| The
Big
Combo |
| Zeus
Headphone
Amplifier
&
Grado
RS-1
Headphones |
| Russ
Novak |
| 9
December
1999 |
Specifications
Fuchs
Audio
Technology
73 Collins
Avenue,
Bloomfield, NJ
07003
Phone:
973-893-0225
afuchs@erols.com
or www.audioweb.com/fuchsaudio
Two
channel 1-watt
OTL tube
headphone
amplifier.
Tubes: 6-6EM7
tubes.
Topology:
constant
current
differential
input stage,
totem pole
type output
stage
w/separate
bias and
balance
controls.
Separate tube
regulated
power supplies
for each
channel.
Price:
$1,595.00.
"The
Zeus is
designed to
drive from 20
ohms and up. I
have
successfully
driven 8 ohm
Koss (Radio
Shacks too),
to impressive
volumes, but I
suggest 20 as
a fair
minimum.
Grados are 30
ohms and
Senheissers
are 300 ohms
(!). It's
output voltage
swing
increases as
impedance goes
up (as most
OTL's do).
Distortion is
.5% or less. I
don't play the
numbers game,
since you
can't hear the
difference
between .00001
and .1 %
anyway."
– Andy
Fuchs.
Grado
Laboratories,
Inc.
4614 7th
Ave, Brooklyn,
N.Y. 11220
John Grado,
President
Phone - 718
435-5340; Fax
- 718 633-6941
Web: www.gradolabs.com
E-mail hpsr60@aol.com
Grado
Reference RS1
Stereo
Headphones;
transducer
type dynamic
headphones,
open air;
frequency
response 12 Hz
– 30 kHz;
SPL at 1mV: 98
dB; nominal
impedance 32
ohms; drivers
matched to
within .05 dB.
Vented
diaphragm,
wooden air
chamber, Ultra
High Purity,
long crystal
copper in
voice coil and
connecting
cable. $695.
The
Summer of ’63
"…in
’63 it was
magical.
They gave me
wide-band
response for
just a few
dollars.
Getting this
close to the
music was an
experience.
All the
subtleties
that passed
unnoticed
through
speakers
were present
in delicate,
nuanced
detail. Even
today it’s
uncommon to
find a
speaker that
does as well
as a top
pair of
headphones."
Headphones.
The experience
of headphone
listening
sends my mind
rushing back
to the balmy
summer of 1963
in the Chicago
suburbs:
quiescent late
nights
reading, a
dawn breeze
through the
windows,
sleeping till
noon in summer
heat. Sixteen
is a time of
rapid
intellectual
growth for a
young man;
adult tastes
are formed. I
spent much
time in my
room reading
history,
politics, hi
fi, sports. At
16 one is
primed for
discovery. I
owned a 20
watt
integrated
tube amp from
Allied Radio
(Knight) and
two woefully
inadequate
Allied two-way
speakers. The
speakers
lacked any
bass response,
not even a
nice mid-bass
hump, and I
had no
financial
prospect of
replacing
them.
I
spent a lot of
time at E.J.
Korvettes in
the plaza,
studying the
art work on
albums,
reading the
covers, trying
to imagine the
sounds of the
strange music
that promised
Nirvana. At
$3.49 per
record I
couldn’t
afford to make
a mistake. Yet
I was
invariably
disappointed.
The sound just
wasn’t full
enough, didn’t
have
"presence;"
wasn’t
"there."
By
some means I
amassed $20
and bought
myself a pair
of Superex
headphones
along with a
speaker/headphone
switching box
(no jack on
the amp).
Decidedly
non-audiophile
I assure you.
Today we’d
find them
uncomfortable
to wear and we
would hear the
distortion.
But in ’63
it was
magical. They
gave me
wide-band
response for
just a few
dollars.
Getting this
close to the
music was an
experience.
All the
subtleties
that passed
unnoticed
through
speakers were
present in
delicate,
nuanced
detail. Even
today it’s
uncommon to
find a speaker
that does as
well as a top
pair of
headphones.
I
discovered
Debussy’s
piano music,
Chico
Hamilton,
Carmen McRae’s
jazz singing,
Ravel’s
"Daphnis
et
Chloe",
and Faure’s
Violin
Sonatas. My
immediate
surroundings
were removed
from the
musical
experience.
Nothing stood
between the
performer and
me. Sound was
immediate and
intimate,
unlike
anything else.
Of
course, that
illusion known
as
"soundstage"
is missing.
The music
originates in
your head:
left, right,
center, and
one hears
ambiance
information on
the recording,
but it is not
"layered"
in the sense
that a perfect
room/speaker
setup is. That
was a result I
could live
with at the
time in
exchange for
better
frequency
response.
I
put away the
headphones in
later years as
I gained
disposable
income and
concentrated
on the main
system in a
home of my
own. But I
always
remembered
what I
discovered on
those quiet
summer nights.
Reborn
In ‘97
"John
Grado
responded
again with a
pair of his
top-of-the-line
RS-1s. As
wonderful as
the SR60’s
are, the
RS-1’s are
masterpieces.
The bass is
deep and
full, even
more
transparent
and tightly
controlled
than the
SR60s."
Robert
"Houn’
Dawg"
Clark was on
the phone
panting over a
headphone
amplifier
designer Andy
Fuchs and he
had just
cooked up.
"I’m
bringing it
over. You
gotta hear
this."
It
was slapped
together in
makeshift
fashion with
miscellaneous
parts. But it
sounded great!
Instantly
apparent was a
transparent,
sweet sound
with deep
extension in
the bass.
Better yet,
this was all
bought without
the opaque
tube
colorations we
hear in some
speaker
amplifiers.
"Houn’
Dawg" was
pushing Andy
to make it a
commercial
product and I
concurred.
I
talked to Andy
about building
me one and I
purchased all
premium parts
and wire. Andy
developed a
handsome
chassis,
further
refined the
circuit, built
both of us
pairs, and I
hauled it
home. These
units were the
final stage in
what would be
known as the
Zeus Headphone
Amplifier.
Of
course I
couldn’t
have heard
what I heard
were it not
for the
courtesy
extended me by
John Grado.
He, of Grado
Laboratories
fame had sent
me a pair of
the wonderful,
inexpensive
SR60 dynamic
headphones
following a
visit to his
CES room the
year before.
Working with
some of the
solid state
headphone
amplifiers in
circulation, I
never felt I
got as much as
these little
‘phones were
capable of,
but through
the Zeus I was
floored. I got
back to John
to urge him to
hear this amp,
but I couldn’t
get the two
guys together.
Well, the best
laid plans…
John
Grado
responded
again with a
pair of his
top-of-the-line
RS-1s. As
wonderful as
the SR60’s
are, the RS-1’s
are
masterpieces.
The bass is
deep and full,
even more
transparent
and tightly
controlled
than the
SR60s. The top
end is more
extended and I
noticed a
reduction in
distortion I
wasn’t aware
of listening
to the SR60s
alone. With
the RS-1s I
was able to
hear into the
recesses of
recordings in
a way
impossible
with speakers.
Zeus
History and
Design
The
Zeus Headphone
Amp is a
transformerless
triode, low
feedback
headphone tube
amplifier with
all stops out
in design and
execution of
the signal
path. MIT
caps, 1% metal
film
resistors,
Teflon coated
silver wire,
and
Wondersolder
are used in
construction.
The unit has a
brass top
plate seated
in an oak
base. The
tubes sit atop
in open air
for
audiophiles
who like to
watch the
glow. It’s
an attractive
unit. I have
mine sitting
on a bookshelf
over the
computer desk
and spend long
hours
listening to
my Zeus/Grado
combination
while working.
The
unit has been
available on a
direct order
basis from it’s
designer, but
with formal
commercial
production, it
is being
offered for
$1595 through
Audioweb or to
get to his web
page directly
at www.audioweb.com/fuchsaudio.
$1,595 seems a
lot of money
compared to
what we might
like to spend
on a headphone
amp, but this
unit brings
sound
reproduction
past the level
of refinement
of the rest of
the system to
a sort of
realistic
bliss.
The
history of
Zeus follows
the typical
motivation
behavior of
audio
designers and
hobbyists:
perceived
inadequacy of
existing sound
quality
followed by
resolution.
Designer Andy
Fuchs recalls
that he
purchased a
pair of high
quality Grado
headphones but
was frustrated
by the
generally low
quality of
headphone
amplifiers
available on
the market.
Headphone
jacks on
supposedly
high quality
components
were similarly
inadequate.
Fuchs
began a period
of
experimentation
to achieve
better
results. He
first tried
conventional
single ended,
low power tube
amps. However
the resolution
of modern
headphones
revealed the
shortcomings
of this
approach. He
heard the
transformers
and a high
noise floor.
Designing
around that
problem didn’t
produce the
results he
wanted, so he
next built a
series of all
tube cathode
follower
circuits. This
approach
showed promise
in that it was
quiet and had
the resolution
he was looking
for, but Andy
was
unsatisfied
with the
dynamic output
limitations of
that type of
circuit.
Something
more akin to a
small OTL
(output
transformerless)
circuit seemed
the answer.
That advantage
of headphones
is that they
present a
simple load to
the amplifier
and do not
require much
power to drive
them to loud
levels. Andy’s
experience
working with
New York Audio
Labs on the
Futterman
amplifiers
gave him
insight into
what sort of
circuit to
design.
Next
he began a
search for an
acceptable
output tube
among the
limited
offerings on
the market.
The 6EM7 tube
was discovered
by accident.
He was looking
for a triode
tube with the
lowest
possible plate
resistance.
The reason was
that it would
produce the
lowest
possible
output
impedance
without
needing the
high feedback
that most OTLs
require to
achieve this
(the lower the
output
impedance the
less
interaction
with the
headphone load
and less
consequent
change to the
signal).
The
6EM7 is a
dual-section
tube. One
section is a
very low plate
resistance
triode, and
the second
section is a
fairly
conventional
high gain
triode, quite
similar to one
section of a
12AX7. It’s
original uses
were for
voltage
regulators and
vertical
output tubes
in B&W TV
sets. While no
longer a
production
tube, there
are thousands
in stock
worldwide.
The
Headphone Amp
uses three
6EM7’s per
channel. One
of the
prerequisites
for low noise
was a quiet,
regulated
power supply.
A tube
regulator
circuit (one
per channel)
uses the 6EM7
in a textbook
regulator
circuit, which
feeds the
audio stage.
The raw power
supply starts
from 500
Volts, and is
regulated to
400 volts. The
entire audio
circuit (input
as well as
output
sections) runs
on this
regulated
source
voltage.
The
input stage
tube sections
operate on
about 275
volts on their
plates, which
is a very
linear point
in the tube
curve. The
output stage
operates the
two (stacked
tubes) on 400
volts, which
puts each tube
section at 200
volts, a
conservative
operating
point that
assures long
tube life.
The
audio circuit
uses the two
high gain
triode
sections as a
constant
current
differential
amplifier. One
half takes in
the audio
signal, and
the second
half receives
the feedback
return from
the output of
the amplifier.
The second
tube sections
operate as a
totem pole
(single ended
push-pull)
output stage
with separate
bias and
balance pots
for each half.
The midpoint
of the output
stage is the
capacitor
coupled to the
phones. The
circuit is
stable enough
to operate
open load (no
feedback)
although it is
somewhat noisy
due to the
excessive
gain. The
circuit will
also run with
100% feedback
(a sign of the
circuit’s
inherent
stability) but
sounded
"pinched"
and sterile.
The original
prototype used
a pot in the
feedback loop
that allowed
Andy to tailor
the feedback
level to the
"sweet
spot",
where the
desired sonic
balance was
achieved.
The
circuit
produces about
½ watt
maximum output
into 8 ohms
(no you wouldn’t
be happy using
it to use it
to drive real
speakers, nor
is it
recommended).
Since dynamic
phones run the
gamut from a
low of 8 ohms
(Koss) to 30
ohms (Grado)
and a high of
about 300 ohms
(Sennheiser),
the amp needed
to be stable
into most any
load.
The
Grado
Reference RS1
Headphones
"This
is a true
reference
product.
Craftsmanship
is excellent
and
long-term
dependability
superb…"
Everyone
acclaims these
headphones as
state-of-the-art.
The $695 price
amounts to
"theft of
sound"
compared to
the cost of
speakers with
equivalent
performance.
They’ve been
reviewed all
over: Jack
English and
Wes Philips in
Stereophile
(a Stereophile
Recommended
Component),
Ken Kessler in
Hi-Fi News
and Record
Review,
and by Cory
Greenberg in Home
Theater
Magazine.
There are
several
reviews on the
web:
Or
go to the
Grado home
page: www.gradolabs.com
So
my purpose in
this section
will not be to
re-review
them, but to
add my
affirmation of
their quality.
This
is a true
reference
product.
Craftsmanship
is excellent
and long-term
dependability
superb (I’ve
used them over
two years).
They are
comfortable
and I’ve
worn them for
as long as 10
hours at a
time without
their physical
presence
diverting my
attention from
the music.
Your ears stay
cool due to
the open-air
design and the
‘phones are
ultra light
with a soft
leather
headband that
conforms well
to the shape
of the head.
The cups seat
well around
the ears
without
excessive
pressure. The
mahogany ear
cups are
specially
cured and
treated to
eliminate
resonance.
Unlike
the classic
left/right/center,
in-your-head
placement of
instruments
with classic
headphones,
the RS1 gets
the sound
outside your
head, outside
the headphone
cups. Ambient
information
retrieval is
huge. One is in
the musical
environment as
opposed to
"listening
forward"
to a stage
within a hall
or a pair of
speakers in a
room. I like
the effect. It
increases my
enjoyment
through
immediacy and
intimacy.
The
RS1 has an
ultra refined
treble range,
a very
necessary
trait in a
product worn
directly on
the ears. This
refined treble
was apparent
even with
cheaper, solid
state
amplification,
or even the
headphone jack
on my cassette
recorder.
Through the
Zeus the
smoothness,
liquidity, and
extension are
phenomenal.
The midrange
is rich,
neutral, and
natural. It
has no peaks
or dips
throughout the
range to
highlight
problems. Bass
is warm
without
bloating or
booming and is
transparent to
the lowest
depths. This
is the Grado
"house
sound," a
smooth
creaminess
without
opacity and an
absence of
resonant
coloration.
You hear it in
the $69.99
RS60, and you
get it in
spades with
lower
distortion in
the RS1.
Now
to be fair to
John Grado, I
need to
mention the
new head phone
amp Grado has
developed, the
RA-1. I have
not heard it
and John has
not heard the
Zeus. The RA-1
is a solid
state, battery
powered unit
that should
inherently
result in the
lowest noise
floor, but how
this will
compare with a
tube OTL
design is
another topic
entirely. I
just want to
tip you to the
fact that the
RS1/Zeus
combination
lock into each
other like
nothing I’ve
heard, like no
tube or solid
state guy
could dream
of.
Just
Some
Practicalities
The
Big Combo will
cost you
$2,290. You
don’t need
to do it all
at once. If
you already
own a pair of
high quality
headphones,
stick with
them and pick
up the
headphone amp.
Many people
already own
Sonys,
Sennheisers,
etc., and
regard them as
state of the
art. I won’t
quarrel. But
you owe it to
yourself to
hear them
through the
Zeus to learn
what they can
really do. Are
you ‘phoneless
at present?
Grado offers
the
universally
regarded SR60
headphones at
$69.99 and the
SR80 for a bit
more. That
gets the price
down
substantially.
You
can connect
the headphone
amp to the
tape outputs
of your preamp
or do what I
do. Take a few
extra seconds
to run the
interconnect
cable directly
between the
DAC and the
Zeus. Why put
extra
circuitry in
the way when
you are
settling in
for an evening
of music?
Another
strategic
consideration
is where the
headphone amp
will be placed
in relation to
your listening
position
(which can now
be anywhere in
the room ‘cause
you are freed
from speaker
placement).
You can
position the
Zeus at your
equipment rack
and run high
quality
interconnects
– not so
expensive
because you
already own
them (and you will
hear the
differences in
cables). But
if your
listening
position is
some distance
away, you’ll
have to run a
headphone
extension
cord. Not
ideal in my
view. Instead,
I place the
Zeus at my
desk and near
my couch where
the SR1’s
cord can
easily reach.
That
means using a
long
interconnect
from the
equipment
rack. If you
don’t have
the mega-bucks
to afford a
long run of
audiophile
grade
interconnect,
you don’t
have to
dismiss the
idea. I made a
25’ pair of
interconnect
from Mogami
Neglex 2549
microphone
cable and find
it tonally
accurate and
very
inexpensive.
This is a
simple
multi-strand
twisted pair
of wires with
a braided
shield.
"Float"
(do not
connect) the
shield to the
RCA plugs at
the signal
source end
(the DAC) and
"ground"
the shield to
the negative
pin at the
receiving end
of the signal
(the headphone
amp end).
Break them in
and you’ve
got a super
pair of
interconnects.
You lose
almost nothing
for headphone
listening.
The
Big Combo
Sound
"The
audiophile
is
completely
freed from
the external
environment
and finds
himself 'in'
the
orchestra,
hearing
detail and
nuance not
available
with
loudspeakers.
The
audiophile
becomes
unified with
the ambient
space."
The
Big Combo is
simply Drop
Dead Gorgeous!
I could run a
lot of bull,
like
"palpable"
this (which it
is) and
"detailed"
that (which it
is also). I
could run up
and down the
audible
frequency
spectrum
praising the
highs and lows
and the rich
midrange. All
of that you
can take for
granted with
The Big Combo.
Rather,
I find my
attention
drifting to
each recording
I play and I
am transported
to the time,
milieu, and
message of the
music. That is
as it should
be. But my
reaction
indicates to
you, the
reader, that I
can get no
extra copy
from
discussing
colorations in
the equipment.
It indicates
how truly
musical the
experience is.
It shows how
readily one
can divorce
oneself from
equipment
concerns when
the sound is
right.
There
are only two
additional
points I wish
to make on the
sound.
"Liquidity"
is a
overworked
phrase in our
lexicon. The
Zeus headphone
amp has it and
the Grado can
reproduce it.
There is no
grain, nor
etched
quality, but
liquidity is
more than
that. The Zeus
and Grado are
able to
maintain the
harmonic
integrity of
the sound,
reproducing
all the
harmonics
present in the
recording,
such that the
instruments
appear
three-dimensional.
I’ve heard
tube
amp/speaker
combinations
described as
"sweet,"
when in fact,
they are dark,
veiled, and
sweet. The
Zeus/Grado
combination is
transparent,
light,
three-dimensional,
grainless, and
has just a
touch of
sugar. The
sound is
"liquid"
in a way few
audiophiles
have heard.
"Intimacy"
is the other
concept you
need to
internalize if
you don’t
have long term
experience
with
headphones.
The audiophile
is completely
freed from the
external
environment
and finds
himself
"in"
the orchestra,
hearing detail
and nuance not
available with
loudspeakers.
The audiophile
becomes
unified with
the ambient
space.
Instrumentalists
may become
tangible
extensions of
the listener.
Mirages appear
in your mind.
You find
yourself
reaching for
piano keys,
bows, the
deliverers of
our unspoken
language. The
urge to create
flows from the
brain, down
the arms and
to the
fingers. Think
that is an
exaggeration?
Try listening
to your
favorite
recordings
with The Big
Combo and tell
me different.
The
fact is that
the only
partnership
that may
better The Big
Combo is the
Sennheiser
HE60/HEV70
electrostatic
headphones
through the
Orpheus tube
amplifier with
integrated DAC
at $14,900.

|