| Harmonic
Tech
Versus
the
Tweakerholic? |
|
| Marhsall
Nack |
| 10
June
1999 |
 Specifications
Pro-Silway
7N
single-crystal
silver 1 meter
RCA terminated
interconnect
cables,
$399.00/pr.
7N
single-crystal
silver 1 meter
XLR balanced
interconnect
cables,
$439.00/pr.
Additional per
1 meter per
pair Pro-Silway
interconnect
cables,
$240/pr.
Harmonic
Technology:
12781 Legacy
Place
San Diego, CA
92131
Tel:
619/578-7788
Fax:
619/586-7918
E-mail: harmonic@san.rr.com
Website: http://www.harmonictech.com
Harmonic
Technology
Pro-Silway
MKII
Interconnects
Reference
system:
my LP12 with
AQ 7000
cartridge is
connected to a
Graham IC30
cable, which
in turn is
plugged into a
BYBEE
interconnect
filter. The
BYBEE's output
goes to Dan
Fanny's AHT
Non-Signature
phono stage.
The output
from the phono
stage is sent
to a McCormack
TLC-1 passive
line stage via
½ meter of
Harmonic
Technology
(HT)
Truth-Link
copper wire.
The passive
line stage
feeds another
½ meter of HT
Truth-Link,
into another
set of BYBEEs
and is then
run to my BAT
VK-200 stereo
amp. Magnepan
MG 3.3
speakers are
connected via
a 6' HT Pro-11
Plus.
The
Harmonic
Technology
Truth-Link
interconnect
became my
reference
because it
offered pretty
near
everything an
audiophile
dreams of, and
then added
many of the
characteristics
a music lover
dreams of. It
gives you
imaging and a
3-D
soundstage,
good bass and
extended
treble. Then
it adds signal
purity and
harmonic
integrity. It
seemed to me
as good as my
prior
reference, the
NBS King
Serpent II, at
about 1/5 the
cost. Out went
the NBS. Then
2 weeks ago in
went the Pro-Silway.
Listening
Impressions
You
can tell the
presentation
is improved in
a big way, but
it is
difficult to
get a handle
on precisely
what is
different. The
Pro-Silway had
the same
natural timbre
and good tonal
balance across
the audio band
as with
Truth-Link. As
time passed, I
noted more
clarity and
detail without
loss of body.
Increased
spaciousness
and
naturalness
were apparent.
The major
changes over
the Truth-Link
can be
described as a
more crisp,
clear and
solid sounding
presentation.
Instruments
had more
weight.
In
the middle of
all this, I
took a break
to make a
foray to my
favorite
classical
vinyl haunt,
Academy
Records on
West 18th
Street, in
NYC. I picked
up what have
become two
additions to
my desert
island pile.
One is the
well known Mahler
Symphony No.
3, with Mehta
and the LA
Philharmonic
(London
CSA2249). If
your system
can
accommodate
full
orchestra,
this disc will
overwhelm you.
Time and again
I put it on to
check out a
system change
and find I am
unable to lift
the needle
until at least
Side 1 is
finished. Lest
I forget to
mention the
performance is
first rate
with Mehta in
full creative
control. After
a steady diet
of baroque and
classical,
Mahler's music
comes as a
shock. One
hundred years
later, the
sensibility
seems
contemporary,
it being
sarcastic,
mocking, and
macabre. The
performance
seems almost
too perfect
and pure
sounding. And
maybe it is.
The
stage is very
deep with
silent space
between the
extremely well
reproduced
instruments.
With the Pro-Silway
in the system
it was easy to
discern the
recording
engineer’s
miking
technique. For
example,
towards the
end of Side 1
there is a
little drum
solo that
sounds like it’s
in another
room. It was
obviously
recorded with
a spot mike.
The
other disc is
a sleeper:
Actéon
by
Marc-Antoine
Charpentier
performed by
Les Arts
Florissants
led by William
Christie (Harmonia
Mundi HM1095).
Amazingly well
recorded in
1982, it
presents a
lush, warm and
intimate
acoustic that
will take over
your room with
an enormous
natural
soundstage.
The hall is
present,
lending
ambience so
that the space
between
performers
feels
occupied. This
kind of
ambience feels
more natural
sounding than
the cool
silence of the
Mahler third
symphony. This
work is an
early French
opera, written
around the
time Henry
Purcell was
composing in
England. I
find it almost
as enjoyable
as Purcell's
Dido and
Aeneas. By the
way, my
favorite
D&A is the
one with Janet
Baker led by
Anthony Lewis
(L'Oiseau Lyre
SOL60047),
recorded in
1962.
Whether
owing to this
group’s
original
instrument
practice or
respect for
the age of the
score, the
Charpentier
does not
exhibit full
blown operatic
mannerisms;
hence I can
enjoy it. The
singing is a
cross between
opera and
recitative.
Unlike say,
Jean Phillipe
Rameau
compositions
of fifty years
later, it
doesn't have
that
over-controlled
dramatic
exhibition of
vocal
technique that
I find
off-putting in
full blown
opera.
After
another 24
hours break-in
one begins to
notice
disconcerting
nuances, like
how the
harpsichord is
far right for
chorus
passages, but
moves to left
of center on
solo voice
sections. The
aural lens is
sharpening to
greater focus.
Another
by-the-way,
regarding
turntable
setup--long
ago I removed
the base of my
LP12. The
table sits on
a bunch of
hardened
carbon blocks
made by Air
Tight. The
blocks in turn
sit on a
sandbox, by
Bright Star.
The sandbox
sits on a
Townshend
Seismic Sink.
All of this
occupies the
top shelf of
my Solid Steel
model 410.
Anyway,
I acquired
more carbon
blocks and put
an additional
one under each
side of the
table. So now
there are
eight blocks
under the
table.
Surprisingly,
even with all
those levels
of isolation,
the
presentation
improved. As
the table was
mechanically
supported by
more blocks,
the soundstage
crystallized.
Center came
into focus.
Vagueness and
smearing were
reduced. The
result was an
increased
impression of
solidity with
rock-solid
images in
space.
Truth
Be Told
Finally
it was time to
put the
Truth-Link
back in place
between the
phono preamp
and the line
stage. The
Truth-Link
still sounded
good, but was
noticeably
recessive.
Imaging became
blurred. No
question, I
wanted the
Pro-Silway
back.
My
listening
impression
overall can be
summed-up as
follows: the
sound had more
vitality, it
was more
forward (than
the
Truth-Link);
the stage got
wider and the
imaging was
enhanced
without loss
of
instrumental
body. The Pro-Silway
Mk II presents
a substantial
improvement
over the
Truth-Link, a
cable I had
previously
considered to
be a contender
for the best
available.
|