| The
Bruce
Moore
Audio
Design
Companion
III
Vacuum
Tube
Preamplifier |
|
|
|
Henry
Wilkenson |
|
6
June 2001 |
Specifications
Gain:
23 dB
Frequency
Response: 1 Hz to
500 kHz +0, -1dB
Maximum Output:
25V RMS
THD: < .03% @
2V RMS out
Input Impedance:
75K ohm
Output Impedance:
500 ohms
Noise: -98dB below
2V RMS output
Absolute Phase:
Non-Inverting
Tube Complement: 3
ea. 6DJ8/6922, 2ea
12AU7
Power Consumption:
30 watts
(detachable line
cord)
Dimensions: height
= 3.6" (79
mm), width =
16" (381 mm),
depth = 12"
(241 mm)
Shipping Weight:
20 lbs.
Notes: Has 5 Line
Inputs, Main Out
and Tape out
Price: $3000
Description
The
Bruce Moore
Companion III
preamplifier is a
well designed high
end line stage in
the middle of the
Bruce Moore line
between the
Companion II-b at
$1650 (?) and the
Dual Mono
Preamplifier at
$6550.00. There is
also the Dual 70,
70 watt tube power
amp at $4300.
You’ll
need a firm grip
in trying to lift
the Companion III.
Although its
shipping weight is
listed at twenty
pounds, it feels
heavier. This is a
solid, well put
together piece of
gear. The
faceplate consists
of a quarter-inch
slab of brushed
aluminum adorned
by four large
rotary knobs. The
first from the
left is the source
selector. It
controls the
choices for phono,
tuner, CD1, CD2
and tape.
(Remember, this is
a line stage.
There isn’t any
phono stage. You’ll
need to connect
your own.) The
next two knobs are
for the left and
right channel
volume controls.
They’re detented,
making it much
easier to set the
balance between
left and right
channels. The last
knob is the mode
selector. It
controls the mute
and a/c on/off.
You may leave the
pre-amp warmed up
in the mute
position between
listening
sessions. One
caveat: you must
engage the mute
before switching
between sources.
Otherwise, you
will cause a large
thump that will do
your system no
good. There are
two small blue
lights at the
bottom center of
the faceplate. The
first indicates
power-up. The
second lights up
when you take the
pre-amp out of
mute. All controls
are
straightforward
and easy to use.
Their solid feel
is commensurate
with a high
quality pre-amp.
A
peek inside
reveals a
well-laid out
circuit board
loaded with high
quality parts and
the five tubes
listed in the
headnote.
The
rear panel sports
a total of
fourteen RCA
connectors
straightforward in
their layout. They
do not appear to
be gold plated but
are of high
quality
nonetheless. There
is also a
conveniently
placed fuse holder
and an IEC socket
for the detachable
power cord.
(Something else to
tweak.)
Aside
from the sound of
tube gear, another
advantage the
pre-amp offers is
the ability to
tailor the sound
by changing tubes.
How many of you
have gone to the
expense of chasing
down NOS (new old
stock) because you
absolutely must
have Mullards or
Telefunkens with
their legendary
characteristics?
In this case,
there are only
five tubes to
contend with, but
that can still be
expensive if your
tastes run toward
matched sets.
Fortunately,
pre-amp tubes tend
to last for quite
a while.
The
Sound
Quality
of parts and build
is all well and
good, but they don’t
mean a thing
unless they swing.
So, how does this
pre-amp sound?
Very good, I’m
glad to say. The
overall character
of the Companion
III tends to the
warm side. This is
not surprising,
given its tube
design. Please don’t
misunderstand,
this is not
yesteryear’s
"classic"
tube signature. It’s
not syrupy or
overly euphonic.
Rather, it renders
a rich harmonic
picture that
allows the
differences
between two
musicians playing
the same
instruments to be
clearly perceived.
Overall, I find
that the Companion
III really
underscores the
differences
between
recordings. Good
recordings sound
very, very good
while poor ones
are hard to hear
by comparison. I
won’t give you a
blow by blow
account of every
recording that I
used to evaluate
the Companion III
– just the ones
I found to be
particularly
noteworthy.
I’ve
made no secret of
my fondness for
Mapleshade CDs. I
appreciate the
analogue quality
they consistently
exhibit. The
Clifford Jordan
Quartet’s Live
at Ethell’s
is one of the best
examples of the
Mapleshade sound.
The listener is
presented with a
wide soundstage
with an
appropriate sense
of depth. The
instruments are
well located
within the stage,
but nothing is
etched or overdone
imagewise. Rather
than a razor sharp
edge around any
instrument, I
heard a very
natural if
somewhat soft
focus. The sonic
cues that give a
sense of room size
come across very
nicely. You know
that this is a
live recording,
but at the same
time there isn’t
any hyper-detail.
You won’t hear
any pins dropping
here.
Carmen
Lundy’s Self
Portrait is a
particularly well
done JVC XRCD
recording. I
noticed a
remarkable degree
of midrange
transparency but
again, neither
cold or sterile.
These qualities
were true of all
of the digitally
recorded XRCDs.
For
this review, I
paired the
Companion III with
the bel canto EVo
power amp. Since
the noise floor of
the bel canto is
extremely low, it’s
not surprising
that I heard a
trace of tube
noise when I
placed my ear
within a few
inches of the
speaker. However,
I never heard it
from my listening
position. It never
interfered with
the music.
I
find that midrange
transparency is
something of a
common denominator
of high-end gear.
I particularly
listen to piano
recordings to see
how well that
tonally complex
instrument comes
across. The piano’s
harmonic structure
and decay rates
are fairly
difficult for many
systems to
reproduce with any
degree of realism.
The Companion III
did not disappoint
in any way here.
It’s clarity
allows you to
"hear
into" the
soundstage minus
the veils common
in varying degree
to lesser gear.
Is
the Companion III
perfect? Of course
not! What is?
Compared to
another line stage
I’m familiar
with, it was a
little less
refined in two
ways. While
listening to a
performance of
Charpentier’s Concerto
Vocale on the
harmonia mundi
label, the
Companion III did
not quite have the
resolution of the
other line stage.
It introduced a
small degree
hardness to vocal
passages. I have
to emphasize these
are very small
points. The other
line stage costs
$2K more. In all
other respects,
the Companion III
is competitive
with the higher
priced spread. For
the additional
$2K, you can
resolve a picked
nit and a half.
The
Companion III came
with four Vibrapod
footers. I placed
the pre-amp on
three Poly
Chrystal cones on
a Rosinante shelf,
two accessories
accounting for a
large sonic
improvement at the
frequency extremes
and in soundstage
focus. The bass
was much more
extended and
articulate, the
top more open and
a touch sweeter.
On good
recordings, the
soundstage was
wide and deep, but
instrumental
placement and
proportions
remained
realistic.
This
is a line stage
that I could
easily live with.
It is so good, in
fact, that it
piques my
curiosity about
the Bruce Moore
Dual Mono line
stage. In any
event, if you are
in the market for
a line stage, you
really should give
this one a listen,
particularly if
you are prepared
to spend more that
the $2,600 asking
price.
The
Music
|
Clifford
Jordan
Quartet,
Live
at
Ethell’s
|
Mapleshade
|
|
Carmen
Lundy, Self
Portrait
|
JVCxrcd
|
|
Marc
Antoine
Charpentier,
Concerto
Vocale
|
harmonia
mundi
|
|
Charlie
Byrd, For
Louis
|
Concord
|
|
Shirley
Horn, I
Thought
About
You
|
Verve
|
|
Gene
Harris, Live
at Otter
Crest
|
Concord
|

|