| The Reson Etile Moving Coil Phono
Cartridge |
|
Goldilocks, come home! Your phono
cartridge is waiting! |
| Paul Szabady |
|
August 2004 |

I hugely enjoyed listening to the
Reson Reca phono cartridge I recently reviewed
here at Stereo Times. So much so that my
interest was whetted for what other products
in the line might sound like. If a company has
the nous to produce one eminently musical
product, I’m willing to hazard that their
other products might also have the same
facility. My intuition proved overwhelmingly
correct. Whatever small quibbles I found in
the $455 Reca’s performance, were completely
eliminated by the $750 Reson Etile.
The Etile is the second to the top of Reson’s
five-cartridge line. Only the Lexe, at $2250,
is more expensive. Like all the Reson
cartridges, they are built by Goldring to
Reson spec and share the familiar Goldring
Pocan bodies. The Etile uses Goldring’s
moving-coil electrical loading and output
characteristics, as well as their stylus
guard. The Etile shares the Gyger S
line-contact stylus profile with the Reca, but
operates on the moving coil principle, thus
the stylus is not user-replaceable. Output is
medium-low at 0.5 mV and should not present
any problems with noise with any decent moving
coil phono stage or transformer. As with the
Goldring cartridges, the recommended 100-ohm
loading should be followed for optimum
results.
The $750 price point in phono cartridges seems
to be a threshold. Not only is it probably the
maximum amount most LP lovers would find
rationally defensible, but it also seems to be
the price where the trade-offs and compromises
of less expensive cartridges seem to ease.
While less expensive cartridges can produce
wonderful music, they often invoke the old
Goldilocks quandaries. I want it all just
right in a phono cartridge: rhythmic
propulsion, articulate phrasing, wide
bandwidth with tight bass and transparent
highs, vivid 3-dimensional stereo
hallucinations, grace, power, and subtlety. I
want to play air guitar, violin and krumhorn;
I want the cartridge to dance, to sing, to
cry, to moan, to soar with all the exaltation
that music provides. I want to boogie and I
want to contemplate. While there are excellent
phono cartridges in the $500 and less range
that I could happily live with (and have) –
the Reson Reca, Rega Exact, Shure V-15 V xMR,
Audio Technica AT OC9ML, Garrott Bros. Optim S
and some of the non-wooden bodied Grados come
immediately to mind – there does seem to be a
higher plateau reached at the $750 price.
That much more transparency and clarity,
that much more power and dynamics,
that much more grace, nuance and finesse,
that much more vivid and convincing a
stereo illusion. Fewer flaws. Far less
Goldilockian vacillation. And most
importantly, that much more musical
communication.
Like its moving magnet brother the Reca, the
Elite sounded pleasant out-of-the-box, making
its 20 hour or so break-in period far from
onerous. The Gyger S stylus requires careful
set-up to optimize its performance. Again, I
used the Ringmat LP Support System’s spacers
to tune the stylus angle. The Etile didn’t
seem particularly neurotic: once set up
according to standard Ringmat procedure, it
didn’t need any further tweaking after the
cartridge broke in. I’m either getting very
good at all this, or I just happened to hit
the sweet spot the first try.
I ran the Etile in 4 different turntables,
with 4 different arms: Origin Live Aurora
Gold/Illustrious arm, Linn Sondek LP12/Origin
Live RB250, Origin Live Standard Kit/OL
Silver, and the Merrill/AR with OL RB300. The
Origin Live Kit/Silver served as my basic test
mule, offering a reasonably priced means to
experience all of the Etile’s considerable
strengths. All four combinations revealed the
Etile’s wonderful rhythmic drive, dynamic
propulsion and coherent and articulate musical
phrasing. These characteristics are essential
music basics, and have been the sine qua
non of my criteria for hi-fi gear for 32
years. It still depresses me how much audio
gear is utterly incompetent at these
essentials of music; the high-priced High End
being the most criminal. Thin kihaRpo ntHistOo
m mMmuc H? (Reads: Think I
harp on this too much?)
The Etile’s frequency response is wide,
balanced and extended: no attempts to soften
or roll-off the bandwidth, nor to exaggerate
it. Bass instruments were clear and tight in
intonation, pitch and decay. As Linn used to
proclaim, the Etile plays tunes in the bass.
The high frequencies were well extended,
producing harmonic overtones in synch with
lower frequency fundamentals, thus making
instrumental timbre believable and easily
identifiable. The higher frequencies of
percussion instruments were clear and
controlled; no harsh ringing or smearing, a
characteristic of the Gyger S in all the
incarnations I’ve so far heard.
High-resolution high frequency reproduction
also guarantees coherent portrayal of the
acoustic ambience of the recording venue.
Midrange response was neutral and controlled:
vocalist’s F’s, T’s and S’s were natural, well
differentiated and without overshoot. Upper
midrange was neither flattering recessed nor
boosted and artificial. I had no quibbles with
the Elite’s frequency portrayal: it was
neither bright and etched, nor lush and
smeared. Cue Goldilocks.
Flat and extended frequency response alone
does not guarantee musical satisfaction. Fast,
accurate transient response and the ability to
accurately track changing volume levels and to
do it equally well with all the instruments
playing is the key. The Etile was superb in
these essentials of creating the musical
illusion. The Elite had no problems with any
of my acid-test records, getting both the
sound and the music right. Indeed it was
difficult to listen analytical and critically
to the sound of the Elite, its performance
being so compelling.
The stereo illusion was well portrayed; stage
width and depth both so convincingly portrayed
that I never felt disoriented or confused.
Near-field mini-monitor listening with the
Dynaudio Audience 52SE and Celestion 3
speakers was near hallucinogenic; the dipole
radiation pattern of the electrostatic Sound
Lab Dynastats more akin to the ambience of a
classical concert hall.
I can think of nothing to complain or quibble
about. The Reson Etile is a jewel of a
cartridge. Yeah, go home, Goldilocks. Time to
do some tunes! This cartridge is a must
listen.
Specifications:
Frequency response: 20Hz-30kHz ±2dB
Channel balance: 1dB max. @ 1kHz
Channel separation: 25dB min. @ 1kHz
Output: 0.5mV ±1dB@ 1kHz, 5cm/sec
Tip mass: 0.35mg
Tracking angle: 20 degrees
Stylus profile: Gyger S
Stylus type: Not user replaceable
Load resistance: 100
Cartridge weight: 5.7g
Tracking weight: 1.5 - 2g
(1.65g suggested)
Price: $750
Address:
U. S. Distributor:
Concert Sounds
PO Box 90957
San Antonio TX 78209
Email:concert@texas.net
Phone: 210-229-1111
Website:
http://cfunkjr.home.texas.net/
DNM/Reson Website:
http://www.dnm.co.uk

|