| Looking
for Mr.
Goodcar |
|
| Jason
Thorpe |
| 20
June
2000 |
"When
it comes to
amplifiers,
strange as
it seems,
America
makes the
best ones.
The Japanese
are starting
to catch up,
but the US
still puts
out the best
amps."
Perhaps
this isn’t
the most
auspicious way
to start off
my career here
at
StereoTimes,
but fame and
fortune awaits
me in the
world high-end
reviewing. So
here goes…
In
one of my
first emails
to Clement, I
foolishly
mentioned that
I have what I
consider to be
a damn good
car stereo.
His suggestion
was that I
write about
it. I actually
had my heart
set on
reviewing a
set of Krell
monoblocks,
but hey, I’m
willing to put
in my chops.
Actually, it
was either
this or the
Bose Wave
radio.
First
off, let’s
get a few
things out of
the way: I
wear my
baseball cap
brim-forward;
the crotch of
my pants rides
higher than my
knees; and I
rarely, if
ever, use the
word
"booty"
in
conversation.
In fact, I
consider
myself a
dyed-in–the-wool
audiophile. I
spin only
vinyl at home
and use an
all-tube
system driving
Magneplanars.
I also have a
serious cable
addiction that
I’m trying
desperately to
kick.
I
was interested
in audio
before I had a
license. Since
I started
smoking pot at
17 years of
age, music has
always been an
integral part
of my life.
And even after
I quit that
habit (pot),
the audio
Jones has
remained with
me. I also
love cars, so
the mix of
music and
autos seems
natural to me.
Audiophiles
and car
stereos. Now
there’s a
fine mix. I’m
sure that many
of you
remember the
outrage that
Wes Phillips’
column,
"Car
Tunes"
elicited when
he wrote about
his car audio
odyssey in
Stereophile
– many
"cancel
my
subscription"
letters were
printed in
successive
issues. I see
a distinct
polarization
among
audiophiles:
the ones who
drive
light-blue K
cars or
babyshit brown
Volvos just
don’t seem
to "get
it".
For
those of you
who may not
have followed
Wes’ column,
I’d like to
sum it up for
you here:
-
Wes
tries to
install
Audio
Alchemy
gear in
his car
and fails
miserably.
-
Wes
tries to
upgrade
his
charging
system and
fails
miserably.
-
Wes
tries to
eliminate
a ground
loop
(resulting
in nasty
hum) and
fails
miserably
over the
course of
four
issues.
-
Wes
buys lots
of
equipment
based upon
manufacturers’
recommendations
and never
ends up
with what
he
considers
high-end
sound.
Wes
is one of my
favorite
journalists,
and I don’t
want to slam
him here, but
his column did
nothing to
promote car
audio to the
readers of
Stereophile.
His approach
was haphazard:
He added
component
after
component,
never
following a
sensible
upgrade path.
He’d listen
to
manufacturers
and attempt to
shoehorn in
gear that was
totally
unsuited to
his needs. I’m
not surprised
that he was
never truly
satisfied with
his system.
What Wes did,
in fact, was
approach
upgrading his
car stereo
just like many
non-audiophiles
approach home
hi-fi.
Well
I’m here,
hopefully, to
stop you from
going that
route.
What
I’d like to
do is walk you
though my
system as it
sits right
now, and
describe how I
chose each
part. If, at
the end, you’re
still reading,
hopefully you’ll
email me some
feedback
asking that I
either cease
and desist or
write more
articles based
upon your
needs and
interests.
Let’s
start at the
front end. As
all audiofools
know, the
source of the
signal is of
paramount
importance.
Anyone who’s
reading this
is probably of
the opinion
that a lousy
source will
result in
lousy sound,
no matter what
amps and
speakers
follow it up.
Well, ladies
and gents, the
same thing
goes for car
audio.
I
know, there’s
a higher noise
floor and all
of the details
are going to
be drowned
out. But that
isn’t the
whole story
here, folks.
Fatiguing
treble from
harsh DACs
will carry
right through
road howl, and
this
detraction
tends to be
exacerbated by
the higher
volumes you’ll
tend to listen
at while on
the road. It
also turns out
that you can
hear through
the noise
floor,
somewhat like
detail that’s
buried below
surface noise
and tape hiss.
All of this
makes a good
deck
worthwhile in
the mobile
environment.
So
what makes a
good head
unit? In my
opinion,
simplicity is
best. A friend
of mine, Colin
Kay, owns a
high-end car
stereo store
here in
Toronto.
Autoworks does
some fairly
exotic
installations:
Colin’s
Corvette has a
Sonic
Frontiers
Transdac and
Jitterbug
housed in some
incredibly
extravagant
custom work.
But that’s a
show car and
for us simple
consumers,
Colin would
say, simpler
is better.
Colin
is a true
audiophile,
and I’ve got
him to thank
for drawing me
into the world
of high-end
audio. Much of
his clientele,
though, is
hat-on-backward
baggy-panted
hip-hoppers,
and I get a
charge out of
watching him
deal with kids
who want him
to install
systems
consisting of
1000 watts’
worth of bass,
with a front
stage
consisting of
Rat Shack
supertweeters
glued to the
dashboard. He’ll
do it, but you
can see him
grinding his
teeth to
paste. Lights,
buttons, and
dancing
equalizers on
head units
seem to sell
well too.

Nakamichi
makes some
wonderful
sounding,
solidly built
head units. I
have an MB-100
in-dash 6-pack
CD changer
with external
preamp and 24
bit DAC. This
is a fairly
expensive
unit. It has
no flashing
lights, no
dancing
graphic
equalizers,
and it most
certainly
lacks the
remote
controlled,
automatically
retracting
6-inch video
screen that
Colin’s
currently
installing in
an outrageous
Z28 along with
4 15"
subwoofers
driven by 2400
watts. Can’t
you just smell
the
testosterone?
While
there’s no
way that you’re
going to be
able to avoid
bass and
treble
controls –
heck, you’re
gonna be stuck
with a
loudness
button whether
you like it or
not – try to
get a deck
without
built-in
amplification.
This isn’t
as easy as it
seems. Just
like in home
audio, where a
preamp with
only volume
and selector
is more
expensive than
a receiver
with a million
buttons, knobs
and lights,
car audio
decks that are
preamp-only
will be more
expensive than
their powered
brethren.
Besides
the MB-100,
Nakamichi also
makes a single
CD player with
an 18 bit DAC
that is quite
reasonably
priced. I’ve
heard it, and
it also sounds
very good.
Unfortunately,
it has
built-in
amplification.
There’s a
million ways
to skin a cat,
and I’m sure
that many
other
companies make
good sounding
decks. But as
with home
gear, avoid
frills,
lights, and
extraneous
buttons if
possible Denon
makes some
decks that fit
the bill, but
I haven’t
heard them
myself.
From
the deck, the
signal has to
travel to an
amplifier. Any
good store
will roll
their own
interconnects.
You can go
crazy and use
home cables,
but remember
that the car
environment is
most
unfriendly to
low-level
signals, and
you may end up
with a vicious
hum that’ll
drive you
witless. This
is an area
where you may
want to follow
the advice of
the installer.
Compromise and
insist on WBT
RCA’s if you’re
feeling
exposed here.
When
it comes to
amplifiers,
strange as it
seems, America
makes the best
ones. The
Japanese are
starting to
catch up, but
the US still
puts out the
best amps.
Again, there
are tons of
different
amplifier
companies, and
many of them
put out a good
product. Just
make certain
that you avoid
Kenwood, Sony,
Pioneer, and
the like. Many
of the lower
end companies
rate their
amps at
"maximum"
watts. 300
watts max is
more like 50
watts from a
respectable
company. Car
amps tend to
be rated at 4
ohms, and a
good one will
double its
power into 2
ohms. Really
good ones will
double it
again into 1
ohm. In my
last car, I
had an
amplifier made
by Soundstream
that was rated
at 50 wpc into
4 ohms, and
would put out
600 watts into
½ ohm mono.
How you ask?
Beats me, but
it was chock
full of
transistors
and big caps,
and had huge
traces on the
circuit board.
If
you want a
fairly simple
system, the
easiest way to
go is to buy a
good 4 channel
amp and bridge
two of the
channels in
order to power
the subwoofer.
4 channel amps
usually have
onboard
crossovers
which is a
good idea in
order to
decrease the
complexity
further.
Active
crossovers and
bi-amping are de
rigeur in
mobile audio,
as passive
crossovers
between subs
and satellites
don’t have
the
flexibility
that’s
required in
the small
confines of a
car.
In
my car I
currently have
an Xtant 3300,
which is a
flexible 3
channel amp
that is
seriously
underrated at
65 watts to
the two front
channels and
300 watts to
the subwoofer.
It also has a
beautiful
stainless
steel chassis
that is very
big on the ooh-ahh
factor. Xtant
makes a very
smooth
sounding amp,
and the
on-board
crossover is
expandable to
24db/octave,
which helps
keep all of
the midrange
out of the
subwoofers.
But
let’s face
it, audio’s
all about MORE
BOXES! We don’t
have separate
amps, preamps,
DACs, and
phono stages
because they
sound better.
We have them
because they’re
sooo
cool. So if
you want to go
whole hog on
your car
system, you need
an amp for
each speaker,
a crossover to
split the
signals, and
heck, why not
slap in a
quasi-parametric
equalizer just
for the
shopping fun.
But
whatever you
do, make
certain that
you get a
subwoofer (or
4!) designed
for a sealed
box. This is
really the
only practical
way to get
linear, deep, accurate
bass. One
10"
subwoofer can
be installed
in a box that
will only take
up 1 cubic
foot of space.
That’s
small, folks.
And that one
sub, powered
by 200 watts,
will give out
satisfying,
tight bass.
This is thanks
to "cabin
gain" the
small
enclosure of a
car will
compound low
bass notes,
giving you
10-15db of
increased
output, as
compared to
free-air, at
30hz. That’s
why the Z28
with the 4
15" subs
will be able
to put out
150db at 25
Hz. Just
remember that
you’ve got
Colin to thank
when you’re
woken up at
3am thinking
that you’re
being targeted
by artillery.
I
have 2 JL
Audio 10w6
subwoofers in
a small sealed
box in the
trunk of my
Jetta. These
subwoofers
show the Xtant
amplifier a
3-ohm mono
load, which
means that
each sub is
receiving
about 200
watts. With
this setup, I
get tremendous
low end that
far surpasses
my home
system. It’s
tight,
authoritative,
and yes, it’s
loud when I
want it to be.
In my old Jeep
Grand
Cherokee, I
had 3 of these
subs. In that
vehicle, with
600 watts (1
ohm, mono
load!) when I
cranked it up
with some
bass-heavy
music it felt
like I was
going to have
an embolism.
But
circumstances
dictated a
downsizing,
yet I don’t
feel any lack
with only two
of these
monster
subwoofers. I
highly
recommend
them.
Front
speakers can
be very
tricky. While
there are some
objective
parameters
that you can
use to choose
amps and head
units, nothing
is going to be
more
subjective
than your
choice of
speakers. I
personally can’t
stand MB Quart
speakers, as I
find them
bright enough
to strip
paint. But
many people
absolutely
love them. My
personal
favorites are
made by Oz
Audio. These
separates
(5" or
6"
midbass,
1"
tweeter and
passive
crossover) use
a soft dome
tweeter. The
surround is
rubber, which
I personally
like for a
mobile
environment.
These speakers
image superbly
and have a
subdued treble
that I find
quite
soothing. As I
said before, I
listen at
higher levels
in the car,
and a rising
top-end tends
to irritate
me. With the
Oz speakers, I
can have the
volume fairly
high and still
hold a
conversation.
If
at all
possible, you
want to get a
6"
midbass in the
doors. This
may
necessitate
some custom
work, but hey,
there are
sacrifices to
be made. If
your car is
leased, you
may have to
make do with
5" This
is going to be
vehicle
dependent and
your installer
can help you
here. Mount
the separate
tweeters as
close to the
mids as
possible,
preferably as
far away from
your ears as
you can, as
this tends to
minimize the
difference in
distance from
the tweeters
to your ears.
Don’t mount
them on the
dash, as
imaging will
suffer. Don’t
glue them to
the windshield
or rear view
mirror either.
Finally,
if you’re in
the process of
choosing an
installer/shop,
try this
skill-testing
question: Ask
him what type
of power and
ground wire he’ll
use for the
amps, and
where he’ll
fuse them.. If
he suggests
anything
smaller than 4
gauge, and
recommends
putting the
fuse anywhere
other than
within
12" of
the battery,
back slowly
away and thank
him for his
time.
There’s
much more that
goes into a
high-end car
system that
the bits and
pieces that I’ve
related here.
I could go on
about
capacitors for
auxiliary
energy
storage,
equalization,
mass dampening
of resonating
panels and box
construction
ad infinitum.
But I’d
really like to
sum up this
(far too long)
article by
saying that if
you love
music, stereos
and cars, you
owe it to
yourself to
delve into the
world of
mobile audio.
It’s
possible to
build a
satisfying
system for
less than the
price of a
good home DAC.
True, this
system wouldn’t
be quite as
good as a
high-end home
system, but
that’s what
the upgrade
bug is for,
right?

|