| Power
to the
People |
| Survey
of
Quality
Power
Cords
from
ElectraGlide,
Magnan,
Sahuaro,
Shunyata
and Tek-Line |
|
Noel
T. Keen |
|
1
December
1999 |
Specifications
Electra
Glide Audio
c/o William Scott
Hall III
Suite A -2772
Burden Creek Road
St.John's Island
South Carolina
29455
803.559.4202
http://www.electraglideaudio.com
E-mail: eglide@dycon.com
Magnan
Audio Cables
355 N. Lantana
#576, Camarillo,
CA 93010-6038, USA
805.484.9544
Fax: 805.484.9544
http://www.magnan.com
E-mail: JMagnan904@aol.com
Sahuaro
Audio
PO Box 26444
Phoenix, AZ 85068
602.943.2326; FAX
602.906.8716
Distributed by
Audio Excellence,
940
E. Cavalier Dr.,
Phoenix, AZ 85014;
Phone:
602.277.0799
Email:alankafton@worldnet.att.net
Shunyata
Research Inc.
7755 Long Lake Rd.
Port Orchard, WA
98366
Ph. 360.871.0586
Fax. 360.871.0592
http://www.powersnakes.com
Email: caelin@shunyata.com
Tek-Line
1224 W. Robidoux
St.
Wilmington, CA
90744
E-mail: TekLineAV@aol.com
Phone:
310.835.2967
"Any
of the cords
listed above can
be counted on to
give improved
sound over stock
power cords and
represent good
value for the
money in view of
the current
technology."
Preliminaries
NBS
was one of the
first companies to
market improved
(and generally
expensive)
after-market power
cords for high-end
audio components.
It was
ElectraGlide,
however, that some
two years ago led
the way in
providing cords
which provided
major improvements
in sound quality.
Subsequent
developments have
been rapid and we
now have at least
20 companies
selling power
cords promising
major improvements
in sound quality
as compared to the
rather generic
cords that are
usually provided
with audiophile
gear. Accordingly,
it was of interest
to investigate
some of the best
of these. Over the
course of what
turned out to be a
two-month
exercise, I
evaluated a total
of 15 different
after-market power
cords. The initial
reference points
were the
ElectraGlide
ReferenceGlide Mk
on digital (that I
had used for about
one year) and the
Magnan Signature
power cord/strip
to the power amps,
both run from
dedicated lines.
Several of the
candidate cords
failed to beat
these references
in my system.
About
three weeks into
the testing, I
received the PS
Audio Power Plant
P300 (see my
review and the
follow by Frank
Alles in
StereoTimes.com).
The P300 provided
increased sound
quality, but also
provided a level
playing field for
the various power
cords used with
the Krell CD
player (except, as
noted below, the
Magnan cords could
not be used with
the P300). The
Power Plant 300
only provides 300
watts output and
as such, it could
also not be used
with power cord
tests on the KR
amplifiers. These
amps were plugged
directly into a
dedicated 20-amp
wall outlet or to
the existing
Magnan Signature
power cord/strip.
I
did conventional
ABA testing with
short-term
listening to
selected CD tracks
at identical
volume levels
(checked with an
SPL meter) and
longer term
listening of
several tracks
from the same CD.
This allowed
assessment of the
microsonic effects
of particular
power cords
(clarity,
resolution, etc.
on particular
short signature
features, whether
it be cymbals,
drum strokes, a
bass viol passage
or whatever), as
well as the
macrosonics (how
musical and ‘live’
the setup sounded,
a summation of
thousands of
microsonic cues).
Software
Tracks That Were
Informative
Since
testing was
extensive, more
than 100 CD tracks
were used in this
evaluation. Rather
than insert
references to
particular CD
tracks in the
commentaries, the
following were
useful to assess
the power cords.
These tracks are
all musical,
relatively well
recorded, provide
good diagnostic
cues to compare
component and
power cord effects
and generally give
systems a good
workout:
A
Taste of Violin,
Jeremy Cohen,
"In the
blue" and
other tracks
(Clarity CCD 1012)
Flamenco
Mystico,
"Rondena para
sabicas",
(Golden String
GSCD 016)
Ring Without
Words, Wagner,
track 10 from Gotterdammerung
(Telarc CD-0154)
Tone Poems,
"Good Old
Mountain Dew"
(Acoustic Disc,
ACD10)
Lost Worlds,
"Matawi:
Killer of
Men" (Hearts
of Space, HS
11054-2)
Marin Marais,
CD 1, track 8
of "Premier
Livre de Pieces de
Viole" (Ricercar
205842)
Brothers in
Arms, Dire
Straits, "Why
worry"
(Warner 9 25264-2)
Pan Pipes and
Organ, "Doina
de la domasnea"
and other tracks (Cellier,
Pv750001)
Dark Side of
the Moon,
"Brain
damage"
(Mobile Fideltiy,
UDCD 517)
Folk Dancer,
Muddy Waters,
"Good morning
school girl"
(Mobile Fidelity
UDCD 593)
James Newton
Howard and Friends,
"She"
and "Amuseum"
(Sheffield CD-23)
Chestnuts,
"Hard Times
Come Again No
More"
(Woodpecker,
WP109CD)
Ultimate
Demonstration Disc,
several tracks,
including 5, 11,
23, 25, 29 (Chesky
UD95)
Café Blue,
Patricia Barber,
"What a
shame"
(Premonition
Prem-737-2)
Das Heldenleben,
Richard Strauss, Der
Wischenvorhang
(Ref Recordings,
RR83CD)
C.I. Williams,
"Because of
you" (Mapleshade
04532)
Ronnie Earl and
the Broadcasters,
"Kansas City
Monarch" (Audioquest
AQ1018)
Wrecking Ball,
Emmylou Harris,
"Goodbye"
(Warner 6180-4-2)
Here’s to Ben,
Jacintha,
"Danny
boy" (Groove
Note, GRV2001-2)
Evaluations
Power
Cords to the Krell
KPS 20-iL CD
Player
In
this phase, both
the Krell amp and
the KR monoblocks
were used to drive
the system full
range. The Krell
amp was powered
with an IEC20
jumper from the
Magnan Sig/strip
and the KR amps
were powered by
various cords
discussed below,
either from a
dedicated wall
outlet or from the
Sig/strip. I was
surprised that all
of the cords
recommended below
equaled or
surpassed the
reference
ElectraGlide
ReferenceGlide Mk
II cord in my
system. Notes with
the Krell and KR
amps driving the
system full range
were quite similar
and so will not be
differentiated.
Because of their
greater mid/treble
resolution,
however, the KR
amps provided a
more critical
stage on which to
assess the various
cords.
Recommended
Moderate Priced
Cords
These
cords all
performed well in
my system and
benefited from use
with the P300. The
cords all gave
similar sonic
signatures when
run from the P300,
providing high
resolution and
detail, yet
maintaining a high
level of
musicality. When
plugged into the
wall outlet, the
SlipStream and Tek-Line
cords exhibited a
tendency to
brightness on some
material, but use
of the P300
generally
eliminated this.
Readers, of
course, should
audition any
candidate cords in
there own room.
The overall
ranking of the
three cords in
this group was:
Tek-Line
D12W —$399
Retail—Third
Two
versions of this
cord were
supplied: the
standard version
($299 retail) and
the W version
($399 retail),
which has a gold
plated Watt-A-Gate
gold line plug.
While I used the W
version in most
listening tests, I
could not
distinguish
particular
differences
between the two
cords in my
system. The cords
are about ˝ inch
in width and solid
but quite
flexible.
Construction seems
first rate and
professional.
The
Tek-Line D12W gave
less resolution
than the
SlipStream and
less air and depth
than the Black
Mamba. Bass tended
to be tight and
very coherent,
perhaps bettering
the other two
cords in this
respect. On some
material, such as
the Flamenco
Mystico track
listed earlier, I
preferred the D12
to the other two
cords in this
category. At its
price, the D12 is
a definite
contender. It also
beat several other
cords that were
judged to be of
lower resolution
and quality, that
do not appear on
this list.
Shunyata
PowerSnakes Black
Mamba —$699
Retail—Second
The
PowerSnakes Black
Mamba is a recent
permutation of a
power cord made by
Shunyata. It uses
the
"Stardust"
that is also
present in the
costlier King
Cobra power cord,
but only in a
single layer.
According to
designer Caelin
Gabriel, Stardust
acts as a high
frequency RFI
trap, effectively
removing this
common power line
contaminant. I
will discuss more
on the design
philosophy of the
PowerSnakes later.
The Black Mamba is
black, and one
inch or slightly
more in diameter.
It is black, very
flexible and easy
to handle and has
high quality but
not gold
terminals, one of
which is a
standard female
IEC plug. The cord
has a first class
appearance.
The
Black Mamba gave
an excellent sense
of air around
instruments and
very good
instrumental and
vocal presence. It
was somewhat laid
back on certain
material and the
level of
resolution was
generally not as
high as the
SlipStream. The
Black Mamba was
exceptionally
musical and did
not exhibit
brightness under
any circumstances.
My notes
consistently
mention a sense of
ease in musical
presentation with
this cord. It
showed some of the
same
characteristics as
the King Cobra,
discussed below,
but in fact falls
far short of its
performance level.
Sahuaro
SlipStream —$599
Retail—First
This
somewhat unusual
cord uses a
plastic mesh air
dielectric
"pod"
near the IEC plug
and this in turn
plugs into a l/2
inch black,
solid-core power
cord, called a
"tail"
by Sahuaro,
through a rather
plain appearing
standard AC plug.
The cords are
hand-built to
desired lengths
and terminations.
Sahuaro offers a
60-day trial with
full refund
opportunity if you
are not fully
satisfied. An
independent ground
line crosses the
pod and can be
unplugged if the
user elects to
float ground on a
component. Sahuaro
recommends against
using any PLC and
suggests plugging
the tails directly
into a wall
outlet. I used it
both in this way
and plugged into
the PS Audio Power
Plant 300.
Sahuaro
has developed a
white paper on
their technology,
excerpts of which
I will mention
here. The Sahuaro
approach to power
cords has been to
use an air
dielectric to
remove energy
absorbing
materials near the
conductors. The
pod contains the
hot and return
wires surrounded
by only minimal
chemical
insulation to
retard oxidation.
The remainder of
the dielectric is
air. Such a
configuration is
claimed to allow
the
electromagnetic
field to expand
externally,
leaving the
structure
unhindered by
field
contamination.
This is felt to
facilitate
electron flow
through the
conductors in a
manner more free
of compression,
distortion, etc.
Sahuaro cords are
distributed
through Sonic
Excellence, noted
earlier, and can
be auditioned with
a 60-day return
policy.
The
SlipStream gave
excellent
resolution with
the CD player,
with good
soundstaging,
detail, and
articulation of
the instruments
and singers. The
SlipStream could
exhibit a tendency
to brightness on
some software when
run from a wall
plug, but this
largely
disappeared when
run from the PS
Audio Power Plant
P300. The
SlipStream did not
present as lush
and palpable a
presentation or as
great resolution
as some of the
higher priced
cords, but is an
excellent
performer,
irrespective of
its price point.
Recommended
Higher Priced
Cords—Magnan
Bronze &
Shunyata King
Cobra
The
following two
cords gave (as
they should, in
view of their
price) performance
that was generally
above the three
previous cords.
Magnan
Bronze Power cord—$1400
Retail—Second
The
bronze power cord
employs very thin
bronze
ribbon-conductors
with proprietary
internal filtering
devices at both
ends. As with all
Magnan products,
the thin ribbons
reduce phase
errors. Because of
the thin
conductors,
current draw is
limited to one
ampere. This in
effect excludes
its use with power
amplifiers, but it
is fine with
preamps, CD
players and other
front end
components that
don’t draw much
power. The Magnan
bronze comes in a
standard 8 foot
length. The cable
is very fat (ca.
two inches, with a
gray mesh outer
jacket) as are the
end pieces, even
more so than the
Signature cord.
Standard IEC
terminal plugs are
supplied and
outlet strips are
not available.
Soon after
receiving the PS
Audio Power Plant,
I found that the
Bronze and
Signature cords
were driving the
P300 nuts.
Plugging either
cord into the P300
without connection
to any component
led to an
indicated 140
watts on the P300
wattage output
readout. This
turned out to be
due to the use of
extensive
capacitative
filtering in the
Bronze (and
Signature) cords
that interferes
with the DSP AC
signal oscillators
of the P300.
Therefore, the
Magnan signature
and Bronze cords
were used only
from a dedicated
20 amp wall plug
or from the
existing Magnan
Signature
cord/strip.
Despite
the fact it could
not be used with
the P300, the
Bronze cord to the
Krell CD player
elevated system
performance above
that with the
three cords
discussed above.
The Bronze
provided greater
resolution and
detail with all
material played, a
very low noise
floor, and also
imparted a great
sense of ease to
music. When run
from a dedicated
wall outlet, it
could exhibit
traces of
brightness on some
material. This
tendency was
largely eliminated
when the Bronze
cord was run from
the Magnan
Signature
cord/strip, but
dynamics also
suffered somewhat
in compensation.
The Bronze cord
gave very good
tonality to my
ears, on guitar
strings, piano and
voice. The Bronze
is an excellent
product that
should be
auditioned with
first-class front
end components.
Shunyata
PowerSnakes King
Cobra—$1995
Retail—First
"The
PowerSnakes King
Cobra was the star
of the listening
sessions on the
Krell CD player. I
try not to get too
enthusiastic about
products because
you can never tell
when something
better will come
along—either in
the form of a
"Mark
453" version
from the same
designer, or from
another guy with a
great idea.
This
cord is designer,
Caelin Gabriel’s,
all-out,
cost-no-object
design. It is a
recently
introduced
production model
that is based on
the
"Anaconda"
cord which was
produced and sold
in small numbers.
The PowerSnakes
King Cobra is a
fat, jet black
cord, about 1.5
inches in
diameter. The body
of the cord is
quite flexible and
has very flexible
extensions at both
ends that make
connection to
components and
outlets easy. The
bulk of the cord
is enclosed in
three successive
layers of
"Stardust,"
the proprietary
anti-RFI material
described above.
The cord has high
quality
connectors,
including a gold
Watt-a-Gate AC
plug.
Caelin
is reluctant to
disclose much of
the technology
involving pending
patent
applications, but
states that the
King Cobra
contains 40
different parts,
and considerable
attention was
directed to
resonance damping
and RFI/EMI
control. Caelin
raises the
important issues
of magnetic and
electric field
reactance and
quantum field
effects as being
important in the
quality of power
delivery to
components, and he
de-emphasizes
current delivery
capability as
being a prime
problem. This
regards not only
the quality of
power provided
from the wall
outlet (or the
PLC, or whatever),
but also
degradative
effects from the
components
themselves. In
this regard, it is
known that digital
components have
the proclivity to
dump garbage back
into the AC power
line. Caelin
maintains that his
passive
"Stardust"
treatment absorbs
much of this high
frequency garbage,
both from the
power line and
from components,
to create a more
placid and normal
AC supply. He
analogizes this
situation to that
of a stream
running down a
mountainside and
then through a
lower valley—on
steep slopes the
flow is rapid,
deep and narrow,
while on the level
valley the flow is
slow, wide and
placid. Caelin
says that what he
tried to achieve
in his power cords
was to place the
component in a
quiet portion of
the stream. The
King Cobra can be
used for front end
components as well
as high-current
power amplifiers.
The
PowerSnakes King
Cobra was the star
of the listening
sessions on the
Krell CD player. I
try not to get too
enthusiastic about
products because
you can never tell
when something
better will come
along—either in
the form of a
"Mark
453" version
from the same
designer, or from
another guy with a
great idea. That
can make you look
pretty stupid for
having raved over
the "Mark
384" version.
However, within
the context of my
system, the King
Cobra cord to the
CD player was
special. It did
things I’ve
never heard from a
power cord, enough
to make even the
most grizzled
"cords don’t
make a
difference"
illuminary grin a
little bit. In
some ways, the KC
cord exhibits the
character of the
Black Mamba
described above,
with excellent
presence and
realism, but in
reality, the King
Cobra is a totally
different animal.
When compared to
other cords, my
listening notes
continually
referred to the
lowered noise
floor of the KC
cord, greater
spaciousness and
depth of
soundstage, and
more presence and
harmonic
integrity. This
cord tends to make
the presentation
from other cords
powering the KPS
20-iL sound more
congested and
closed. Of the
cords evaluated,
the King Cobra
alone had the
ability to
correctly place
instruments in the
soundstage and to
integrate them
with each other,
creating a sense
of reality and
authenticity. It
made the other
cords seem
somewhat
"hifi-ish"
by comparison.
The
KC cords also
imparted a great
sense of what I
call
"air"
around instruments
and singers. These
were given the
sense of
"living"
or
"breathing"
that we take for
granted in real
life but seldom
experience in
recorded music.
Reviewers
frequently refer
to the fact that
in real life sound
does not just come
from the mouth of
a singer as a
point source.
Instead, it
resonates from the
chest and oral
cavity as well,
creating a sort of
3-D hologram that
we recognize as
"live"
The King Cobra
created this
illusion for me.
The King Cobra
could be described
as lush, since it
fills the
soundstage with
ambience and is
"oh-so-good"
at coaxing the CD
player to portray
a very
analogue-like
experience.
Indeed, during my
initial listening
with the KC cord I
thought,
"oh-oh, with
all this lushness
are we missing a
lot of
detail/resolution?"
But, no, repeated
A/B comparisons
with other cords
convinced me that
all the detail
(and perhaps more)
is there, but it
is presented in a
very natural and
life-like way.
This product is
special—for
those wanting the
best on digital,
look the
PowerSnakes King
Cobra over—it
won’t bite.
Power
Cords to
Amplifiers
The
class A KR
Enterprise amps
each draw at least
300 watts
continuous power,
and as such, cords
must have good
power carrying
capacity.
Extensive
listening led me
to recommend the
cords above as the
best of the lot at
their particular
price points.
Compared to the
stock cords, the
various power
cords made
relatively less
difference with
the KR amps than
they did with the
Krell CD player.
As indicated
above, I could not
use cords to the
amps from the P300
Power Plant, so
they were either
plugged into a
dedicated 20 amp
wall circuit or
into the Magnan
signature
cord/strip.
Magnan
Signature—$800
Retail—Third
David
Magnan has
extensively
researched
interactions in AC
power cord design,
and this led to
the Magnan
Signature power
cords, combining
greatly reduced
time dispersion
ribbon conductors
and proprietary
built-in passive
filtering. These
cords combine
micro-thin alloy
and nonmetallic
ribbon
technologies with
air space/TFE
Teflon dielectric
construction. The
Signatures and the
recently
introduced Bronze,
described below,
are entirely hand
made. The
Signature power
cord is claimed to
improve all sonic
parameters—greater
resolution, image
focus, dynamics,
weight and impact,
along with a much
quieter
background. CD
playback is most
improved, due to
the particular
sensitivity of
digital timing
jitter to noise on
AC power. The cord
comes in a
standard 8 foot
length, with
shorter lengths
claimed to
diminish the
beneficial
effects. Longer
lengths are
available, as is a
six outlet strip.
Note the
discussion below
of capacitive
filtering in the
Sig cords and its
effect on the PS
Audio power Plant
P300.
Shunyata
PowerSnakes King
Cobra—$1995
retail—Second
I
will not repeat
the technical
details for the
PowerSnakes King
Cobra cords since
they are covered
above. Designer
Caelin Gabriel
states that they
can be used
anywhere in a high
end system, and I
found that they
worked quite well
with my power
amplifiers. On the
KR power amps, the
King Cobra cords
yielded some of
the
characteristics
noted on the CD
player, namely a
sense of ease and
musicality, with
beneficial effects
on soundstaging
and depth, air and
palpability. They
performed better
when run from a
wall outlet as
opposed to the
Magnan Signature
power cord/strip.
The latter
resulted in a
suppression of
dynamics and some
reduction of the
"airy"
character of these
cords.
ElectraGlide
Fat Boy Gold—$2000
Retail—First
Designer
Scott Hall’s
latest effort with
this highly
regarded cord
makes extensive
use of gold
throughout. Unlike
the King Cobra,
which uses gold
plated Watt-a-Gate
plugs; the Gold
Fat Boy cord uses
Leviton plugs and
IEC connectors
with 24 kt gold
coating. Scott
also strongly
recommends that
Fat Boy users
invest in gold IEC
male plugs on
components and
gold duplex AC
outlet plugs,
since he believes
that these also
make a major
improvement in
sound. The
standard Fat Boy
cords are short
(only five feet),
such that they
would not reach my
dedicated wall
outlet, and had to
be used with the
Magnan Signature
cord/strip. The
newest Fat Boy
cords have revised
outer tubes; new
damping controls;
RFI/EMI filtration
and the ribbon
conductors are
also sealed in a
vacuum. Thus,
while expensive,
the new cords
offer many
features relative
to the older
versions that sold
at the same price.
Scott recommends
that the Fat Boys
only be used on
preamps and power
amps, but not
digital
components.
Listening
trials were
somewhat
compromised
because the Fat
Boys were about a
month late in
arriving. However,
after one week of
constant break in
with a 125 watt
lightbulb, the Fat
Boys provided
excellent
resolution with
the KR amps,
better than any
other cord tried.
During the first
few days, this
high level of
resolution was
accompanied by a
tendency to
brightness, but
fortunately the
brightness
disappeared and
the resolution
remained.
Summary
Stewart
Marcantoni at
Weekend
Environments in
Port Orchard,
Washington (360
874 1201) is a
power cord fanatic
and probably has
more experience
comparing them
than most anyone
else. He believes
that power cords
should in fact be
considered as
components and
says that
audiophiles should
invest a
substantial
portion of their
system cost
(10-20% or more)
on high quality
cords. Stewart
argues that the
improvements in
sound generally
are greater than
the same funds put
into an upgraded
CD player or other
component. I tend
to agree with him.
Any of the cords
listed above can
be counted on to
give improved
sound over stock
power cords and
represent good
value for the
money in view of
the current
technology. While
the degree of
benefit will
doubtless vary
with systems and
there may be
better cords
available at the
various price
points, the cords
above should be on
a short list for
home audition by
audiophiles
thinking about
upgrading their
power cords.

|