|
Harmonic
Recovery
System
by:
Source
Components
Electronic |
| No
Man is
an
Island,
Completely
unto
Himself |
|
Clement
Perry
|
|
1
July 1998 |
Specifications
Web: www.sceaudio.com/
How
often do you come
across ‘so called’
audiophiles who
claim that their
system is where they
want it and that
there is nothing out
there, amp, speaker
or tweak that’s
gonna make it sound
any better? Sort of
like the ‘been
there done that’
type! I know quite a
few folks like this,
who refuse to try
anything that might
improve their system
because of many
preconceived ideas.
The most common
symptoms of these
delusional
afflictions are
remarks such as,
"How can it
work if it only
costs $600?" or
" I heard that
unit at such and
such and I didn’t
think it sounded
good at all!"
How about,
"Yeah Perry, I
heard of the
product, but I’m
not interested in
putting it in my
system right
now.....but if you’re
not too busy later,
you should come by
because the system
is really sounding
great!" The one
that I really love
is, "Perry, I
don’t care what
you say or what the
white paper reads.
If I put that thing
between my amp and
preamp, it’s going
to mess up my
sound." One
thing I learned in
this industry is
that closed minded
views prevent you
from putting
together the system
of your dreams ‘cause
you’re doing just
that, dreaming! It
is surely no
coincidence that the
very best systems I
have heard were put
together by very
open minded folks.
It's
Not Easy Being Green
Okay,
here’s the skinny.
I am now using a
speaker cable that's
better IN MY SYSTEM
than the Goertz
silver, which is put
out by a company
called Custom House.
Their cable is
inexpensive and
something that I
simply can’t
believe is this damn
good. I’ll get you
their number in a
minute. The reason I
know why it’s
better sounding is
this: I had a number
of high end
listeners over for a
session and all
thought that my
system has never
sounded better. Yet,
not one of them
noticed that I had
changed the cable.
End of story! Now,
once you meet a guy
who can put out a
product such as
this, you wind up
calling more than
just once in a
while. So, now I’ve
got this connection
and he tells me
about a product that’s
gonna blow my socks
off. I got very
excited until he
told me how it
works. "You put
this thing after
your preamp right
before the
amp." And I
said, "Bob, I
don’t use a preamp
because I have the
Meitner BIDAT, which
has its own volume
control. Besides,
how can that thing
be better if it goes
directly into the
signal path?"
His reply was
simple. "Put it
after your dac....trust
me on this one,
please." I
finally get the unit
and was admittingly
reluctant to put
this thing after the
Meitner BIDAT
processor. I managed
to find a run of
single ended
interconnects
although I’ve
always believed that
balanced runs are
superior. I ran a
pair of excellent
Custom House
Benchmark 2’s out
of the BIDAT and
straight into the
HRS. I then ran 3
meter Benchmarks out
from the HRS
directly into the
BAT VK 1000 mono’s.
The rest of the
system is composed
of Von Schweikert
VR4.5 loudspeakers,
Z-Systems RDP-1 EQ,
Ed Meitner’s BIDAT
DAC (w/ built in
preamp) and
Transport
combination, and
Tekna Sonic
Vibrations Devices
(C10 & C12’s)
on VR4.5’s.
Digital cable from
the Meitner
transport to the
RDP-1 is Illuminati
D-60 and out of the
Z into the BIDAT is
NBS, power cords are
Custom House
Benchmark on the
amps and Electra
Glide on digital.
All digital
components rest on
Seismic Sinks, which
in turn, rest on
Symposium Roller
Balls. The shelf is
particular and all
amplification
including the HRS
rests upon
Tranquillity Bases.
This room is treated
with ASC and Echo
Busters room
treatments. All my
evaluations were
done in single ended
mode. Here are my
impressions...
Where
Were You When I
Needed You?
Once
the system was ready
for this evaluation,
I pulled out a Keith
Jarrett "Live
at the Blue Note"
(ECM 78118-21575-2).
This is one of the
best box sets
available for the
jazz lover. Disc
three is an absolute
killer that appears
to be on its way to
becoming legendary,
particularly in the
New York audio
societies. First, I
played track five
entitled "When
I fall in
Love", which
features Gary
Peacock on bass and
Jack DeJohnette on
drums. Well, I’ve
played it a number
of times and I know
how it should have
sounded on my
system. In a minute
I said to myself,
"give me a
break." My
first thoughts
jotted down on a
piece of paper read;
cleaner highs,
better focus,
incredible widening
of stage, blacker
background, more
vivid presentation.
Out of the box, this
device sounded as if
someone had placed a
magnifying glass to
my system, bringing
everything clearly
into focus from a
seemingly
subterranean level.
But I knew that it
still needed a major
break-in because the
bass was now ill
defined and bloated,
as if the HRS
brought out more
information but at a
cost. Gary Peacocks’
bass plucking
sounded less
articulate. I didn’t
sense the intimate
finger motion that
was so apparent on
the recording prior
to placing the HRS
in line.
Transparency also
took a step back,
although I expected
that to happen. But
what did you expect
right out of the
box? Still, I was
very impressed by
its quality of
tonality in the
treble and midrange
which was enough to
warrant a very
positive impression
and proper break-in.
As the Purist
Burn-In CD spun for
the next few days, I
placed some
important phone
calls to many of my
serious, ‘open
minded’ audio
associates. My very
close and dear
friends from the New
York Audiophile
Society should
definitely give this
product a listen. I
explained to them
that this unit seems
to be all that its
advertisers claim it
to be and that they
should audition it
for themselves
exactly how I tested
it; see if the HRS
does the same exact
thing in your
systems too! But
first I had to be
sure that the
break-in does what
its manufacturers
claim it should do,
which is to take it
to another level. We
shall see.
Burn
Baby Burn
While
patiently waiting
for the 100/150 hour
burn-in, I decided
to give the company
a call. A friendly
voice answered the
phone by the name of
John. He was way too
nice to have
anything to do with
the company besides
marketing or sales.
But surprise,
surprise. John (with
the pleasant voice),
is one of their
designers. After
dispensing with the
pleasantries, we got
down to business. In
his discussion, it
was known to me that
this device was
originally slated
for life as a
preamp, with plenty
of emphasis on
simplicity and
nothing more. Well,
a funny thing
happened while
making this product.
With the addition of
any switches,
attenuator knobs, or
buttons, there was a
definite impact on
the sound quality.
Each piece used
seemed to get in the
way of what they
were determined to
create, the purist
sounding preamp you’ll
never hear! I found
this very intriguing
for someone like
myself who comes
from this same
purist approach. I
got a warm feeling
inside when I
realized that
without any
switches, knobs or
buttons, I finally
received the perfect
preamp for my
system!
The
HRS is internally a
work of art! The
ultra high-quality
resistors and
capacitors are of
the best in the lot.
These are employed
in only two gain
stages, and in
addition, all wiring
is point to point.
Most unusual is the
non-utilization of a
power switch (the
first sample came
equipped with one.
Let me be the first
to say that there is
a difference between
the two units)
Output impedance is
150 ohms with an
additional 3db of
gain. For anyone who
thinks that this is
too much and that it
would clip their
amp, don’t fret,
they make a version
that has zero output
impedances too. And
for anyone who owns
tube amps, they also
have units with 1000
ohm output
impedances
available.
Apparently, they’ve
designed this unit
to fit every nut in
the business.
Reading the theory
behind the unit
suggests that it
recovers lost
information that is
somehow lost during
the recording. I
consider this far
fetched, but decided
to listen first
before I made any
more assumptions
because one thing is
certain, IT DOES
WORK! This whole
topic whetted my
whistle. With the
burn-in time
required now quickly
approaching, I
decided to do some
listening.
Second
Time Around
After
turning the unit on
for a few minutes,
it dawned on me to
give it the best
chance of really
coming to life. Out
went that terrible
stock power cord and
in went the Electra
Glide Reference AC
Line Cord. This, my
friend, is a
declaration of war
on poor AC. Shall we
begin some serious
listening? The first
CD to make it into
the Meitner
Transport (sorry
guys it’s much
better than the
Sony!) was "Exotic
Dances from the
Opera" (Ejji
Oue/Minnesota
Orchestra Reference
Recordings HDCD
RR-71CD). I am
always enchanted by
track 1 "Dances
Of The Tumblers from
The Snow
Maiden". Upon
listening to the
first few notes, I
immediately
understood more of
what was going on in
this recording than
during previous
listening sessions.
Something quite
strange was
happening to me, a
feeling as though
someone slipped some
vinyl into the
system. Yeah, that’s
right, somehow the
HRS seems to convey
a feeling of
righteousness that’s
very reminiscent of
vinyl. You sense a
very low noise floor
and hear spacial
qualities that I’ve
never before
encountered with
digital. Moreover,
there appeared to be
much more cohesion
to everything.
Everyone was playing
more together.
Strings, for
instance, took on a
tonality that was
unfamiliar. They
seemed to gather
momentum. There
seemed to be a
righteousness that I
never before sensed
or noticed, a unison
of image specificity
that had long
alluded me. It’s
quite a sobering
achievement
considering what I
thought of the sound
before the HRS was
installed, which by
the way was quite
good! The greatest
gift I received by
putting the HRS in
the system was the
way in which the Von
Schweikert VR 4.5’s
went to another
level. I love these
speakers but I am
aware of their
limitations. They
lack focus compared
to the best point
source monitors. I
alluded to this
quality in my review
for The Audiophile
Voice. This aspect
was greatly
corrected with the
HRS. It makes these
babies focus like
real point source
loudspeakers. This
discovery now leads
me to believe that
Albert Von
Schweikert was right
all the time about
how well they focus.
I was unable to
achieve this result
until the HRS came
on the scene. The
other problem I
encountered before
proper burn
regarding the bass
had now disappeared.
The bass now took on
a very contoured and
textured quality
that again, sounded
very natural. There
appeared to be an
added presence of
the lower extended
bass due to much
quieter passages.
Images appeared to
come from a jet
black background
lending a greater
sense of detail. I
was particularly
impressed by the
"Exotic
Dances" CD.
Because of this very
quite and black
backdrop, the
performance gained a
greater sense of
three
dimensionality.
Again, the
naturalness of the
HRS was immediately
noticeable
throughout this
evaluation,
regardless of the
CD.
End
of Story
Okay,
I guess you think
that I really like
this unit. You got
that right! I
personally think
that this unit may
change what most
analog lovers always
hated about digital,
that very antiseptic
and sterile sound (
I personally don’t
agree with, then
again I don’t
listen to analog
either).
I
guess this device
was designed to get
us closer to the
original recording.
I believe that they
have accomplished
this in many
significant ways
that are important
to the discerning
audiophile.
Regardless of the
cost of your system,
this unit must be
auditioned. It is
simply that good.
Highly recommended!

|