| The
Art
&
Science
of Audio
Tuning:
Part
Four |
| Commentary |
| Mike
Vans
Evers |
| 1
August
2000 |
"…check
out the
directionality
of your
digital
cables, as its
direction will
also affect
the bass.
Additionally,
the polarity
of two-prong
AC cords will
affect the
bass of an
audio system.
Getting the
orientation of
your cables
optimized for
your system
can be a fun
and rewarding
way to get
more enjoyment
from your
system."
The
first step is
to work with
the energy
storage of the
room/speaker
combination.
You start by
moving the
speaker and/or
listening
position
around in
order to get
the least
lumpy bass.
This step
costs nothing,
but does take
up some of
your time.
There are many
articles and
speaker
reviews, which
spell out how
to get the
linear bass
response from
a set of
speakers in a
listening,
room. There
are even
several
computer
programs
available to
guide you in
this task.
To
perform a
quick test for
evaluating
your need for
room tuning,
pick a CD
track with
many bass
frequencies,
play it
several times
to familiarize
yourself with
it, and then
pile some
couch pillows
on the floor
in the corners
of your room.
You will
definitely
lose some
bass. Whether
or not this is
a positive
step depends
on your taste
and your
system's
needs. For
those who
aren't allowed
pillows in the
ceiling
corners, this
might open
other avenues
for room
tuning. (Note
for the
do-it-yourself
types: Fabric
stores have a
large
selection of
pillows and
foam and
enough fabric
styles to
match any
decor.)
The
second step
deals with the
bass
characteristics
of the
system's
cables and
also costs
nothing. The
manufacturer's
recommended
directionality
of a cable is
not cast in
stone. The
manufacturer's
system is
almost
certainly
different from
yours. The
direction of
the arrow may
be the
opposite of
what will be
best in your
system. In for
a penny, in
for a pound.
While you're
at it, check
out the
directionality
of your
digital
cables, as its
direction will
also affect
the bass.
Additionally,
the polarity
of two-prong
AC cords will
affect the
bass of an
audio system.
Getting the
orientation of
your cables
optimized for
your system
can be a fun
and rewarding
way to get
more enjoyment
from your
system.
Here
we will be
working with
the energy
storage of the
equipment;
i.e. the panel
resonance’s
and sprung
weight of the
electronics.
Our goal is to
reduce the
amount of
"lumpy"
bass at the
listening
position by
using a
combination of
coupling-type
and
de-coupling-type
feet. An
examination of
how
coupling-type
feet work will
be helpful in
understanding
this step:
To
recap: Audio
equipment
usually
contains wire
and PC boards.
These act like
mechanical
tone controls
(Axiom #1).
Most
decoupling-type
feet cause
bass energy to
be stored.
These
spring-like
feet, together
with the
weight of the
equipment,
form a bass
energy storage
mechanism
(resonance)
which enhances
those same
bass harmonics
in the music
that coincide
with the
frequency of
this
resonance. If
this
bass-energy
storage in the
equipment
coincides with
a gap in the
room's
resonant
signature or
the speaker's
frequency
response, it
smoothes the
resonance
response of
the system
resulting in a
positive
change.
However, if it
coincides with
a clump or a
balanced area
in the room's
resonant
signature, it
makes the
resonance
response (and
the sound)
worse. (See
Axiom #2.) (In
any case,
personal
preferences
will usually
determine what
sounds
"right",
smooth or
accentuated
bass.)
By
placing a set
of energy
transmitting
(coupling-type)
feet under a
piece of
equipment, an
audiophile is
exchanging one
bass bump for
another. The
compliance
(springiness)
of shelves is
much lower
than that of
rubber feet;
the amount of
energy that
can be stored
will be
reduced. The
mass of the
component will
be free to
interact with
the stand in a
more direct
manner, and
the resulting
bass bump will
be lower in
magnitude. The
new bass bump
will also be
lower in
frequency if,
and only if,
the stand's
bass resonance
is lower in
frequency.
PLEASE
NOTE: Solid
coupling-type
feet DO NOT
ISOLATE! This
statement is
true for all
cone type feet
from all
manufacturers.
Remember this:
if it is
Rigid, it
Resonates
[RIGID
RESONATES].
Because
cone-type feet
are made from
a rigid
material, they
must resonate,
usually at an
audio
frequency. On
the other
hand,
cone-type feet
can have some
areas of the
audio
frequency
response where
they will
dampen
transmission
of mechanical
vibrations.
The resulting
new
distribution
of resonance
and absorption
will change
the resonance
response of
the system and
therefore its
sound.
However, this
modification
of the
transmission
response does
NOT make a
cone-type foot
an isolation
device. A
serendipitous
change in
sound is all
that is often
necessary for
many people to
believe
whatever
claims a
manufacturer
may make.
(This
statement is
not meant to
call into
question the
veracity of
any
manufacturer.
It is,
however, meant
to set
straight the
actual working
nature of the
device.)
Procedure
for Using
Coupling and
Decoupling
Feet
"The
placement of
the Tuning
Block
affects the
vibration
pattern of a
chassis
bottom panel
or top
cover. This
affects the
harmonic
balance of
the mids and
highs in the
sound of
your
music."
Some
systems will
need every
component
coupled; some
systems will
need its
components
DE-coupled
only. Most
will need a
mix of the two
techniques. It
is also
possible to
partially
couple the
chassis by
placing a
coupling foot
under, for
example, just
the front, and
by leaving the
back half on
its rubber
feet. This
gives an
effect in
between that
of coupling
and
decoupling.
For
tuning the
bass, the type
of material
used is as
important as
the fact that
a hard
material is
being
substituted
for a soft
material.
Coupling feet
made from
small blocks
of wood such
as oak
(7/16" ×
3/4" ×
1") can
be made and
used for bass
tuning.
However,
it's always
better to have
several
materials
and/or types
of wood
available when
it comes to
tuning the
bass,
midrange, or
treble of your
system. There
are many
tuning devices
currently
available.
Rather than
debate which
ones are the
best, we
recommend a
different
approach: use
anything that
makes your
audio system
sound better
to YOU. The
VansEvers
Company makes
different and
sometimes
unique tuning
products. We
feel that our
Tuning Blocks
offer the most
flexibility
because they
are offered in
many different
types of wood
(and each type
of wood has
its own unique
sound). In
addition, for
those of you
so inclined
and equipped,
give us a call
and we'll tell
you where to
get the wood
so that you
can make your
own tuning
blocks.
However,
anywhere in
the text that
it says to use
a VansEvers
"Tuning
Block"
feel free to
substitute a
Tip Toe* or
any other
product that
you may
prefer. The
mechanism will
still hold
true: the
resonance
response of
the new object
will alter the
harmonic
balance of
your system.
The positive
or negative
response this
will elicit is
not tied to
the
superiority of
the theory
that has been
used to
validate this
product. The
concept that
should hold
the most value
to you is your
reaction to
the change in
the sound of
your system:
is the sound
better or
worse? If the
sound is
better, keep
the change. If
the sound is
worse, put the
tweak back in
your cache of
tuning
products until
another time
when it may be
perfectly
suited for
correcting a
problem in
your system's
resonance
response
caused by a
new component
or some other
changed
factor.
Step
I. Select
a piece of
music or test
disc that has
a range of
music or notes
that cover the
bass spectrum.
Play it
several times
until you are
familiar with
the strong
notes and the
weak notes.
Step
II. Place
coupling type
feet under the
heaviest
component in
your system
that doesn't
already use
them. Play the
same music
again. If the
bass is more
even, leave
the feet
there. If the
bass isn't
more even,
remove the
feet and move
to the next
heaviest
component.
Step
III.
Repeat Step II
with each
piece of
equipment in
your system.
Include
transports,
power
conditioners,
and other
things you may
feel cannot
possibly make
a difference.
Components
sitting atop
isolation
platforms are
also
candidates for
this
procedure. The
isolation of
these
platforms only
reduces
vibrations
transmitted
through the
shelf.
Vibrations
will still
travel through
the air and
connecting
cables.
Step
IV. Start
over:
experiment
with the
heaviest
component
first as in
Step I, but
use your
aftermarket
decoupling
feet this
time. (Yes,
this section
IS about
coupling type
feet. However!
No one concept
works 100% of
the time.
That's the
reason there
are so many
competing
concepts/products
out there,
each with its
own legion of
supporters.
The idea is to
mix these
concepts to
your
advantage.)
Step
V. To add
another, and
lower,
dimension,
place heavy
objects on top
of a component
to change its
bass resonance
frequency. The
heavier the
object, the
lower the
resulting
resonance and
therefore the
lower the bass
"bump"
in the sound
of your
system. This
technique will
broaden the
effectiveness
of coupling
and decoupling
methods.
There
are a number
of
audiophile-approved
"heavy
objects"
on the market.
They work
well. It helps
to have
several
objects with
differing
weights to
work with,
though. Heavy
books and
leftover
barbell
weights can be
very useful.
Just remember
that with
barbell
weights, the
metal, or
plastic
they're made
from or
covered with
will also
become part of
the sound.
Wrapping the
object with
several layers
of a suitable
dampening
material, such
as soft cloth,
may be able to
tame
objectionable
mid and high
frequency
resonances.
Lead diver's
weights are
inexpensive
and also very
useful. (To
keep from
getting lead
residue all
over you and
your
equipment, a
layer or two
of cloth or
cloth tape
should be
considered
mandatory.)
At
this point,
your bass
should be a
lot less
lumpy. For
those really
serious about
getting the
best sound
possible, it
may prove
beneficial to
go back and
repeat at
least the
first three
steps.
To
continue this
discussion, I
will
concentrate on
the
characteristics
of a product
that I know
very well: the
VansEvers
Tuning Block.
The resonant
signature of a
VansEvers
Tuning Block,
or any other
resonance
control
device,
affects the
energy it
transmits or
absorbs. The
placement of
the Tuning
Block affects
the vibration
pattern of a
chassis bottom
panel or top
cover. This
affects the
harmonic
balance of the
mids and highs
in the sound
of your music.
Wood
has obvious
influences on
the sound of
musical
instruments.
The same style
of instrument
made from
another type
of wood will
create sounds
with a
different
harmonic
balance. Each
distinct
variety of
wood has its
own set of
frequencies
that will be
absorbed
because of
internal
friction.
Other
frequencies
will resonate
because of
that wood's
elastic
properties.
Still other
frequencies
will be
transmitted
without
attenuation.
This adds up
to a
characteristic
sound for each
particular
wood.
The
VansEvers
coupling-type
feet are made
out of many
different
types of wood,
from Amarello
to Zebrawood.
(Many of them
are quite
beautiful.)
Our goal is to
make the
resonance
response of
the system
more of a
level playing
field and thus
more
dynamically
neutral. It is
necessary to
have a variety
of materials
from which to
choose,
because each
system will
have a unique
set of
strengths and
weaknesses.
The
following
properties are
those that we
have observed
for unfinished
(other than
smooth-sanded)
wood blocks
approximately
3/4" ×
1" ×
1.5" in
dimension:
Basswood:
This
light-weight
softwood
sounds thin
when replacing
wood types
with the same
mid-bass
emphasis (a
size
phenomenon).
It resonates
(enhances) in
the upper
treble area;
it sounds
recessed in
the lower and
upper mids.
(Basswood:
Tilia
Americana)
Bloodwood:
This is a
reddish
straight
grained, fine
textured
hardwood that
has a high
frequency
resonance in
the
mid-treble. It
also resonates
slightly the
lower midrange
and has a lack
of energy in
the middle and
upper
midrange. (Bloodwood,
Brosimum
paraense, has
a wonderful
smell when
freshly sawn.)
Bocote:
This can be
quite
beautiful
wood. It has
good extension
in the highs
and sounds
quite
"solid"
because of a
slight
emphasis in
the lower
midrange/upper
bass. It also
has a slight
emphasis in
the mid
treble. (Bocote,
Cordia
gerascanthus,
which is
native to
Costa Rica, is
considered an
endangered
species, and
therefore will
not be offered
by the
VansEvers Co.)
Cherry:
This American
hardwood has
more mass than
Basswood and
therefore
resonates at a
lower
frequency. Its
area of
enhancement is
in the upper
midrange; its
peak is lower
and broader
than Basswood.
Cherry (Prunus
serotina) is
not
distinctive in
its looks, and
can easily be
mistaken for
other woods
such as maple.
Cocobolo:
This imported
hardwood has
one
enhancement
area in the
lower and
mid-treble,
another in the
upper bass.
This size
block also
sounds
recessed in
the lower
midrange.
Cocobolo (Dalbergia
retusa) has an
alternating
color scheme.
The thin dark
brown bands
are from the
dense winter
growth. The
lighter summer
growth's color
can vary from
golden
orange-red to
a reddish dark
brown. The
grain ranges
from straight
to wavy, and
the texture is
usually fine.
Some
individuals
will have
allergic
reactions
similar to
those from
poison ivy
upon exposure
to sawdust
from cocobolo.
Ebony:
This is an
African
hardwood. Some
of the darkest
black
varieties (Gaboon)
are almost
unobtainable
(in large
quantities)
today. Its
emphasis range
is in the
upper treble
and top
octave. (Gaboon
ebony:
Diospyros
mespiliformis)
Lignum
Vitae:
This is a
medium to
dark-colored
(brown or
black)
hardwood whose
grain is often
strongly
interlocked,
very
irregular, and
"roe"y;
the sapwood is
pale yellow or
cream colored.
Its upper
resonant peak
is a narrow
band in the
upper treble;
the lower
resonant peaks
are in the
middle
midrange and
middle bass.
Correspondingly,
it sounds weak
in the lower
mids and the
upper
midrange. It
has less top
octave than
amarello.
Lignum Vitae
(Guaiacum
officinale) is
very waxy, up
to 30% by
weight, and
has growth
rings that are
very thin; the
resulting wood
is so dense
and heavy that
it will not
float. It is,
however,
compared to
some other
woods like
Pernambuco --
seemingly --
relatively
soft. This is
an interesting
paradox in the
light of its
use as ship's
propeller
shaft
bearings...where
it lasts as
much as three
times longer
than steel or
bronze
bearings.
Mahogany:
This wood is
imported from
many different
countries, and
even
continents, as
there are some
40 species.
The darker
(denser)
varieties
enhance the
lower mids and
the upper mids.
The sound will
become warmer
with more
midrange
presence.
There is also
a lack of
support from
the mid treble
up. The
lighter
varieties
shift the
enhancement
up, and sound
less
"lumpy";
the highs are
not quite as
extended as
zebra's.
(Mahogany dust
can be toxic.)
Maple:
This is an
American
even-grained
wood, and
there are over
20 native
species. It
can be either
hard or soft.
Rock maple is
the hard
variety. Our
sample had
emphasis in
the mid-bass,
upper-treble,
and top
octave; there
was a loss in
lower midrange
and upper bass
presence.
MDF:
Medium Density
Fiberboard.
This is a
manufactured
material made
from fine
sawdust. The
MDF at our
disposal
absorbed lower
treble and
upper midrange
energy . This
makes the
treble sound
thin even
though it is
not
accentuated.
There is also
a slight
emphasis in
the lower
midrange.
(Formaldehyde
is used in
MDF's
manufacture;
cutting and
sanding MDF
will liberate
this pungent
gas.)
Oak:
This popular
American
coarse-textured
wood is
available at
most large
lumber stores;
it is
available in
both red and
white
varieties. The
enhancement
area of common
Home Depot red
oak is in the
upper
midrange.
There is a
de-emphasis in
the
upper-bass/lower-midrange,
and the highs
are extended
and smooth.
Southern oak
trees are
faster growing
than their
northern
counterparts,
which accounts
for their
coarser
texture. (Quercus
alba: white;
Quercus rubra:
red)
Olivewood:
This wood is
indigenous to
the
Mediterranean
area, and has
a nice full
middle and
lower
midrange; it
rolls off high
frequencies
starting at
the upper
midrange. Its
sonics are
similar to
cypress. Olive
(Olea europaea)
is light tan
with
greenish/grayish
darker brown
stripes.
Pequia
Amarello:
This hardwood
is light
yellow in
color. The
middle
midrange is
emphasized in
comparison
with the upper
and lower
midrange. Its
upper
enhancement
range is the
upper treble
and top
octave. Too
much energy in
this area will
decrease depth
of image. Its
lower range of
enhancement is
in the middle
bass. (If
you're going
to make blocks
of
Aspidosperma
tomentosum
yourself--always
use a sharp
blade...otherwise
you'll
generate an
abominable
smell, and
even with a
sharp blade,
it can
sometimes
still smell
bad...and,
just wait till
you sand it!!!
To be
truthful, it
doesn't always
smell bad when
being worked,
however, it
does far too
often for my
olfactory
nerves. )
Pernambuco:
Another
imported
hardwood. The
treble
enhancement is
nicely broad.
Its main
enhancement
area is the
middle
midrange; it
sounds quite
even
elsewhere. Its
hue leans
slightly
toward orange.
It is often
used to make
bows for
violins,
cellos, etc.
Its species
name is:
Caesalpinia
brasiliensis
S.
Poplar:
This readily
available wood
highlights the
treble and
lightens the
lower midrange
and bass, even
more than
Basswood.
There is a
slight
emphasis in
the lower
treble and the
middle
midrange. The
name is
actually a
misnomer. This
greenish-gray
hardwood which
is commonly
mistaken as
poplar is
really a
member of the
magnolia
family of
trees. Yellow
poplar and
Tuliptree are
also common
names for
Liriodendron
tulipifera.
Purpleheart:
An imported
hardwood whose
name graces
wood from
approximately
20 species; it
is dark in the
upper-treble
and top
octave. Its
resonant area
is the lower
and middle
midrange. The
grain is
typically
straight with
medium to fine
texture, and
the color
vividly purple
(except when
fresh-cut,
when it is
grayish to a
dull brown).
Peltogyne
porphyrocardia
is one of the
species of
purpleheart.
Teak:
This wood is
popular with
the yachting
crowd because
it weathers
well. If your
middle
midrange or
top octave
needs taming,
this is a good
one to use.
Its resonance
peak is in the
lower
midrange/upper
bass. Burmese
teak, Tectona
grandis, is
straight-grained
with a coarse
and uneven
texture.
Zebrawood:
This light
golden-yellow
to pale
yellow-brown
imported
hardwood is
striped like
its namesake
with narrow
dark-brown to
almost black
veins or
streaks. It
has a smooth
peak in the
lower treble
and does not
roll-off the
top octave.
While it has
an emphasis in
the
upper-bass, it
has less upper
bass/lower
midrange
energy than
teak, and less
top octave
than amarello.
The dust and
odor from
cutting or
sanding
Zebrawood (Microberlinia
brazzavillensis)
can smell
unpleasant and
even be an
irritant.
Tuning
Blocks or
other
coupling-type
feet placed at
the extreme
outside edges
of a chassis
allow its
bottom panel
to vibrate
freely. This
enhances the
highs of the
system. If you
need more
"air,"
place the
blocks near
the edge, and
use a suitable
wood. To
lessen the
contribution
to the highs,
use a
"darker"
sounding wood
and/or move
the Tuning
Blocks closer
towards the
center.
More
highs: move
feet toward
outside edge
of chassis
Less
highs: move
feet toward
center of
chassis
Step
1. Select
a piece of
music that you
know well. It
should be
something that
has a rich and
well developed
midrange.
Step
2. Start
with the
coupling feet
nearest the
source. Try
different
woods (or
other
materials)
until the
harmonic
balance is
closer to
being correct.
Once you get
acquainted
with the sound
of several
types of wood,
experiment
with
combinations
of wood types.
This will
broaden the
effect.
Move
the blocks
closer to the
outside edge
of the chassis
for more
highs, further
underneath for
less.
(Note:
Either select
wood or other
materials with
the same
general bass
characteristics,
or be aware
that the bass
of the system
will also
change and
might need
re-tuning.)
Step
3. Go to
the next piece
of equipment
and, using
tuning blocks,
repeat step 2
as necessary.
As
valuable as
tuning blocks
are underneath
a component,
they are just
as valuable a
tuning method
(if not more
so), atop
audio
components.
Components
that are
sitting on
original feet,
aftermarket
coupling/decoupling
feet, or
isolation
shelves/platforms
can all
benefit from
Tuning Blocks
placed on that
component's
top cover. The
effect is
twofold: The
cover's high
frequency
vibrations
will be
somewhat
dampened, thus
reducing their
contribution
to the sound
of the system;
the resonant
signature of
the wood or
other material
will be added
to the sound
of the
component.
Two
or more types
of wood can be
stacked, one
atop the
other, for a
mixture of the
sounds of the
two woods. The
relative
position of
the stacked
wood is
important. For
example,
Basswood on
top of Lignum
Vitae sounds
different from
Lignum Vitae
atop Basswood.
Again,
I will
illustrate
tuning
principles
with products
whose
properties I
know very
well. The
reader is free
to find
equivalent
products.
There are two
types of
VansEvers
Cable-Multi-Resonators:
1)
The lighter
treble
versions are
built around a
plastic
clothes pin
and are very
easy to use.
Their intended
purpose is to
add or enhance
treble
resonances,
thus providing
a more even
support for
music's upper
harmonics.
2)
The heavier
midrange CMR
is built
around two
aluminum discs
of different
thickness’.
It uses a
wooden cable
clamp and
holds much
heavier and
larger
resonant
plates than
the lighter
version can.
Because the
diameter and
mass of the
plates can be
larger,
midrange
frequency
enhancement
and/or treble
dampening is
the result.

|