of a rant so
far, and you might ask,
"Well, Wagner, how would
you go about getting
good sound into a car?
Funny you should ask,
because I addressed just
that issue forty, yep,
forty years ago.
I was much too young,
and could ill-afford the
220SE Mercedes coupe at
the time. And space will
not allow how I
justified it, nor will I
bore you with the
intricate history of my
romance with that
oh-so-gorgeous machine.
Let's move on to the
sound system.
At the time there were
no CD's, not even
cassette decks in cars.
In fact, FM was rare in
American cars. But the
Mercedes had an FM tuner
which could receive the
entire FM frequency band
being broadcast in the
US. However, the tiny
single speaker mounted
in the center of the
dash, just would not do.
So with my heart in my
mouth, I summoned the
courage to ask my local
dealer to cut through
the heavy steel of the
rear deck and drop a
small KLH speaker,
walnut cabinet and all,
into the space. The
sound was directed
upward towards the slant
of the rear window,
thence to the occupants
of the car. Lest you
wonder, I should remind
you that mono was the
order of the day in
broadcast FM, so one
speaker seemed
sufficient to the task.
The sixties were
troubled years in many
ways, but in at least
one respect they were to
be cherished. The
sixties was the golden
age of broadcast
classical music in the
New York area. We had at
least three stations
then; barely one and a
half now. The Becker
Mexico radio had
sufficient power to
drive the KLH. I recall
the sweetest sound
emanating from that
little system. Sure, the
highs were rolled off. I
doubt the bass went much
below 100. But the six
octaves between those
points was music, deeply
involving and richly
satisfying. And that's
what sound systems, in
cars or otherwise,
should do…get the
mid-range right…then,
and only then, deliver
the best high frequency
response and as much
clean bass as you can
afford.
I would happily exchange
the fancy premium car
systems I now own for
that fine Becker
Mexico/KLH sound of old.
And while I'm wishing
for the good old days,
perhaps WNCN, 104.3 on
the FM dial, will
broadcast classical
music again.
Editors note: I spent
some dozen years
associated with the Car
Audio Nationals and then
the International Auto
Sound Challenge
Association, as a sound
quality judge form the
mid 1980's through the
late 1990's. I judges
hundreds of events and
many hundreds more
automobiles fitted with
aftermarket systems
installed by reputable
retailers with custom
installers and install
bays at their place of
business. Delete the
bloody "Premium" system
when possible - and yes,
I know that can be
difficult. Take the
money you save to a
reputable 12-volt audio
retailer (do your
homework - it is not
that difficult to check
up on a dealers
reputation in the
community) and see what
good aftermarket sound
can do for you. The
installations today look
as good or better than
the factory system and
sound infinitely better
than ANY factory system.
You will be surprised
what a joy you will find
for your efforts!
Greg Weaver
|